Bank of America ejected reader Tycho after he refused to give the teller a thumbprint while cashing a check.
"Your are not a customer and I don't have to help you." I asked, "What good is a BofA check if BofA wont cash it? Checks are bound by federal guidelines, it seems to me like not honoring a check to your own bank would be fraud." "Those rules tell me I have to get your thumb print to cash a check." "Show me that rule."
Question: Can a bank legally refuse to cash your check? Can a bank legally require a thumbprint as a prerequisite for doing business?
Tycho's letter, inside...
Tycho writes:
"To cash this check I need your thumb print."
"I'm not going to give you my thumb print, how bout some more ID?"
"I can't do that."
"Do you not think I am who I say I am?"
"I need a thumb print."
At this point she waved the next person in line to her. I asked to see the branch manager.
The manager came up to me with a stack of papers she was busy with and set them down on the counter. I told her I had a check drawn on BofA that I would like to cash and the teller refused to do so. We went through the above exchange. When I offered extra ID to prove I am who I say I am, very discreetly, almost imperceptibly, she glanced at the security guard. When we got to the second "I need a thumb print." the tete-a-tete' took a different turn.
"Your are not a customer and I don't have to help you."
I asked, "What good is a BofA check if BofA wont cash it? Checks are bound by federal guidelines, it seems to me like not honoring a check to your own bank would be fraud."
"Those rules tell me I have to get your thumb print to cash a check."
"Show me that rule."
To that she made no response, glanced at the security guard who was right behind me at this point, and went about her work as if I had never walked into the bank. I asked the security guard if he could cash my check. He said no and that if I had no business at the bank, I would have to leave. I turned to the manager and said that her security guard cannot help me either. She walked away keeping her head down to avoid eye contact.
I left, check in hand, frustrated and insulted.
This branch is in Miami Beach. I don't know the managers name.
Regardless of the thumb print, each person I spoke with was amazingly quick to ignore me and let someone else deal with my vigilance. It was really only a few sentences when the manager gave the security guard the glance and he came creeping up behind me. It was not anything about how I behaved, I was certain to remember my manners and to be polite.
It was only what I said (and it wasn't much) that quickly warranted me being ignored with a security guard at my side.
-Tycho"
— BEN POPKEN







