Consumer Reports Tests the ShamWow
CR moves one step closer to testing Snuggies, Tentacle Grape, and pork brains in milk gravy. [Consumer Reports Online]
Post a comment
Comments:
@richcreamerybutter: You're the one that takes out an entire row of cubicles because your feet are cold?
Now you want to look like a druid at at work?
@snowburnt: The DBAs all have matching robes and ceremonial candles whenever we need to put in a change request... I should be able to look like a tool for warmth.
I love the snarkiness, CU! It adds a lot to the entertainment value while not detracting from the information content.
Now, can you guys fill a room full of hungry cats, place a tub of Perfect Oatmeal™ in the middle of it, flip on the camera then run for your lives?
I'd find the resulting video oddly, hypnotically fascinating.
You could even make a screen saver out of it and offer it to Consumerist donators.
(hint. hint.)
Sorry, enjoyable snark aside I expect more in depth analysis from consumer reports.
The only small part of that video that was worthy of being a CR report was the determination that it holds 10x it's weight & the sponges do so also.
However, in a real CR report they would have noted that the sponges drip at 10x and if the shamwow does or doesn't. They would have also had an analysis of how much of the maximum capacity the shamwow needed to be at before it started leaving "small droplets".
Also, doing some sort of extended wear testing would be useful, they do it for paint and other stuff.
Great video, lousy CR report. I hope they haven't lowered their report standards since my subscription lapsed, it has been a couple three years.
@richcreamerybutter: As one who roasts during summer, I'd gladly buy snuggies for my coworkers if they'd complain less. But then, I'm the one who's thinking 'yeah, it's 90 outside, but I'm inside. Perhaps I shouldn't wear a light sundress and sandals inside."
This video wasn't that impressive or useful. So what if it isn't scientifically correct about how much liquid it can hold. I wouldn't be using it to carry water across my kitchen to a pot on the stove.
I want to know if it is actually good at picking up an asstastic amount of spilled liquid. I'd prefer to use one of these instead of a whole roll of paper towels. Then I can use 1 to get the droplets that are left behind.
Also - those are the cheapest sponges around, who even uses them they are worthless.
I really wanted to see them disprove the "test" where it absorbs the "cola" (which is either flat cola or just colored liquid since it doesn't fizz when he pours it) through the carpet and it's dry underneath.
The one thing I notice is that you can see a small puddle expand under the square of carpet when he pours the liquid but when the shot changes, there's no long any liquid coming from under the carpet.
@richcreamerybutter: I have 2 co-workers that sit near to me that use heaters during the summer. I'm half tempted to put an air conditioner under my desk....
@William Mize: I can't believe I'm saying "Wow," she beat up Vince (ShamWow Guy) almost as bad as that hooker who bit him. Wow!
@ShortBus: Please lighten up. This is clearly a product that does not take itself very seriously. I'm a subscriber as well and as much as the reports are useful in my buying decisions, I'm not opposed to humor with my science. The report did show that only one of shamwow's claims did in fact hold water, what was the better buy, and did it in an enjoyable easy to understand way. I'd understand if they made their riding mower section into a youtube variety show but that is all the attention the shamwow required.
@ShortBus: It's funny when I imagine what you wrote being spoken in the voice of the comic store guy from The Simpsons.
@snowburnt: Thant's me!
How do they expect me to work when my frozen fingers are incapable of typing?
@JakeChance84: What?! the shot doesn't change. Vince even says "we're gonna do this in real time". So even though it's got about 10 cuts in there, I gotta take Vince's word for it... he's a trustworthy guy...
@Gokuhouse: Just point the A/C exhaust towards your coworkers, kills two birds with one stone, and uses just as much electricity (disclaimer, using an A/C indoors will raise the temperature very quickly)
@ShortBus: If I want snarky banter, I'll come here--or practically anywhere else on the Internet. But I pay money to CR to get meaningful, un-biased information.
If they begin to focus more on selling their style over their expertise, it's a major warning sign that things are headed downhill. Call me old fashioned, but I like my facts to be boring. Adding personality to the review, by definition, adds bias.























Actually, I wish they would test Snuggies in an office setting. They could be perfect for those of us who freeze during the summer when the AC is way too high.
(I'm the one always scolded by the maintenance department when they discover my cubicle space heater.)