Consumer Groups To Obama: Please Put Someone With A Brain In Charge Of The CPSC

There’s been a lot of talk lately about how the upcoming implementation of the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA). The law requires that all children’s products be tested for lead and has caused a major freak out amongst librarians (who don’t really want to test their books for lead, or ban children from the library) and thrift stores (who can’t afford to test used toys for lead). Apparently, according to consumer groups that support the bill, the CPSC is supposed to be monitoring this situation and adding exceptions as needed, but has been ignoring the issue. Now those groups are asking President Obama for a change of leadership within the CPSC. Read their letter inside.

Just a little background: The CPSC is currently being run by Acting Chair, Nancy Nord, a Bush appointee who took over the agency after Bush nominee and former manufacturing industry lobbyist Michael Baroody bailed just one day before a scheduled Senate confirmation hearing. It was speculated at the time that Baroody didn’t want to discuss his $150,000 severance bonus from his employer, the National Association of Manufacturers.

Consumer Federation of America, Consumers Union, Kids in Danger National Consumers League, National Research Center for Women & Families, Public Citizen and the U.S. Public Interest Research Group write:

January 30, 2009

The President of the United States

The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Ave, NW
Washington, DC 20500

Dear President Obama:

As leaders of organizations dedicated to protecting consumers from the hazards posed by unsafe products, we are writing to urge you to move quickly to put in place new leadership at the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC).

As you know, the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA) was signed into law on August 14, 2008, after many months of discussion, multiple hearings, and input from stakeholders. The law was passed in both chambers by huge bipartisan margins: 89-3 in the Senate and 424-1 in the U.S. House of Representatives.

The bipartisan CPSIA makes consumer products safer by requiring, for the first time, that toys and infant products be tested for safety before they are sold, and by banning lead and phthalates in toys. The law also creates the first comprehensive publicly-accessible consumer complaint database, authorizes for the CPSC the resources it needs to protect the public, increases civil penalties that CPSC can assess against violators of laws, and protects whistleblowers who report product safety defects. This law is a strong, effective and much-needed solution to the persistent problems plaguing our product safety system.

Unfortunately, the current CPSC leadership, which is responsible for implementing this critical new law, has delayed taking the necessary steps to ensure its successful implementation. As a result, the agency has not properly addressed concerns being raised by small businesses, home crafters, thrift stores, book publishers, and libraries among others. These concerns involve, for example, establishing common-sense exclusions from lead testing for textiles and paper-based books that are proven to be lead-free, component part testing where appropriate for lead and phthalates, and clear guidance for thrift stores. This did not have to be the case. The CPSIA already includes mechanisms for solving these legitimate concerns raised by these groups in a manner that protects the public health.

As a result, this has created a climate of confusion and is contributing to broader efforts to undermine consumer safety in this nation. Effective leadership at the CPSC is urgently needed to help implement the law as intended, to provide common sense interpretations of the law, and to clarify pervasive misstatements and confusion about this consumer protective law.

Nominating a new Chairman of the CPSC is critical. The Chairman has direct command and control over all the nonpolitical career staff and all of the scientific, enforcement and communications apparatus of the Agency. The Chairman sets the agenda, directs the policies executed by the Agency, and manages the distribution of the Agency’s resources. All of the offices and directorates of the Commission report to the Chair, either directly or through the office of the Executive Director. In addition, quick action is necessary is because the current acting chair remains in that position until a new nominee is confirmed.

As you know, the CPSC has been underfunded and understaffed for too long. We urge you to move expeditiously to nominate a strong chairperson to the CPSC with product safety expertise who can implement the critical new product safety law and begin to tackle the myriad of issues facing this agency.


Stephen Brobeck Jim Guest
Executive Director President
Consumer Federation of America Consumers Union

Nancy Cowles Sally Greenberg
Executive Director Executive Director
Kids in Danger National Consumers League

Dr. Diana Zuckerman Joan Claybrook
President President
National Research Center for Women Public Citizen
& Familie

Executive Director
U.S. Public Interest Research Group

Rahm Emanuel
Don Gips
Jim Messina
Phil Schiliro

Meanwhile, this guy is introducing legislation that aims to delay the bill until it can be rewritten so that it balances “the need for safety with a common-sense business approach.”

Letter from coalition of consumer groups to President Obama [CR]
Congress Must Keep Overreaching Consumer Products Safety Improvement Act From Harming Small Businesses, Families [Jim DeMint]

Want more consumer news? Visit our parent organization, Consumer Reports, for the latest on scams, recalls, and other consumer issues.