Game Consoles, Dolls And Wooden Dogs Are The Best Toys Ever

Did you play with a Slinky growing up? Well, that makes you a loser, because your toy didn’t make Good Housekeeping‘s Yahoo list of the greatest toys ever made.

Winners include my full-time childhood caretaker, the Nintendo Entertainment System, the creepy stalker known as Furby and adorable, overfed Cabbage Patch Kids.

There’s even room for a weird dog on wheels that used to please kids of the 1920s, back before fun was invented. But no Slinky, because it lacked dog, wood, wheels and the ability to play Tecmo Bowl.

Them, of course, be debatin’ words. So let’s have it, commenters — what’s your favorite toy ever?

The Best Toys of All Time [Yahoo, via Kotaku]
(Photo: Yahoo)


Edit Your Comment

  1. donnie5 says:

    Lincoln Logs.
    It took me four years to get them, and I barely wanted them when I did get them. After playing with them for hours on end, I must say, they were my favorite. You could use them with hot wheels cars, G.I. Joes, tonka, Marvel Comics toys, etc.

  2. cabjf says:

    But how many are in the National Toy Hall of Fame?


  3. MostlyHarmless says:

    My mom’s mind. It fries real easy, and I love deep fried treats. Yeah, I’m a sadist.

  4. sir_pantsalot says:

    I loved my lawn darts as a kid. It was so cool to throw more than one at a time and watch them fly side by side like jets in formation. Then they would all stick into the ground right next to each other. I can see why they would not want to put them on the list.

    • Platypi {Redacted} says:

      @sir_pantsalot: Agreed. And then they went and outlawed the metal tipped “darts of death”. I LOVED how they stuck in the ground, it made you feel like a knife thrower or something.
      Seriously, playing with the round plastic lawn darts is so lame you might as well chuck bean bags! Luckily, I still have my illegal set from when I was a kid!

      • caveman1428 says:

        @Platypi: doubly agreed…for some reason there was never a more satisfying sounds than that thhbbt they all made when they came back to earth. pops used to throw them all up at once and yell SCATTER!! ah good times..

      • Whtthfgg says:

        @Platypi: I had one land in my eye when I was young…..yes, Im one of the idiots. Both my eyes still work…musta gotten lucky

    • The Cynical Librarian says:

      @sir_pantsalot: I was always a huge fan of the darwinian experiment of chucking the dart straight into the air as hard as you can and then running for your life.
      /grew up in a small town.

  5. Phil Keeps It Real [Consumerist] says:

    Wow I can tell this article/post will put many people in a time machine. I will reminisce, quietly, in the corner here. (Feelin’ warm).

  6. Trance1861 says:

    I had a dog on wheels (it was plastic though…. made by fisher price in the 80s). I thought it was AMAZING, until I got my parents to get me a real dog by refusing to potty train until they did. Suckers.

  7. LightningUsagi says:

    I’ve got to disagree with the Dreamcast being on the list. Yes, it’s a great system, and I still have mine along with copies of SC5 and JGR, but I don’t think it was nearly as popular as the Playstation. Having worked in a toy store during the 1997 holiday season, I can tell you that thing was insanely hard to keep in stock.

    I received most of my gaming systems for holidays, so I can’t really pick which was the best, but I have more memories of playing my Genesis than any of the other ones I received as a kid.

  8. h3llc4t, breaker of office dress codes says:

    I refuse to lend this list any credence because it does not include these.

  9. chocobo says:

    The NES, easily. Everything else I played with for a month or two at most, the Nintendo I played for a decade.

    After that, sports related stuff like a basketball or tennis racket certainly got the most use. I remember being really excited over Transformers or a remote control car, but I didn’t play with them for long before I got tired of it. The best toys are the ones with lasting appeal, not just a new fun gimmick.

  10. LandruBek says:

    True to my era, I guess, I gotta go with Lego. Mostly to build spaceships, as I recall. The fancy Technical Lego with the gears and shafts and linkages came out when I was just the right age to enjoy, too. Those little bricks are the perfect fuel for a little person’s imagination.

  11. boobookitteh says:

    Hot Wheels! And the little plastic Army guys. And Silly Putty.

    There’s a Saturday afternoon for you.

    • floraposte says:

      @boobookitteh: Silly Putty was the one toy my otherwise nonjudgmental parents forbade. I believe my mother had had some savage cleanup trauma with it.

      My brother had army guys. They were good for placement in Lincoln Log forts that were then destroyed by the attack of other army guys.

    • Whtthfgg says:

      @boobookitteh: Am I the only one that remembers stompers?? those things rocked!!

  12. TakingItSeriously is a Technopile says:

    Legos Legos Legos, and more Legos

    Once I was 12 it was my BB gun

  13. korybing says:

    Wait wait wait wait.

    Sega Dreamcast? Honestly? I love my Dreamcast but I would no way be putting it up with the best toys ever, especially since that was the system that kicked Sega out of the console market.

    My favorite toys as a kid included K’Nex, Aliens, TMNT, He-Man, Ghostbusters, and Littlest Pet Shop. What, I had to have at least a couple girly toys. Oh also Lego Dragons.

    • pop top says:

      @korybing: Your childhood sounds almost exactly like mine, down to the toys even. I still have some of my original Littlest Pet Shop stuff. They look so much better than the bug-eyed, big headed crap out now.

      • korybing says:

        @squinko: Oh man the Littlest Petshop stuff today is just heartbreaking to see. Does it even do all the cool stuff the old toys did? My whole reason for liking the old sets were because they did clever things with magnets and whatever. These new ones just look like Bratz versions of pets.

        I was also really into My Little Ponies, but mostly because they were the perfect size for my TMNT guys to ride on into battle.

        • pop top says:

          @korybing: Holy shit, are you me? I loved My Little Ponies! I don’t remember ever combining them with TMNT though. That sounds awesome. I don’t believe the new Littlest Pet Shop does anything cool. My favorite pets were the hamsters because they had a freaking wheel!

    • lilyHaze says:

      @korybing: I coveted the K’Nex. It was super expensive when it came out, and my best friend got one. In late middle school/early high school, she got the awesome roller coaster set. At 100 or so dollars, it was too rich for me even thinking about asking my parents for one.

      • korybing says:

        @lilyHaze: One of my big Christmas presents as a kid was the K’Nex Big Ball Factory. It was 5 feet of complete awesomeness and I spent three days straight and suffered a week of sore thumbs putting the thing together. I kept it up in my room for years afterwards and decorated it with Gargoyles and Aliens (facehuggers fit nicely around K’Nex pieces, I had discovered). I also used K’Nex to build several of my Halloween costumes. I got way more use out of them than I ever got out of Legos. Loved them!

  14. floraposte says:

    I actually found the Slinky rather tedious. You watched it coil, then get caught in itself in a way from which you could never extricate it. Whee.

    I liked the buildy toys like Lincoln Logs, Tinker Toys, and Legos, but I played the crap out of my wee battery-operated organ with colored keys, and I wore down to the fake dirt my little farmscapes with miniature barns and animals. (Seriously cute baby lambs.) Probably the all-time winner, though, was a toy travel trailer. Built with the solidity of a Tonka truck, sized for dollhouse stuff (I loved the furniture, but it was the animals who lived in it, because people were boring), so probably close to 2 feet long. Amazing I never attacked my brother with it.

  15. GMFish says:

    Best toys for young kids: Giant cardboard boxes, markers, and masking tape. You can get all of that real cheap at Uhaul and it’ll keep the kids entertained for days.

    • pecan 3.14159265 says:

      @GMFish: Also, unused furniture. At my grandma’s old house, no one used the dining room so I took over and made the entire room my fort. I would sleep there almost an entire summer.

  16. dbshaw says:

    When playing ‘superfriends’ whoever was Aquaman would use a slinky for communicating with fish by holding it to their forehead with one hand and saying ‘doo doo doo doo doo’ in a high-pitched voice and extending the other end out with their other hand.

  17. tchann says:

    …does my backyard count?

  18. econobiker says:

    My family was so poor that twelve children had only one toy to share…
    It was a little wooden car…
    And it was broken – it only had three wheels…
    And those wheels were square…
    Imagine 12 children fighting over a little wooden car that only went “chunk,tah, chunk,tah, chunk,tah” when you tried to push it around…

    But we never, ever got to play with it when our mother had to tenderize possum or raccoon meat that she was lucky enough to find on the roadside…

    Afterward it was even a more special treat for us children to lick the little wooden car off…

  19. Verucalise (Est.February2008) says:


  20. pinecone99 says:

    Fisher Price Adventure People!!!! yeah, Legos were cool, too. Otherwise the best toys were the ones I made myself.

  21. jhuang says:

    What about Easy-Bakes, Radio Flyers (I had a Radio Flyer horse too!), those red slide projector clicky things, pogs, Tamagotchis…. I was just saying yesterday how kids’ toys today just don’t measure up.

    • h3llc4t, breaker of office dress codes says:

      @jhuang: I loved the Creepy Crawlers Maker (basically an Easy-Bake Oven that made critters out of goop instead of baked cakes out of goop). I think they might even still make them.

      • floraposte says:

        @h3llc4t, breaker of office dress codes: No, Creepy Crawlers got a lot hotter than the Easy-Bake Oven did. Bare hot metal on flesh–fabulousness!

        We also had Incredible Edibles, which were basically Creepy Crawlers made out of nominally edible materials. I think you can still see them on my MRIs.

  22. Darkneuro says:

    I was the Slinky untangler in our household. Love the things. I still have my favorite doll (1973 Tender Love by Mattel). Mom still has my Tonka trucks from when they were made of metal and so much more fun than the plastic ones.

  23. backbroken says:

    6 words…

    Mill En Ee Um – Fal Kin

  24. Pink Puppet says:

    I was all about the TMNT. They lived together in a glorious four foot tall pink plastic dollhouse that I wired with Christmas lights. (I wasn’t trusted with the hobby knife at the time, so running wires needed adult assistance.) Throw in some Legos and Play-doh to trick it out a bit more, and I had the perfect turtle lair to defend against the evil Shredder.

  25. YouDidWhatNow? says:

    Hello! Lawn darts! Duh! And BB guns! Firecrackers! And other things that involve matches!

  26. dbshaw says:

    Well you know, it gets boring at the office, we have to amuse ourselves some how.

  27. B says:

    When I was in school, my class was asked to write an essay on “the greatest gift I received” Everybody else did stuff like honesty, love, etc. My answer was my NES. And I stand by that choice.

  28. H3ion says:

    Lionel trains, Erector sets and Radio Flyer wagons. Everything else was just fluff.

  29. ageshin says:

    Lionel trains, and books.

  30. coren says:




    Really? I mean, furby? Creepiest toy, lamest toy, but greatest of all time? Fuck. That.