New Grocery Shrink Ray Makes Me Feel Dirty
The Grocery Shrink Ray has reared its ugly head again, this time hitting Dawn hand soap by nearly an entire ounce. It's amazing what they can hide in slight revisions of molded plastic.
Post a comment
Comments:
@Foibles and Weebles: Wow, yeah I missed the part where it's "hand soap," which can definitely be acceptable if it smells like apple - as far as I know, they don't make apple scented soap for dishwashing liquid. Or at least I hope they don't...but they do make lemon, so my opinion still stands.
@Foibles and Weebles: it's hand soap. Says so right under "Antibacterial". Which is the thing that would stop me from using it. (insert George Carlin immune system quote here).
@Ayanami: My kids are going to be taught that overall, mankind is good, with the exception of credit card companies and people in charge of the shrink ray.
@tekmiester: Actually, if the packages appear to be the same size, they are probably using more plastic as it would take a greater surface area to get those grooves and crevices deeper.
@Foibles and Weebles: @larrymac808: It also says "Concentrated Dishwashing Liquid" under the "Dawn" logo. Anyone who buys something called "Ultra Concentrated Dawn Concentrated Dishwashing Liquid" to use exclusively as handsoap is an idiot... with really, really dry cracked hands
@Foibles and Weebles:
It does say hand soap at the bottom, but under the word Dawn it says "Concentrated Dishwashing Liquid." And you'd probably be surprised how many scents dishwashing liquid comes in..apple, lavender, citrus, spring flowers.....
Well, as you can clearly see, the new 10.3 OZ version is 'Concentrated Dishwashing Liquid' while the old 11 OZ version is merely 'Dishwashing Liquid.' Therefore the 10.3 OZ version is at least .7 OZ better because it has another adjective used to help describe it.
As an aside, to clear up any confusion...this is a dishwashing soap that has antibacterial properties that apparently make it double as a handsoap. That antibacterial agent (triclosan) is at such a low concentration, though, that it is effectively ineffective (except when it comes to making antibiotic-resistant bacteria...but I digress).
@shepd: Its quite brilliant really, if you didn't know what the original size was, normal common sense would be "hrm, why would they advertise a smaller size, naw, must be a better value!".
@Heather A: We need to start a site or at least a listing of products that have been shrink ray'd and we just encourage people to stop buying these products. It'd be really fun to produce a roll of labels (kinda like the one's they slap on your window when you park illegally that take forever to remove)that whoever wants to, can carry with them in the grocery store and slap on the products that Consumerist has brought light to. I'd buy a roll of 100 or so.
Let's not forget that some of the store brands are actually name brands with store brand labels. The stores get a deep discount by purchasing the unused production capacity from the name brands and the name brands make some money to cover the rest of their fixed costs that they would have to pay regardless if they make a product or not.
@Squeezer99:
Quite literally, the only thing I buy with is not store-brand is instant mashed potatoes. And that is a whole $.06 more per box.
@shepd:
I don't get the criticism here. Isn't the grocery shirk ray about deception? Now it seems like we're saying they can't change the size even if they're open about it.
The reason why this and similar products say "hand soap" on them is they cannot claim the antibacterial ingredient will be effective on dishes, but if you use it to wash your hands, it will be. I've never bought any fancy brand of dish soap unless it was cheaper than the others. Who cares what the soap smells like?
@Heather A: And they tried to make it sound like a *benefit* by claiming "new size," insinuating that the old size was "worse."
@Adisharr: Kind of like when the airlines saved millions of dollars by taking out 2 olives from every salad.
@tekmiester: Probably the reverse is happening -- volume scales roughly as height cubed, and surface area as height squared, so when you take out 0.7 ounces, I bet you have more plastic packaging per ounce of soap.
@mbz32190: I only care that the soap doesn't smell bad like rotten eggs...past that, I only care about its effectiveness.
I'd usually agree with all of the 'buy the store brand comments' but i have found Dawn to be a superior product for greasy clean ups. I keep a bottle of it for just these cases and use generic brands for general cleaning. Want an endorsement for my use of Dawn? you need to go no further than any large bike race and ask the bike techs what they use for greasey-grime cleanup on the bikes and many will say Dawn. There is a better bike-specific product just recently released though, by a company called 'Pedros' that is 'green' and biodegradable...
@Heather A: Amazing is it not? I agree with you so much. Why can't we, the customers, have a standard size of everything? What is wrong with a 16oz (note: not metric size) or a 1/2 gal (again, not metric) size for what WE consume? It started with 1/2 gals of ice cream going to 1.75 liters and off to "I bet I can out confuse my customers faster and better than you."
If this were the case, I bet they'd be plastering it all over that plastic bottle of theirs.





















This practice continues to make me sick. I'd much rather they just raise the price and stop trying to deceive consumers.