Child Labor? In MY Local Store? It's More Likely Than You Think
Was anything you own made with forced or child labor? It's more likely than you think. Last week, the U.S. Department of Labor finally released a long-awaited report on the use of child labor or forced labor worldwide. The unsurprising result: Children and forced laborers work in agriculture, mining, and manufacturing worldwide.
The report was a requirement of the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2005. In the introduction to the list of products and countries, the Department of Labor notes:
Buyers in today's globally integrated marketplace face an array of choices when they shop. In addition to the usual price considerations, many consumers and buyers would like to weigh other factors before making purchasing decisions: Who produced this product? How, and under what conditions, was it produced? However, there is a huge gap in information available to consumers about the processes and labor practices that produce the goods in our markets.
The report does not include children and adults forced into underground work, such as the drug trade, prostitution, and the production of pornography. Still, the report is eye-opening, and something you may not be able to help thinking about when shopping for chocolate, tea, clothing, or Christmas decorations.
The report doesn't name specific companies, which would have actually made it useful.
List of Goods Produced by Child or Forced Labor required by the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2005 (TVPRA List) [U.S. Department of Labor]
Child, forced labor behind many products: study [Reuters] (Thanks, chaitea!)
(Photo: kI-Ga)
Post a comment
Comments:
We can make the argument that people will think twice before buying these products because of this report, but what other product can they buy that isn't linked to this? Practically everything has some link to this.
Unfortunately, all of this will go into one ear and out the other when it comes down to profit margin.
@Eldritch: This has been going on since the dawn of humanity. That we have reached a point where we expect it to not exist and attempt to stomp it out when possible says, if anything, good things about humanity.
Child labor happens in every country on the planet. While some countries like America, it should not be happening, in other poorer countries like China or Africa, families may require their children to start working at a young age because the parents income may not be enough to support the child. While there some that should not exist in any part of the world like the underground stuff. The standard non underground work is understandable in some countries.
PS, pretty much all 3rd world countries make extensive use of child labor in all forms of business because income is so low that once a child reaches a certain age where they require significantly more resources to stay alive, the income of the parents is not enough to keep everyone in the family from starving.
You gotta take action.
Things like this seem to just sneak up on you.
@Eyebrows McGee (now with more baby!):
At least I'm honest about it; that should be worth at least a couple of points in my favor.
@Razor512:
This is true. Child labor was once common in the US, too. It wasn't until we were wealthy enough as a society to support and educate our children that we strove to eliminate the practice.
The question then becomes, how should we react to child labor in poor countries? Do we demand (through our purchases and our words) that it end immediately, possibly preventing or slowing the economic growth necessary to truly provide these children with decent food, housing, and education? Or do we tolerate a practice we find unethical, and hope that less wealthy societies, as they become more prosperous, will come to think as we do?
@Bogart's Falcon: Just Forget the Other Name: As an adjustment for inflation. Everything will rise in absolute costs, but not necessarily relative costs.
@AgitatedDot: Crap like this? The forced slavery of human beings in 2009.... crap like this...... unbelievable. How do you sleep at night?
Heh. Even in good ole' America you get child labor. At least my story is about work that was only semi-voluntary. When my GF was in high school, her summers she worked for a local organic fruit stand. Not inside, mind you, but out in the fields. When your mom can barely afford to feed you and your three little brothers, you take jobs that pay $2.00/hr. She couldn't work legit, since she was 13 at the time. Minimum wage was either $6.25 or $6.75 (good old CA sun). Good times.
@Laura Northrup: See I tried the image tag but it just wouldn't let me do it for some reason. A little help, please?
@macbeach: They might have to name every retailer in this country - which, in its own way, would be useless information as well.
@Subliminal0182: Dear A. Patriot,
Buy products made in the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. "Made in the USA" goodness with Chinese-style labor standards (not surprisingly, often with Chinese laborers who quickly realize that labor rules and standards don't apply to "certain parts" of the United States)
Sincerely,
Nationalism is not Patriotism.
@acvicari: Absolutely. Unchecked child labor was officially sanctioned in parts of the United States as recently as the Great Depression (1930's).
As of an appropriate reaction to child labor: We're in a Catch-22 situation at the end of the day. Damned if we do, damned if we don't. Might as well make the best of things...
@Method of Steepest Descent: Hey! I was always curious.
What do you look like after decades of lack of sleep?
@Esquire99: I'll be honest too. I don't care where something I'm buying came from, as long as it safe and a low price. Will me - personally, just my own lonesome self - not buying an item do ANYTHING to stop child labor?
No. And don't bring that "everyone's vote counts" BS either, because in the grand scheme of things, me not buying, 100 people not buying, 10,000 people not buying does nothing, nothing at all.
So just live with it and help the people in need around you out. If your heart bleeds so much, you die.
Is anyone else surprised to see Pornography on the list of goods? I mean you'd have to have some pretty heavy blinders on to not know it's happening, but most govt. reports tend to leave important things like this out. May what ever deity they pray to or a man with a gun and good intentions get them out of that situation asap.
@SpruceStreetPhil: You're absolutely right. That's why we need to pass laws about this; because voting with your wallet is, most of the time, completely ineffective.
Be it an international law, some sort of importing law in the U.S. or whatever, I'd definitely go for that. Of course, you'd probably have the Chamber of Commerce harking about how it would hurt the mom-and-pop stores if the Chinese can't use child labor, but whatever.
@acvicari: Yes, we end it immediately. A lot of research has found that strict bans on child labor decrease the birth rate. The reason is that when children are no longer valuable for their parents, parents don't want as many. If poor countries decrease their birth rate, more wealth will be available per capita. You'll have a higher standard of living for children and all the people of these countries.
@TCama:
Yes, more laws is exactly what we need. Lets make the legal landscape even more complicated than it already is and involve the government in more areas of private business. Since this deals with something that isn't even occurring in within the borders of our country it needs even more attention, more legislation and more money spent on it.
@Esquire99: So, let's get this straight:
1) You're offended by counterfeiting, but child and forced labor is super-duper.
2) Child and forced labor is simply a private business matter!
3) LA!LA!LA!LA!LA! If I can't see it or hear it in this country, it's not happening!
4) You eschew government action, yet likewise ridicule action via "consumer choice."
5) You "hate kids," but think highly enough of them to have them make your socks and shoes and fine persian rugs.
You're alright, dude.
@veg-o-matic:
I wasn't clear: I'm not offended by counterfeiting, I just want to make sure what I buy isn't counterfeit.
Also, I think consumer choice I great; here I was merely explaining how I choose.
Otherwise, yeah, you're pretty much right.
If information about where and how things are produced were as readily available as information about price, more people would care.
It is not in the seller's interest to provide it, though.
forced labor, in general, is a lot more common than many realize.
my thesis is on the topic and when i tell old friends about what i'm studying i have to convince them this is actually happening. and then i have to convince them that it's a problem in america. :::sigh:::
i'm glad the consumerist is choosing to highlight this (so much so that after years of reading daily i've finally decided to get a log-in name for commenting)
anyway, for those interested in studying or learning more about human trafficking, check out freetheslaves.net or polarisproject.org.
Read this blog a while back (Hasn't been updated in a very long time, but it puts a personal face on some of these statistics.























As long as huge majority of people only care about the price (like me) I don't have worry about crap like this increasing prices.