Share:
Add to Favorites   |  

The Really Big Guide To Secret Menu Items

203611 views

Not content ordering from the menu? Need to have that extra little bit of class that comes from "knowing the chef"?

Here it is, your guide to secret menu items. Sure, it's not the secret rib eye at Nobu, but it's something. Before reading this please note that this article has not been fact-checked. This report is based purely on reader suggestions. We are posting them entirely without confirmation and are not going to try to order any of this crap in order to confirm its existence. We would die of heart disease, be broke, and our ass would be the size of Texas. This is the internet, the internet is not fact-checked, and these are your secret menu items. Enjoy.



Taco Bell: Everything Taco Bell makes is comprised of a few basic ingredients, so they'll likely make anything they have the stuff for, which is probably pretty much anything they've ever served. Examples to attempt: Cheesy Gordita Crunch, Cheesy Fiesta Potatoes, Encharito.

Wendy's: A tipster tells us, "order a "Grand Slam", It would otherwise be called a Classic Quadruple, were it on the menu." Reader bringafajita suggests trying to get a "Quarter Pound Double Stack with Cheese." FishingCrue tells us to try "Everything" (lettuce and tomato) on a Wendy's Double Stack, sometimes it's even free. If they look at you like you're crazy, tell them there's a button for it. A double stack with everything, add bacon is a decent sandwich for somewhere south of 2 bones."

Chipotle: Chipotle will, like Taco Bell, make anything they have the ingredients for. Unlike Taco Bell, this is an official policy. Some suggestions: Nachos, Quesadilla, Individual Tacos, Taco Salads, Tiny Bean Burritos Using Taco Shells, Fresh Cilantro on Your Tacos, whatever you can think of.

Subway: Subway will still make the "pizza sub," and many other former menu items. Also, they can't sell "broken cookies," so they may give you some for free.

Jamba Juice: Jamba has an entire secret menu of "unhealthy" smoothies named after things that would involve copyright violations were they to be included on the menu. The ones we know of:White Gummi Bear, Red Gummi Bear, Green Gummi Bear, Raspberry Dreamin', Pineapple Dreamin', Sourpatch Kid, Tropical Tango, Pacific Passion, Berry Depressing, Now and Later, Peanut Butter and Jelly, Apple Pie, Fruity Pebbles, Rainbow Sherbet, Strawberry Shortcake, Push Pop, Skittles, Andres' Surprise, and Lemonade Lightnin'. (Thanks,ronaldscott!)
100100.jpg
In-N-Out Burger: Has their "secret" menu posted on their website, but a tipster writes in: "Not only can you get an animal style burger but you can also get animal style fries which are amazing. It's fries piled with onions, cheese and sauce and they come with a fork." In addition, we hear several voices calling from the mist, whispering that the secret menu doesn't stop at 4 x 4., but may, in fact, go on to infinity. Or at least to 100 x 100...
(Thanks, xapplexjuicex!)

Starbucks: Starbucks will make you absolutely anything you want no matter how insane it is, according to our tipster.

"Baristas might try and tell their customers that no, we can't do that with the blenders. This is a lie. Starbucks corporate policy is that the customer is ALWAYS right (even when the request is stupid). If you really insist that you want your iced soy latte blended, the baristas HAVE to do it. If they continue to refuse, ask to speak to a manager and either they'll realize they're about to get in trouble and will fill your request, or the manager will come out and politely tell the barista to make the customer happy.

Absolutely any concoction that you can think of (involving any type of milk, syrup, coffee, etc.) will be made for you. The limits to Starbucks "secret menu" are merely the limits of your imagination. You can even bring supplements from home and ask the barista to please include that in your drink."
Well, damn.

Dairy Queen: Reader Falconfire says: "I couldn't even begin to tell you the list of Dairy Queen secret menu items. Lets put it this way, there is a huge book every DQ has to have, you want it, it's in there. It may not be listed as a item, but the instruction on how to make it and what to use are in there as well as how it is rung up. About the only thing they cant make is seasonal items, since they usually require a ingredient not carried normally."

Chili's: According to Reader Elara, they no longer have chili on the menu (what?) but if you ask them, they'll bring you a cup.

Blimpie: Attention veggie-lovers: Reader VeryFancyBunny says: "Blimpie used to have a sandwich called the "Cheese Trio" on the menu. They took it off years ago (at least around here), but I've been able to order it with no problem. Otherwise, all their sandwiches involve meat."

Burger King: Try the "mustard whopper," a whopper with mustard rather than mayo, from Reader dwneylonsr, and the "veggie whopper" from VeryFancyBunny, which is just a whopper with the meat omitted. Reader sixtoe suggests attempting to get the "Bull's-Eye BBQ Burger."

Popeye's: mullenite suggests ordering the "Naked Chicken," which is chicken with no breading. Sounds very Atkins.

TGIFriday's: Readers junkmail and mullenite tell us that TGIF have a "Five Easy Pieces" policy that says they'll make anything you want with the crap they've got in the kitchen.

Denny's: Speaking of Five Easy Pieces, Reader weave says: "Don't expect a secret menu at Denny's. I went in there and asked for a grilled cheese sandwich and they were baffled. They finally decided to give me Moons over My Hammy and toss out the ham -- and charge me the full price for it." Did she hold the ham between her knees?

and finally, at Arby's: sixtoe likes the "French Dip."

Thanks to everyone for sharing their knowledge of the wild and woolly world of nationwide chain restaurants. You are the heroes. Let your indigestion be a mark of your bravery.

Did we forget something? If you'd like to suggest an item for this guide, email tips [at] consumerist [dot] com. Put "Secret Menu" in the subject.
—MEGHANN MARCO

(Photo: cogdogblog)

This is a test using rich text formatting and html links. It's the generic "company" ad that should appear on all posts with the Company category if they don't have an ad attached to a specific company.

Post a comment

Comments:

132
user-pic

Ooh, mentioning Starbucks reminded me. I used to be friends with a barista at a Barnes and Noble Coffee shop (those are operated by Starbucks now, I believe). He used to blend chocolate biscottis into our frappachinos, which was way tastier than the normal mocha frappachinos. If you ask the barista, he or she will do it for you for the cost of the biscotti.

user-pic

How DARE you! I wake up in New York to read this only to now be controlled by a need to procure In-N-Out. I am seriously considering getting on a plane right now, or paying my mom to fed-ex me some. Bah!

user-pic

Red Robin used to have "petite" burgers on their menu. They don't anymore, but you can still order them. Useful for when you're not THAT hungry!

user-pic

Somewhere on the interwebs there is a photo chronicle of odering a 100x100 at an In-n-Out. I'm too lazy to look it up, but it does exist.

user-pic

Unless things have changed at Popeyes in the past seeral months or so, the naked chicken strips are by no means "secret," they're right there on the menu above the cashiers.

user-pic

@muddgirl: Nope, BN cafe only serves Starbucks Coffee but they are not run by Starbucks Corp.

The Starbucks thing is true and same thing goes for BN Cafe. However here the thing, we charge for "extra" so if you want that extra syrup in whatever crazy drink you want us to make, beware.

I so wish we had a Jamba Juice here. We only have Smoothie King which is close enough.

user-pic

When this story broke last week about Jamba, I went striaght down there to try the Pink Star, and he totally knew what it was, and it was oh so very good. I am so happy with my jamba list, I will be trying all of them. But the pink star was a wonderful start.

user-pic

Oh your list is not the same as mine, here is my full Jamba list, I got.

Blue Gummy Bear

Peanut Butter and Jelly

Skittles

Bluetopia

Apple Pie

Fruity Pebbles

Strawberry Shortcake

White gummy bear

chocolate gummy bear

Red Gummy Bear

Pink Starbusrt

Raspberry Dreamin'

Pineapple Dreamin'

Sourpatch Kid

Now and Later

Push Pop

user-pic

At Red Robin, their secret menu comes from their website. Basically they have a lot more ingredients than they actually list. You can go to their website and design your own burger and they'll have to make it.

user-pic

What's the secret code at McDonalds to get a burger that hasn't been spit on?

user-pic

I have been ordering veggie whoppers at BK for a few years, most of the time they get it wrong. The last time i ordered it they gave me a meat patty in a box, how wrong is that?! I always get them to fix it, and sometimes it's a dollar cheaper then a reg. whopper. Taco Bell will also replace the meat on the tacos with beans, but watch out for that extra charge.

user-pic

Animal Fries ARE amazing. They're so delicious they make my tummy hurt. But it's worth it. /droooooool

I go to Jamba Juice ridiculously a lot, I'm gonna have to try out some of those secret items. Push Pop sounds tasty...

user-pic

They used to have a "toasted cheese" sandwich at mcdonalds... (two big mac middles and cheese I think). I wonder if they still have the two cheeseburger meal... you used to be able to order it instead of the double cheeseburger meal back in the day.

user-pic

McD's: 2 cheese burger meal. It's like any other meal (so it comes with fries/drink) and 2 burgers. It's cheaper than getting 2 burgers + fries + drink individually.

user-pic

I've gotten the "white gummi bear" at Jamba Juice twice now, and as previously reported, it is indeed better than crack.

Try it now, thank me later!

user-pic

Not that this is a huge deal, but at Chick-Fil-A you can get a chicken strips salad with nuggets instead of the strips. You just have to ask.

user-pic

The secret ingredient for some items is apparently eye contact.

I thought I'd try the Wendy's doublestack at the drivethru, but all I got was a "we don't have that anymore." Then I suggested it's still in the register I got "no, you can't have that. Order something else or move on." unquote.

user-pic

Chili's definitely still has chili on the menu. I just had it a couple weeks ago. Tasty.

There were a couple types of chili, for that matter -- a red and a white, as I recall.

user-pic

This post could also be titled:

"How To Make The Life Of Someone With a Job They Probably Hate That Much Worse."

My fiancee is a four year shift at Starbucks, and if some jackass came in and demanded to put his own ingredients in a frappucino, I'd want to hunt the person down and pour an iced soy latte down their pants.

Ordering something that's not on the listed menu is fine, but wreaking havoc on someone that has to deal with obnoxious people all day, just so you can have your orange mocha frappucino is ridiculous. Buy a blender.

user-pic

More of a local item rather than 'secret', but in Green Bay, WI, the BK's had a "Gilbert Burger", named for Packer's player Gilbert Brown. He told reporters he would order triple Whoppers with double toppings, so the stores began selling them by name.

user-pic

I'm really impressed by all the "they'll make you X... they have the ingredients," because the Jack-in-the-Box near my husband's work "can't" make a double cheeseburger. I forget what the logic is - maybe something like 'uh, we don't know what to charge you for it'. So my husband buys two single cheeseburgers for 99 cents (or whatever the special deal is) and doubles up the meat and throws the buns away.

user-pic

Starbucks has a short cappuccino that isn't on the menu, it's supposedly the best ratio of price/espresso shots. Same amount of espresso as a tall, but less milk. I've ordered it and sure enough, they have the cups for it and they know what it is.

user-pic

I used to love the Classic Double with Cheese at Wendys before I became the food nazi. I went ahead and put together the essential nutrition info for the class double, triple, and quad:

burger | cal | fat | sat fat | carbs | sugars | protein
quad | 1240 | 79 | 34 | 38 | 10 | 92
triple | 0970 | 59 | 25 | 38 | 09 | 70
doubl | 0700 | 39 | 16 | 38 | 08 | 48

Ahh...to be young and fat again.

user-pic

If you ask for a "spicy" or "green" bean burrito at Taco Bell, they'll put green stuff on it instead of red stuff.

user-pic

Spanky:

So, instead of bleeding on it, they'll hock a loogie on it?

user-pic

Chili's will also let you order the Guiltless Grill Chicken Pita even though it's not on the menu anymore. So much better than the Guiltless chicken sandwich!

user-pic

Some Starbucks stuff (from a long-time barista who hasn't worked there in a few years): First, quoting the article--

You can even bring supplements from home and ask the barista to please include that in your drink.

This is only true in a few situations. If you bring something like your own all-natural sweetener in a packet (I used to have a regular that brought in stevia packets), the barista will probably put it in the cup before pulling your shots. But they will absolutely NOT put anything into a blender or otherwise contaminate the Starbucks equipment with whatever the hell you've got in your flask/bottle/pocket. There's no telling what that meth residue might do to the next little kid coming in for a venti mocha frappaccino and the lawsuits it might spawn.

Also, the "short" size is available for all hot drinks. It's 8oz. and does cost less. As of the last time I pulled a shift, it's on the register so you shouldn't get any weird looks asking for it.

OK, that said, here a few "off the menu" drinks well-known by Starbucks baristas:

Red Eye - a cup of coffee with a shot of espresso in it.
Black Eye - a cup of coffee with two shots of espresso in it.
Zebra (aka Oreo) - a mocha made with half regular mocha syrup and half white chocolate syrup
Chai Latte with a shot of espresso - no catchy name, but it is tasty and will keep you awake for days

user-pic

I've been getting the Cheesy Gordita Crunch from Taco Bell for a few years now. One of the only foods I'll eat there.

user-pic

There was a larger in-n-out Burger.
Some Caltech kids tried to order a 666x666, as satanism is common around Caltech. Because In-n-Out is religiously affiliated, they wouldn't make it, but instead they did a 667x667. there were boxes and boxes of meat and cheese, and the thing was re-assembled in the student dorms in all its glory. There are pictures floating around somewhere, but I don't happen to have them.

user-pic

McDonald's is willing to mix things up a bit as well, Double BigMac, Mac Jr., etc.

My personal favorite is the Double BigMac with Quarter Beef, they'll throw a whole pound of beef on a burger for you.

user-pic

For McDonalds:
/remembering things from when I worked at one... years ago
1) Triple Cheese Burger (duh)
2) Grilled Cheese Sandwich (Bun toasted sides out and cheese in the middle)

One thing people may not know, is that if you order something FRESH, they have to cook you a fresh one... But you will have to wait for it. (Burger patties about a minute. Quarter patties somewhere in the range of 1 and a half to two minutes. Fried stuff 3+ minutes.)

user-pic

@OnoSideboard: Damn, I was just going to post that.

At a smaller chain coffee shop that I used to work for we could only add something that a customer brought with them if, and only if, it only needed to go in their cup. Any other way, like into the blender or steaming pitcher, would be a major health code violation. I'm sure Starbucks abides by a very similar policy.

user-pic

Some good burger king tips:

You can order a burger "no steamer" which means it comes directly off the grill. It will take a bit longer but tastes way better. You can also order burgers cut into quarters. Why? CAUSE.

user-pic

Chai Latte with a shot of espresso That sounds almost worth going to Starbucks for. I'm going to have to see if my local little café can do it for me.

I agree about considering the workers in this. Unhappy workers are slower and less willing to help you, so why go out of your way to make them more unhappy by pulling the "I know it's not on your menu but I'm the customer and you HAVE to" schtick. Trying to call down a manager on a barista because he doesn't know the right buttons to push to make you some fabulous crazy drink is cruel. You don't need it that bad. I promise. I'm not against trying to use the secret menus or anything, just don't have a fit if you're refused. Try again next time and suck it up for now.

user-pic

OnoSideBoard: The chai latte with a shot of espresso is known as "Dirty Hippy" at the coffee shops around me (all local places in the Upper Penninsula of Michigan)

user-pic

In Canada McDonald's offers a double Big Mac, it's not on the menu in the States, but I'm sure you could order one. Just so everyone knows, they're delicious.

user-pic

sorry to be a jerk, but can someone describe the jamba flavors. thanks alot.

user-pic

A friend of mine once ordered the a burger at Burger King and the person serving accidentally hit the CUT 1/2 button. He looked at his receipt and was asking us.. "CUT 1/2??" So one of the servers grabs a burger off the queue, and as he's watching, pulls out this huge knife and slices the still-wrapped burger in half. My friend was just, like, 'huh?' Then the server wraps it in yet another wrapper and hands it to him. The look on my friend's face was priceless.

After seeing that, another friend suggested maybe next time he could ask for one that was cut into thirds..

user-pic

At a Canadian Dairy Queen I once ordered a Chicken Strip Blizzard, and to my surprise they agreed to make it after the Manager warned me that the result of mixing hot fried chicken and smooth ice cream would probably not be very palatable.

In the end, I chickened out (pardon the pun) and got something a little more sensible but it was liberating to know that I could get basically what I wanted if I was willing to pay for it and live with the results.

user-pic

I always wondered why Burger King stopped cutting the original chicken sandwiches in half. You have to ASK for it now?

user-pic

i work at mimi's cafe, and much the same applies to most sit down restaurants:

if we discontinue an item, but still have the ingredients to make it, we will, lack of computer buttons be damned.

just be polite, and don't be surprised if shows up under another name, or as 'open food' on your ticket, that's just the way we have to charge it.


again, the rule is, the customer is always right, however, we reserve the right to determine who's a customer;)

user-pic

Chili's no longer has the "Blue Ribbon Salad", but I still order it and get it.

user-pic

McDonalds will add or subtract meat patties to your liking. Personal favourite is the 'Pounder': the contents of 4 quarter pounders in the one burger. Mmmm..cholesterol.

user-pic

" Starbucks corporate policy is that the customer is ALWAYS right"
While it is corporate policy to do so, a) being rude to the barista may get you decaf shots
and b) Food safety is taught at every level, and so making a "soy" frappachino is impossible, since the blender would have to be sanitized at the very least after adding your ingredients to it.
Note: you might be able to bully a manager into it, but again, I wouldn't suggest it.
You can also order a kids apple juice, or milk/flavored milk through starbucks with no problem. Should ring up for $1.05 or so.
Try not to ask for "red eye" or nicknames for your drinks, it's easier to just explain what the drink is, and results in less confusion. (Since each store has different names for these "special drinks" ex) a black and white mocha is called a tuxedo for us.)
If you're a regular at a particular starbucks, they're more willing to bend over backwards for you, for example one of the regulars always orders a "venti 2 splenda no water extra ice black tea and a grande 1 pump mocha"


Absolutely any concoction that you can think of (involving any type of milk, syrup, coffee, etc.) will be made for you. The limits to Starbucks "secret menu" are merely the limits of your imagination.
-This is really ONLY true with espresso drinks.

Please, Please, Please take into consideration your barista when ordering.
(and yes, I am a "partner" at SBux)

user-pic

At the Brooklyn Diner on 57th St in Manhattan you can order the best turkey burgers in town, which are not on the menu.

user-pic

At sonic, you can order a pink flamingo which is like pink limeade with lemons and cherries(It is awesome). They stopped promoting it after they changed their menus, but if you get a somewhat knowledgeable person they will know what you mean. When you get your receipt though the description will probably say "See Me" or something similar. My guess is that the smart person has to tell the newb how to make it.
-Matthew

user-pic

Skyline - Secret menu item is the Chilito. It is a mini burrito filled with chili and cheese. You can add onions and sourcream for a truelly fantastic adventure :o)

user-pic

@derherzeleid:

I'm calling your bluff on the soy frappachino.
I have worked as a Barista before at Borders Group and
am a vegetarian going on 6 years now. I have never
heard of any sanitation issues over adding soy to a
frappachino.
I admit I don't know everything, but I
am interested in knowing where is your sorce.
Especially since google comes up empty.