Like a Good Neighbor, State Farm is There With a Helping Hand and a Hatchet

Image courtesy of

Harry writes in a tale of what he describes as extortion by State Farm Insurance.

Harry writes in a tale of what he describes as extortion by State Farm Insurance.

State Farm was going to raise his housing deductible by 150% as he only had a single line of insurance with them. Thinking quick, Harry figured out how to side-step the rate hike without switching over his Progressive car insurance as well, though not without paying a price…

Full story after the jump…

I got a post card from my State Farm agent the other day. It said, “Please call us about a matter concerning your homeowner’s insurance.” I spoke to a very nice lady at the agent’s office who told me that State Farm was going to be instituting a change in my policy when it came up for renewal next June. This change only affected “single line” insureds, in other words, people who only used one of State Farm’s insurance lines. Personally, I use Progressive to insure my car, and State Farm on my house, because, well, I did the math and it was cheaper than having State Farm insure my cars.

The change which is going to affect single line insureds (at least those of us in Missouri) is that, instead of our current deductible (mine is $1000), SF would increase our deductible to one percent of the value of the property. Thus, my deductible would be increased to, approximately $2600. I would get the “benefit” of an approximately $100 decrease in my yearly premium.

“Wow,” I said to the agent. “That’s a big increase in potential out-of-pocket. If I had two unrelated losses in one year, we’re up over $5,000.”

“Yes,” she said. “But you could keep the $1000 deductible if you weren’t a single line insured.”
“I’m pretty happy with my auto insurer. What other lines does SF have?”
“We have life insurance, health insurance and we have several investment vehicles that would count as another line.”
“Investment vehicles?
“Yes. We have money market funds, mutual funds, even a savings account.”
“Okay,” I said, (and here’s where the Consumerist Cynic in me began to blossom), “if I’m the cheapest S.O.B on the planet, and I didn’t want to bother switching insurance companies, what would you suggest I do?”
“Our savings account has a minimum balance of $100. If you opened one of those, it would be sufficient for you to be considered as a multiple-line insured.”

“I see. So basically, I pay State Farm $100, and they don’t unilaterally increase my deductible by over 150 percent. Fine. Please go ahead and set me up for a savings account, mail me the application, and just let me know where I need to send the extortion money.”

I want to clarify that I actually appreciate that my agent gave me the heads up on this. It’s State Farm corporate which came up with this great money-saving / money-making idea.

But me, calling it extortion, that’s the Consumerist in me talking.


Good job, Harry!

Want more consumer news? Visit our parent organization, Consumer Reports, for the latest on scams, recalls, and other consumer issues.