What Is The Most Perfect Sandwich On Earth?

Yes, yesterday was election day and blah blah democracy and all that. But what many have overlooked in all that hype is that today is National Sandwich Day.

Apparently the hamburger is the most popular sandwich in the country, but does that make it the best sandwich? What about classics like the BLT or PB&J? Some of us are partial to tuna salad while other, “independent thinkers,” go rogue with open-faced turkey sandwiches.

Here at Consumerist, we regularly dine one gold-dusted cheese sandwiches or pre-made lasagna sandwiches imported from the UK.

So here is your chance to share with the world your particular, perhaps peculiar, thoughts on what makes the best sandwich.

National Sandwich Day [punchbowl.com]

Comments

  1. Cheap Sniveler: Sponsored by JustAnswer.comâ„¢ says:

    RibWich.

  2. akepp7 says:

    Isabella’s Groceria in Medfield, MA makes “The Mayflower.” The traditional after-Thanksgiving sandwich. It’s a braided roll topped with warm stuffing, cranberry sauce, and turkey. I usually get it with a bit of mayo. It’s fantastic!

  3. TheGreySpectre says:

    Roast beef, mayo and pepperjack on french from Domini’s in Spokane WA

  4. lehrdude says:
  5. Paco47 says:

    Ever hear of a Primanti’s Sandwich from Pittsburgh? It’s a local legendary franchise that piles your choice of meat (I like pastrami) with a vinegar based cole slaw and fantastic fresh cut french fries between two great slices of Italian bread. Splash some Red Devil hot sauce on every bite for a mouth watering meal between bread.

  6. gybryant says:

    Muffuletta from Central Grocery in New Orleans. I’ve never found another muff’ that has that perfect blend of crusty but chewy bread, hard salami and that olive salad with just a bit of crunch. Dear God, I’m hungry.

    • Me - now with more humidity says:

      Mellow Mushroom has a mufuletta pizza. Olive tapenade instead of sauce. OMFG!

  7. biggieshorty says:

    Carolina pulled pork bbq with cole slaw and bbq sauce on a nice smooshy roll.

    Mmmmmmmmm.

  8. Me - now with more humidity says:

    A reuben (not one of the pansy turkey reubens) or a Cuban. Or rare roast beef with horseradish cheddar. Or…

    Do I have to pick just one?

  9. haggis for the soul says:

    Rare roast beef on italian loaf bread with mayo.

  10. lucky13 says:

    I make a “dago” burger (I’m part Italian so no offense) that is to die for:

    grilled ground Italian sausage patty topped with sauteed peppers, onions, & mushrooms and melted provolone & mozzarella

    The second most perfect sandwich would have to be the cheesesteak, which is more readily available.

  11. HogwartsProfessor says:

    An authentic Philly cheesesteak. Barring that, my own homemade substitute with Steak-Ums, cheese, onions and peppers. Mmm.

  12. gybryant says:

    Oh, and those long Paris street sandwiches. I’ve never had a bad one. It’s probably because they’re typically seasoned with hunger.

  13. Snubber says:

    There is a place up in Seattle called “Paseo” that has two locations. They serve the best sandwich in the entire universe. It’s called the Cuban Roast Sandwich and it’s slow cooked pork with grilled onions, jalepenos, cilantro on a crispy roll with some special sauce. Don’t even think of going to Seattle without eating one (cash only too.)

  14. BigDave says:

    Chipotle, [chip- oat-lay] not “chipolte” [chip-ol-tay]
    Sorry, I hate seeing/hearing it misspelled/mispronounced
    Like nuclear/”nucular” or supposedly/”supposably”

  15. joshwillis says:

    muffaletta

  16. Atalanta says:

    There are so many good sandwich possibilities! Pastrami on rye is a given, egg salad with onion and bacon on a kaiser roll (with a slice of provolone if so desired) is delicious and comforting, and a gastropub near me makes a divine fresh mozzerella, pesto, and tomato on a baguette. Current fave, though, is fried salami on white bread with a smidge of spicy brown mustard.

  17. Powerlurker says:

    The New Jersey style sloppy joe, especially when it’s made in the original style: sliced ham and cow tongue (roast beef is a common substitute), three slices of seedless rye, swiss cheese, cole slaw, and Russian dressing.

    • DrLumen says:

      Hard to pick just one as a favorite as there are so any. But I guess it would have to be a Schlotzky’s Turkey & Bacon Club on Jalapeno Cheese sourdough. Yummy.

      I’m going to get one right now!

  18. Consumer David says:

    McRib!

  19. suez says:

    For me it’s a toss-up between a BLT, a Reuben, or a simple ham, swiss & mustard. Nothing fancy.

  20. sopmodm14 says:

    mcrib ftw , duh !

  21. okcancel says:

    Chop suey sandwiches from Salem Lowe at the Willows in Salem, MA. Awesome, and downright healthy for anyone with a salt deficiency.

  22. VouxCroux says:

    The best sandwich is one that is brought to me by a woman.

  23. ossuary says:

    The Chubble. No doubt about it.

  24. tooluser says:

    Southern California style hot pastrami sandwich. About 10 ounces of thin sliced pastrami slowly simmered in spiced beef broth until it is falling apart tender. Piled on a crusty hoagie roll with some yellow mustard and dill pickle slices. It’s got vegetables!

  25. Difdi says:

    Some years back, I set out to produce the best gourmet cheeseburger recipe I could…I came up with this:

    Fresh from the oven honey wheat mini round loaf (great harvest bread company), aged cotswold cheese, best foods mayonnaise, grey poupon country-style mustard, heinz no-HFCS ketchup, 50/50 mix of bibb and romaine heart lettuce, single slice of a large home grown vine ripened beefsteak tomato, hempler’s maple cured bacon fried in fresh cracked peppercorns, sliced shishito peppers, charcoal-grilled ground llama patty (seasoned with gray sea salt, white pepper, rubbed sage, ground fresh basil, lea & perrins worcestershire sauce, crumbled feta, crushed garlic, msg seasoning, wasabi powder, herbes de provence, tapatio hot sauce, mae ploy sweet chili sauce, tabasco smoked chipotle sauce and a little bread crumbs to make the pappty less gooey).

    Yeah, it’s a burger, but a burger is still a sandwich.

    • Difdi says:

      Almost forgot. Home made dill pickles, lightly pickled so that the pickle is still white in the middle. Serve the masterpiece with a side of home made french fries (yukon gold potatoes), lightly dusted with garlic salt.

      We need an edit button.

      • tooluser says:

        All male chefs need an edit button. Mom knew something very deep and abiding about grilled cheese sandwiches.

  26. savashley says:

    Chicken sandwich from Hursey’s BBQ in Burlington, NC with mayonnaise and two pieces of cheese!

    SERIOUSLY best thing I’ve ever put in my mouth. I don’t understand how it’s so good.

  27. Coles_Law says:

    Jalapeños and banana on an English muffin. Try it.

  28. ThatsWhatSheSaid says:

    the MCRIB

  29. HungryGal says:

    BLT. Five ingredient bliss, especially when made with plenty of thick cut high quality bacon, room temperature ripe flavorful tomatoes, plenty of top quality mayo, and golden toast made out of that magically dense/soft “pullman loaf.”

  30. MongoAngryMongoSmash says:

    How about a nice greasy pork sandwich served in a dirty ash try?

  31. Chooi says:

    The turkey sandwich from Champps (without Avocado) is pretty good.

  32. stottpie says:

    i always get roast beef, cheddar, spicy mustard. preferably on white bread or a french roll

  33. ginnel says:

    Sweet Lebanon Bologna on a Sesame roll with mayo and Middleswarth potato chips.

  34. TacoDave says:

    Nothing beats the original Chick-Fil-A chicken sandwich. Two pickle slices. Bread. That is all.

  35. prizgrizbiz says:

    A wish sandwich – two pieces of bread, and you wish you had some meat, a baw-baw-baw…