Payday Lender To Pay $19 Million For Robo-Signed Collections & Overcharged Servicemembers

Last week, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau took a big step toward reining in irresponsible, predatory lenders by taking its first enforcement action against a large payday loan operation accused of robo-signing court documents related to debt-collection lawsuits, illegally overcharging military servicemembers and their families, and trying to cover these actions up by destroying documents before the CFPB could investigate.

ROBO-SIGNING; IT’S NOT JUST FOR FORECLOSURES
While the term “robo-signing” has mostly been associated with mortgage servicers who hired untrained people to rubber-stamp foreclosure documents without even knowing what the documents were, it also happens in the debt-collection business, where folks have been known to affirm that all the documentation tied to a collections lawsuit is legitimate without having even reviewed it.

And according to CFPB, the debt-collection subsidiary of one of the nation’s largest payday lenders, Cash America, spent the better part of five years preparing, executing, and notarizing documents filed in its Ohio collections litigations without complying with state and court-required signature rules. Specifically, the company was accused of stamping attorney signatures on legal pleadings, military-status affidavits, and consumer account paperwork without prior review.

In total, around 14,000 people ended up paying money as a result of debt collection litigation that may have relied on improper court filings.

OVERCHARGING THOSE WHO SERVE
As we’ve written before, just because the Military Lending Act sets interest rates caps on loans to servicemembers and effectively bans the issuing of payday loans to active-duty military personnel doesn’t mean some payday lenders won’t find a way.

And unlike some of the clever tactics taken by other short-term lenders who have figured out loopholes in the MLA, the CFPB says Cash America simply made hundreds of illegal payday loans to servicemembers and their spouses.

COVERING YOUR TRAIL
One way to not get in good with the new regulator on the block: Destroy documents and evidence that might be helpful in that regulator’s examination of your records.

The CFPB says that’s exactly what happened during a routine examination of Cash America in 2012. According to the agency, Cash America’s payday subsidiary Enova not only instructed employees to limit the information they provided to inspectors about the company’s sales and marketing pitches, but also deleted recorded phone calls with consumers, shredded documents and continued to do so even after the CFPB told them to stop, and withheld a report related to the company’s robo-signing practices.

THE PAYDAY PAYBACK
Cash America will pay out $14 million in refunds to consumers affected by the alleged violations. It has already repaid $6 million of that amount. The remaining $8 million will be given to people who affected by debt-collection lawsuits in Ohio between 2009 to January 2013. If you fall into that category, there is more information available at this link.

On top of the $14 million in refunds, Cash America will pay a $5 million fine for its attempt to destroy evidence and documents.

“This action brings justice to the Cash America customers who were affected by illegal robo-signing, and shows that we will vigilantly protect the consumer rights that servicemembers have earned,” said CFPB Director Richard Cordray in a statement. “We are also sending a clear message today to all companies under our watch that impeding a CFPB exam by destroying documents, withholding records, and instructing employees to mislead examiners is unacceptable.”

Read Comments3

Edit Your Comment

  1. CzarChasm says:

    While all business takes advantage of people to some extent, these places go way beyond, deliberately targeting the most desperate. It’s no wonder that it’s not allowed in several states, they should be banned outright.

  2. Pacer says:

    Well, 19 million looks like a lot but it may be a fraction of this company’s profits during those five years. I would like to see some really punitive fines.

    • PhillyDom says:

      Cash America’s net income from 2009 to 2012 totaled $456 million, so $19 million is less than 4.2% of that.