<![CDATA[Consumerist: Toothpaste]]> http://cache.gawker.com/assets/base/img/thumbs140x140/consumerist.com.png <![CDATA[Consumerist: Toothpaste]]> http://consumerist.com/tag/toothpaste http://consumerist.com/tag/toothpaste <![CDATA[ Charges Filed Against Importers Of Toxic Toothpaste ]]> con_squozentoothpaste.jpg On Tuesday, the city of Los Angeles and the FDA charged the heads of two U.S. importing companies with 14 counts each of "receiving, selling and delivering an adulterated drug," for their roles in importing and distributing over 70,000 tubes of toothpaste containing diethylene glycol (DEG) instead of glycerin. "Each count carries a maximum penalty of one year in jail and a $1,000 fine."

From the Washington Post:

The companies are liable for distributing the tainted product even if they had no direct knowledge of the risk because they were negligent in not ensuring the toothpaste was safe, Supervising Deputy City Attorney Jerry Baik said.

Ghermezi said he had not seen the charges but was shocked by the filing. All the adulterated toothpaste was voluntarily pulled from shelves and from his Vernon, Calif., company's inventory eight months ago and destroyed by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration last month, he said.

"Everything we had was destroyed by the FDA," Ghermezi said. "I thought the file had been closed."

Ghermezi said he supplied the toothpaste to Vernon Sales, also based in Vernon. He said his company never knowingly sold adulterated toothpaste and thought the product had FDA approval.

"We didn't know of the ingredients of the toothpaste," he said. "We don't [have] any intention of hurting people."

What's the appropriate level of punishment for unwittingly importing tainted products? Is it reasonable to ask a U.S. importer to test products for safety and/or monitor production quality overseas? Is this too harsh, or do the prosecutors have evidence of deliberate negligence? We're waiting to see more details of the case before feeling sympathy or vindication.

(Thanks to dsavlin!)

"Charges filed against LA importers over toxic Chinese toothpaste" [Chicago Tribune]
"Criminal Charges Filed Over Poisonous Toothpaste" [Washington Post]
"Los Angeles City's Chief Prosecutor, Along With FDA, Files Criminal Charges Against Two Local Companies For Toxic Toothpaste Import " [RTT News]

RELATED
"Man Who Discovered Tainted Toothpaste Located, Interviewed"
The saga of the tainted toothpaste on Consumerist
(Photo: Janmi_)

]]>
Fri, 07 Mar 2008 12:04:54 EST Chris Walters http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=365174&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Man Who Discovered Tainted Toothpaste Located, Interviewed ]]> con_tubeoftoothpaste.jpg Sometimes being a conscientious shopper really does matter. The man who realized that tubes of discount toothpaste were tainted with diethylene glycol last May has been found and interviewed by the New York Times. Eduardo Arias, a 51-year-old government worker in Panama City, was shopping in a discount store one Saturday when he saw the toothpaste—he said he could read the ingredients list clearly without even picking up a tube, and when he saw "diethylene glycol" as an ingredient, alarms went off.

He bought a tube, and the next Monday he took a vacation day to bring it to a Health Ministry office. They directed him to a second office, naturally. They told him to take the toothpaste to a third office, and when he balked, they had him fill out a complaint form and leave the tube. Three days later, the story exploded when the country's top health official reported that a "shopper in Panama" had discovered the tainted product.

A year ago, those words would have meant nothing to him. "Nobody had ever heard of this stuff," Mr. Arias said. But a steady drumbeat of news about poison cough syrup had engraved the words in his mind.

"It was inconceivable to me that a known toxic substance that killed all these people could be openly on sale and that people would go on about their business calmly, selling and buying this stuff."


"The Everyman Who Exposed Tainted Toothpaste" [New York Times]
(Photo: Janmi)

]]>
Tue, 02 Oct 2007 13:17:53 EDT Chris Walters http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=306139&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Poison Toothpaste Also Found In Prisons And Mental Hospitals ]]> We missed this AP article from June 28th but poison toothpaste isn't just for dollar stores anymore, turns out Georgia prisons and mental hospitals bought hundreds of thousands of the tubes and distributed it to their wards.

In total, 2 state prisons received 846,288 tubes, 5 cuckoo clocks got 14,544 tubes, and 4 juvis received 3600 tubes. This reminds us of a Johnny Cash tune...

I hear the Chinese poison train a comin'
It's rollin' 'round the bend...
And I ain't seen the FDA,
Since, I don't know when,
I'm stuck in Georgian Prison,
And time keeps draggin' on,
But that Chinese poison train keeps a-rollin',
On down to San Antone...

When I was just a baby,
My Mama told me, "Son,
Always be a good boy,
Don't ever play with Magstix,"
But I fed a man antifreeze toothpaste in Atlanta,
Just to watch him die,
When I hear that whistle blowin',
I hang my head and cry.

Tainted Toothpaste Found in US Prisons [Guardian Unlimited]
(Photo: imorgan73)

]]>
Wed, 11 Jul 2007 10:49:34 EDT Ben Popken http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=277177&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ 700 Tubes Of Poison Toothpaste Seized ]]>
Over 700 tubes of poisonous counterfeit toothpaste were seized in Connecticut, according to The New York Times. The toothpaste is flavored with diethylene glycol, a sweet-tasting chemical more commonly found in anti-freeze. It can cause liver and kidney damage if swallowed.

From the NYT:

Inspectors from the state's Department of Consumer Protection said they seized 430 tubes of a counterfeit Colgate toothpaste reportedly made in South Africa and 275 tubes of Chinese-made Dentakleen and the strawberry and blueberry flavors of Dentakleen Junior from stores in Hartford, West Hartford, Waterbury, Derby and North Branford. The varieties of the counterfeit Colgate brand, including maximum cavity protection, gel and triple action, are listed as tainted.

State officials said inspections would continue this week.

Last month, about 900,000 tubes of tainted toothpaste turned up in prisons and other state institutions, mostly in Georgia and North Carolina, and at some hospitals in South Carolina and Florida. The investigation in Connecticut was prompted by a call from a consumer who reported that the toothpaste was still on the shelves of some stores, despite the recall order.

Connecticut's Attorney General, Richard Blumenthal (a sort of rock star of Attorney Generals, as he is currently suing Best Buy over their secret website), said, "Our demand to Chinese manufacturers is for information necessary to track down and crack down on all these poisonous products."

For pictures of the poison toothpaste, head to the CT Department of Consumer Affairs where they have pictures as well as the names of stores that were caught still stocking the toothpaste.

700 Tubes of Toothpaste Are Seized in Connecticut
[NYT]

]]>
Wed, 11 Jul 2007 10:04:16 EDT Meg Marco http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=276935&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ China: Consuming Low Levels Of Poison "Not Harmful" ]]> China's General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine thinks the FDA overreacted by advising consumers to discard all toothpaste made in China:

So far we have not received any report of death resulting from using the toothpaste. The U.S. handling (of this case) is neither scientific nor responsible.
The FDA issued its warning after seizing several shipments of Chinese toothpaste containing diethylene glycol, a poison used in paint and antifreeze. 100 Panamanians died last year after consuming cough syrup made with diethylene glycol. According to Chinese logic, poison in toothpaste isn't as deadly as poison in cough syrup. Besides, wasn't it Confucius who said: "That which does not kill us makes us stronger." Either him or Nietzsche. We always confuse those two. — CAREY GREENBERG-BERGER

China says U.S. warning on toothpaste irresponsible [Reuters]
PREVIOUSLY: Today's Helpful Tip From The FDA: Throw Out Poisonous Chinese Toothpaste
NEXT WEEK: Head Of Chinese General Administration Of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine Sentenced To Death For Inane Declarations Taking Bribes

]]>
Sun, 03 Jun 2007 14:34:29 EDT Carey http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=265484&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Today's Helpful Tip From The FDA: Throw Out Poisonous Chinese Toothpaste ]]> Remember how the FDA said there was "no evidence" that Chinese toothpaste tainted with diethylene glycol had made it to the U.S.? That was wrong.

The FDA is now warning that there is a "low but meaningful risk of toxicity and injury" to people who use the following brands of discount toothpaste: Cooldent Fluoride, Cooldent Spearmint, Cooldent ICE, Dr. Cool, Superdent, Clean Rite, Oralmax Extreme, Oral Bright, Bright Max, and ShiR Fresh Mint.

The tainted toothpaste has been spotted at bargain stores in Los Angeles, Miami, and Puerto Rico. The FDA has devised a simple test to evaluate the safety of your toothpaste: if it says "Made in China," throw it out. — CAREY GREENBERG-BERGER

FDA: Some Toothpaste Sold at Bargain Stores Dangerous [AP]
PREVIOUSLY: FDA To Test All Chinese Toothpaste
Chinese Poison Train Rolls On: Next Stop, Panamanian Toothpaste

]]>
Sat, 02 Jun 2007 09:12:05 EDT Carey http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=265394&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ FDA To Test All Chinese Toothpaste ]]> The FDA will test all toothpaste made in China. It was discovered last week that some Chinese manufacturers had been substituting a more costly sugar flavoring with a cheaper, and deadly one, one that is also used in antifreeze. The toothpaste was discovered and sold in Panama.

There's no evidence that any of the brands, Excel, Mr. Cool, and Mr. Cool Junior, were sold in the United States. Still, the FDA decided to err on the side of caution. — BEN POPKEN

F.D.A. to Test Toothpaste Sent to U.S. From China [NYT]

PREVIOUSLY: Chinese Poison Train Rolls On: Next Stop, Panamanian Toothpaste
(Photo: Getty Images)

]]>
Thu, 24 May 2007 09:18:01 EDT Ben Popken http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=263201&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Chinese Poison Train Rolls On: Next Stop, Panamanian Toothpaste ]]> Cpt%20Toothpaste.jpg6,000 tubes of toothpaste in Panama have been found to contain diethylene glycol, a poison used in solvents and antifreeze. The poison appears to have originated in China.

Diethylene glycol is the same agent that killed 100 Panamanians after the state-owned Chinese company Taixing Glycerin sold the sweet tasting poison as pharmaceutical-grade glycerine. The mislabeled glycerin was used to make cough syrup.

According to Panama's Health Ministry, the tainted toothpaste, sold under the brands Excel and Mr. Cool, poses less of a threat than the tainted cough syrup because people spit out toothpaste after brushing.

The poison was discovered when "a consumer notified the pharmacy and drugs section of the Health Ministry after seeing that diethylene glycol was listed as an ingredient in toothpaste at a store."

The FDA is watching the situation closely and has found "no evidence" that the tainted toothpaste poses a threat to America's pearly-whites. — CAREY GREENBERG-BERGER

Poisoned Toothpaste in Panama Is Believed to Be From China [NYT] (Thanks to Matt!)
PREVIOUSLY: Counterfeit Cough Medicine Traced To Chinese Factory
(Photo: Jonas B)

]]>
Sun, 20 May 2007 10:43:17 EDT Carey http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=261939&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Toms of Maine Sells Out to Colgate ]]> toms.jpgGuess we can't brush our teeth with our dissent anymore:

    "Colgate on Tuesday became the second multinational corporation in a week to buy a small company with a social responsibility message. It bought 84% of Tom's of Maine, the all-natural personal care brand based in Kennebunk, Maine, for $100 million."

    "Consumers have shown they are willing to pay a premium for "natural" products from values-oriented companies that make them feel good, and big marketers want a piece of the profitable trend."

We will just have to resort to good ol' fashioned fennel clippings to get that maryjane aftertaste out our gums.

Big Companies Buy Small Brands With Big Values [USATODAY via Adpulp] [p]

]]>
Wed, 22 Mar 2006 09:58:49 EST popkin http://consumerist.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=162162&view=rss&microfeed=true