Amazon Takes Page Out Of Kafka, Puts Seller Account ‘Under Review’ And Won’t Explain Why

Having the ability to sell items in the Amazon Marketplace is a great opportunity for individuals with just a few items to get rid of. That’s the case for Allan: he’s sold a total of three items, ever. Amazon arbitrarily put a hold on his account before he sold the third one, meaning that he can’t get money from his sales for as long as a month and a half. How can he fix this? What did he do wrong? To find out, he’d have to penetrate Amazon’s bureaucracy.

He writes:

I am a private individual seller on I have sold 3 items to date, with no seller complaints whatsoever. My account standing as of this writing is at 100%.

On 1/9/13, at 2:25 pm EST, literally one minute before my third sale, I received an email from Amazon stating that my account was under review and that my funds would be withheld until the review was completed, which could be anywhere from 30-45 days. The email did not specifically state why my account was flagged; it only provided steps I could take to shorten the time the review would take.

After following those instructions (via an appeal), I received another email from a different department (instead of merchant-approval, now seller-support) asking for the very same information I just sent. After calling the seller performance department, I was informed that yet another (third) department was responsible for the account hold, so it is out of their hands. During this call, I was also told to resubmit all the information again.

It is now seven days into the review, and I still do not know specifically why my account is on hold, in spite of my high ratings as a seller. Amazon mentioned that I should try to get feedback from my buyers. The first customer provided feedback right away. The second never did, even after persistent prodding. The third – we’ll see, since his product arrived today (I have a FedEx tracking number and checked that he did sign for it). I spend extra money using FedEx (not UPS or standard mail) to make sure that whatever I’m selling arrives in tact. I go the extra mile, so I am at a loss right now. I cannot force the second customer to provide feedback. I did the best that I could in terms of communicating with him in writing. Even Amazon’s policies forbid the use of coercion to pry feedback out of customers. I was previously satisfied with Amazon, but now I am quite disillusioned with the way I am being treated.

We’re usually critical of companies’ methods of coaxing positive feedback out of their customers, but if Amazon punishes sellers (even micro-sellers) for not getting feedback, it’s no surprise that some companies resort to bribing their customers.

Hey, Amazon, Your Marketplace Sellers Are Customers Too

Want more consumer news? Visit our parent organization, Consumer Reports, for the latest on scams, recalls, and other consumer issues.