Which Router Bit Set Would You Buy?

While mucking around on Home Depot‘s site, Elliott spotted this juxtaposition of smokin’/non-smokin’ deals. It seems that the prices for the 20-piece router bit set is the same as that of the 10-piecer. He states the obvious:

I don’t think they’re going to sell a lot of those 10 piece sets.

I dunno. Maybe there’s something we don’t know about that 10-piece set. I’ll have to stare at Home Depot’s handy price comparison page for a while to come to a verdict.

Product Comparison [Home Depot]

Comments

Edit Your Comment

  1. katstermonster says:

    Wait, did Home Depot really drop the “free shipping” requirements to $49. I like that. I hate that Target always has these deals running for free shipping on $50 orders, and everything I want is $49.99.

  2. rpm773 says:

    Which Router Bit Set Would You Buy?

    The 10-piece set. I threw the 20-piece set on the ground!

  3. diasdiem says:

    You can take the donkey to the top of the hill, or you can take the tram. It is the same price.

  4. FatLynn says:

    Are both carbide? Are the bits the same size? It’s hard to tell from the pic.

    • dangerp says:

      @FatLynn: They both have the same model number (sans the 10 vs 20 part). In the retail world, that generally means the same product, different quantity. They look the same to me.

    • Rachacha says:

      @FatLynn: Both sets are Carbide, but it was difficult to tell whether all of the bits in the 10 piece set are included in the 20 piece set. If the exact bit that I needed to complete a woordworking job was only in the 10 piece set, I would buy the 10 piece set.

      • perruptor says:

        @Rachacha: Where do you see that the 20-piece set is carbide? The 10-piece set is labeled as being carbide, but the other one isn’t. That could make the difference.

  5. GitEmSteveDave_OverSleptThisMorn says:

    The 10 piece set, because the 20 piece is Energy Star Compliant, and I have a vendetta against polar bears.

  6. catskyfire says:

    One seems to be carbide, the other not. That would up the price on the 10 piece one.

  7. zigziggityzoo says:

    Carbide vs. not carbide?

    • pimpybra says:

      @zigziggityzoo: They’re both carbide, you have to open up the pictures in both listings.

      The model numbers are near identical, too A25RS10 vs A25RS20 (probably 10/20 for quantity).

  8. jvanbrecht says:

    They are Ryobi, they are cheap Chinese and Taiwanese bits. They will chip, they will wobble, and they will only be useful for 1 or 2 rounds on any manufactured wood product (MDF, LVL, Plywood… these things destroy cheap router bits).

    If your going to purchase router bits for more then a single project, pay the extra cash for a quality product, Whiteside (these are also made in the USA), MLCS have some nice bits, hell, even the Porter Cable bits (1″ not 1/2″ shank) at home despot are okay….

    Seriously… avoid cheap router bits, little bits of carbide flying off a spinny blade of doom at 30k rpm are deadly….

    • stuporglue says:

      @jvanbrecht:

      As a novice router-er, I intend to buy a cheap Ryobi set!

      I know they’re crappy and won’t last long, but I don’t really know what types of bits I will need. I’ll get a Ryobi set for the price of a single good router bit, and whatever bits get worn out, I’ll replace with good bits.

      And if it really does shatter and kill me, at least I’ve got life insurance. :-)

    • Costner says:

      @jvanbrecht: 1″ not 1/2″? Are you serious? I don’t know of any handheld routers that use 1″ shanks, and if they do exist they surely aren’t common.

      If something has a 1″ shank it must be for a shaper table, not an actual router. Are you sure you didn’t mean 1/4″ vs 1/2″?

      As to the Ryobi bits, I have a set of the 1/2″ shank bits and they are ok. I probably wouldn’t have bought them myself but they made a nice gift, and frankly since I’m just a DIYer and not a serious woodworker, they have worked very well for me. The bearings are doing good, I don’t see any chipping on the carbide, and the bits I have used have remained sharp thus far.

      Can’t really complain even if it they are “cheap”. Sometimes cheap tools are all a person needs.

  9. revmatty says:

    Actually both sets are carbide tipped, looks like the 10pc is a subset of the 20pc as a lot of the bits are the same.

  10. coan_net says:

    This happens all the time – supplies, dealers, reseallers, stores, etc… will have a surplus of an item and offer it at a discount – sometimes making the “20 piece” item as cheap as the 10 piece item.

    For example, I was purchasing Dragon software for where I work. I had the choice of just the software for $199, or I could get the software bundled with headphones for $99. Now I really don’t need the headphones, but I asked why, and it was a overstock issue that they needed to sell a lot of those.

    It happens, not really a consumerist issue I would think.

    • econobiker says:

      @coan_net: A “pro-consumer” issue! I have hit some weird stuff like this also on closeouts. I was looking for a model car kit for #1 son and I to do. Single kits go for $14.99 to $24.99 now ouch! Then I went to look at a craft store that usually has kits on the upper side of the cost spectrum. They had a two kit holiday package close out that said marked down from $25.99 to $14.99- cool says me- two for $7.50 each. I take it to purchase and it rings up at $4.99! I asked if this was correct and it was as the register person said it was a close out. Turned around and bought two more twin packs at $4.99 and then sold one of the kits alone for $5.00. #1 son and I now have 5 possible kits to build and I’ve only spent $10 plus the taxes.

    • Traveshamockery says:

      @coan_net: BINGO.

  11. runchadrun says:

    Am I the only one who, when he saw “router” and “bit” in the same sentence was thinking of a Cisco configuration?

  12. b4k4 says:

    When I look up the 20 piece set on home depot’s website there’s an image that says “New Lower Price”

    [www.homedepot.com]

    Sounds like either a sale or a price drop that hasn’t affected the 10 piece set.

  13. robdew2 says:

    I would buy neither, as ryobi router bits are toys.

  14. jvanbrecht says:

    Aside from my trashing Ryobi bits earlier.

    There is a perfectly reasonable explanation why a 10 and 20 bit set could be the same price.

    First off, I have not looked very closely at the bits in question, others have stated they appear to be the same, however, there can also be some small subtle differences in the profiles of each of the sets bits.

    Router bits in general can be pricey, your standard profiles are pretty cheap, but once you get to more exotic or odd shapes (which may only differ slightly form your standard profiles), the prices go up, way up.

    I have a $250 set of profile bits (6 of them) that are designed to create molding (crown and floor), picture frames, and a bunch of other odd shapes. I also have a $50 set of standard cove, bullnose, etc bits, then there is the $200 set of rail and stile.

    The point being, different profiles have different costs, hence why a 10 set could be the same as a 20 set, but in this case, as has been pointed out, it could be the 20 set includes the same bits as the 10, and its just a matter of clearing out old stock.