Buy DS Game Scribblenauts, Get Bonus Racist Symbolism
In the puzzle game Scribblenauts for the Nintendo DS, you type in names of items that appear on screen and help you complete levels. Among the tens of thousands of possibilities is one that's more than a little unnerving: type in the antiquated racial slur "sambo" and up pops a watermelon, another racist Vaudevillian symbol.
Joystiq spoke to Jeremiah Slaczka, creative director of 5th Cell, which developed the game:
Slaczka explained to Joystiq that "sambo" is used in the game as an alternate term for "fig leaf gourd," an ingredient in the Ecuadorian dish fanesca. "Sambo" is the local term for the gourd. As for the watermelon-like appearance? "We reuse art," he said. "Fig leaf gourd looks a lot like a watermelon. It's just an alternative name in a giant list of tens of thousands of names."
Wikipedia has Slaczka's back. But it's alarming that the art Scribblenauts uses for "sambo" is the same as that of "watermelon," and odd that an obscure Ecuadorian ingredient would be one of the non-cognate Spanish words to make the list. What do you think, Consumerists? Is 5th Cell on the level or covering up for an in-bad-taste inside joke?
5TH Cell: Scribblenauts' scandalous-looking 'sambo' item is a misunderstanding [Joystiq]
(Photo: Joystiq)
Post a comment
Comments:
@apd09: Well, if you believe th explanation given by the 5th Cell guy, there was never any racial connotation meant by it - presumably, the person who programmed the part didn't even know it was an old timey racial slur. I certainly didn't know that was one interpretation of it.
He's right though - the gourd does look like a watermelon.
@Pandrogas: I would also assume that this game's target demographic would have no idea about racial slurs from the 30s and 40s. [en.wikipedia.org])
@mythago: If you can make it say that for 10 minutes I would be terribly impressed. Please. Go prove yourself.
@saigumi:
I am offended by your Cracker reference as I am quite white and do not condone racist slurs! How dare you sir or madam! How dare you!
@Pandrogas: At least 1899 I would think: [en.wikipedia.org] "The story may have contributed to the use of the word "sambo" as a racial slur."
This is completely a misunderstanding and people are way too uppity anymore. As soon as it gets out what happens when you type in Jesus and Satan in the game, religious zealots are going to be all over this no one's business.
Besides, 5th Cell? They can do no wrong. Just look at their portfolio for crying out loud!
@mythago: OK, you're on.
Ten...
Nine...
Eight...
...
The wonderful thing about Wiki is if you see an article you don't like, FIX IT! :)
I'd think that you, of all people, would grok the whole Open Source, Egalitarian, Hive Mind intelligence thing, Mythgo. :D
@fnool:
I agree. Some of the suggestions are things I've never heard of and appear to be food. This is all a manufactured controversy.
Eh, I'm 29 and haven't heard that term much, in fact the only reason I probably have heard of it is because there are baby pictures of me in front of a Sambo's restaurant, which was in Tampa in 1980.
I'm not saying there is no chance that was was a racist intent, but I figure the people who looked up words and assigned art to them, were probably my age, and it wouldn't surprise me at all if they have never heard that word until this controversey came up.
I still have my copy of "Little Black Sambo" from when I was a kid somewhere in my attic. I stumbled across it a couple of years ago. I kept it for sentimental reasons but no, I won't be bringing that down to read to my kids. I can just picture it now -- "Hey, teacher, guess what book my Daddy read to me last night?" followed by a phone call home...
@mythago: can you get it to say that the autumnal equinox is a federal holiday? after this nightmare of a day, i desperately need tomorrow off. X(
@mythago: That's why it's always good to check the sources at the bottom of the page.
BTW: look up the term "fanesca" on Google and you'll see the word used as a synonym for "figleaf gourd". Wikipedia checks out.
Sounds to me like Consumerist is just looking for a story. I like you guys here, but this isn't the first time I've seen you guys knowingly leave out facts and start steering the story in a different direction in order to make it some sort of controversy to make everybody look evil.
Everybody: please read the full article after the link. It's painfully obvious that neither the company nor any of it's employees meant anything racist by this.
@fnool: This is entirely a misunderstanding. If they were trying to be racist, you'd get something like a black person, or a person in blackface, at which point outrage would be more than justified.
I'm quite surprised that the game contains balut, however. That stuff just freaks me the hell out.
@What The Geek: Have you ever seen the Target Racist Soda? There is a "white" buck toothed child" eating watermelon on one side, and a "black" child doing the same thing on the other. Then then stoke outrage by showing an "ol' timey" racist pict, then the Target soda, which of course makes an immediate connection take place.
@madog: Yea I'm leaning towards this...
Never heard the word before (other than in martial arts) and was unaware it was a racial slur. Of course ignorance is not always a valid excuse but in this case I don't think too many kids would know the sambo connection.
Well, there's some good news if you like the basic story--it's been re-published as "Sam and the Tigers" Racism-free!
@thomas_callahan: It's an oops, sure, but actual racist intent? Nah.
There's plenty of re-used art in the game, particularly amongst anything botanical, and a few very regional and very obscure words. Hell, there's over 22,000.
Sambo isn't a slur thrown around these days, and it's easy to see how it slipped through. Besides, were it intentional, I'd imagine they'd have had a child running around a tree.
@zekedms: Also, maybe I'm not remembering right, but I don't remember the book itself being racist. A little archaic in the fact it's an Indian boy being labeled as black, but wasn't the point of the story that he outwitted the tigers?
I don't see how a book gets banned because some ignorant people decide to take something out of context.
@zekedms: "I don't see how a book gets banned because some ignorant people decide to take something out of context. "
You've got to be really niggardly with your assumptions, you don't know what'll happen.
@Pandrogas: Phil sensationalizes everything in regards to videogames. He is extremely ignorant however, and only serves to spread this type of bullshit. Anyone remember the day Phil bitched out MS for not being able to use his MS points to buy new games.... when in reality the option to do so was RIGHT IN FRONT OF HIS FACE. bang up journalism there douchebag.
























Why not ask the question why the person was typing the word in the first place.