Saks To Close Tween Makeover Paradise "Club Libby Lu"
Saks has announced that they will be closing Club Libby Lu, an unprofitable tween-girls "makeover" chain that apparently exists. For $25-$40 girls could paint themselves with temporary tattoos, make bracelets and get a "Club Libby Du." (We think that last thing is a hairstyle. At least, we're hoping that it is.)
Dow Jones says:
The chain, purchased in 2003 for $12 million, had 11 stores at the time and has since grown to 78 stand-alone shops and 20 locations within department stores once owned by Saks. Club Libby Lu's closure should be completed in six months.
Some 1,700 employees will be affected by the shutdown of the chain, which had nearly $60 million in sales for the year ended Feb. 2.
In an effort to fully comprehend just what has been lost, let us now read from Club Libby Lu's explanation of their services.
At the party, girls arrive at the Club. They are all greeted by a fairy and make a wish on her fairy dust. Each girl then creates her own secret Club name. Then their Libby Dus™ comes true. After dressing up and playing games, they visit our Goodie Shop and make their own Goodie Bags. Singing and Dancing, all the girls celebrate the guest of honor.
This is the part of the post where we'd write something to sort of wrap up, but we're too busy laughing and have decided to quit while we're ahead.
Saks To Close Club Libby Lu Chain After 5 Turbulent Years [CNNMoney]
Post a comment
Comments:
There's one at Downtown Disney here at the Disneyland Resort in California. I pass by it whenever I go to have dinner at the Napa Rose.
That place looks like Barbie and Paris Hilton drew up architectural designs while crashing on 'shrooms.
The Napa Rose, on the other hand, is nothing short of magnificent. Definitely worth a visit if you're ever in the area.
@Mkp-hearts-nyc: They get porny pop star makeovers, but they make a wish on fairy dust when they walk in? That does not compute for me.
OK, I propose a new rule: when you don't know what something is, you can't comment on it. Seriously. This was a place for (overindulgent and no doubt guilt-ridden) parents to have a BIRTHDAY PARTY for their daughters and all of the daughter's little friends. Don't make this out to be more than what it is.
@Crabby Cakes is SOLID AS BARACK!: They arrive there as little girls, but they leave as women?
All I know is that all the marketing materials were pink and fluffy and had faux feathers and tiaras...but little girls wound up in my store with slicked back hair, asymmetrical spandex tops and tight dance pants with fake-microphone headsets.
@CyrusOpeth: Yes- My daugher came home from a "party" at Libby Lu several years ago. She came home wearing 14 pounds of makeup and jewelry with a brochure that advertised other "makeover" parties for little girls. It's pretty much exactly as they described in the post.
@PixiePerson: THIS. They have one of these in the local mall. I walked by one time during a "dance" lesson, which was really a "teach the 6-10 year olds to bump and grind in a fashion that would make an NFL cheerleader blush." These places are Stupid Spoiled Whore madrasas.
@CyrusOpeth: ...you don't think it's worthwhile to comment on an institution that fulfills every little girls fondest dreams...as long as that dream begins and ends with a makeover? Happy Birthday, you're a year older, but why not try to regain that youthful glow you've lost since turning seven?
@Mkp-hearts-nyc: hah!
And yes, I know what this is. It doesn't make it less disgusting. And I'm saying this as someone who is fairly liberal. There's a reason the West Coast hasn't embraced the child beauty pageant scene.
Hmmm, how exactly do you "makeover" a child? "Sweetie, we're going to take yeeaars off that face...you'll have the glow of an 8 year old. And that waist? Dahling, that waist simply must be trimmed down to a svelte 12 inches. And lots of glitter, honey, lots of glitter. And my all means, you should smell like chocolate and cherries."
I have to say that I have seen one of these at the Scottsdale Fashion Square mall here in Arizona. My two girls, 7 and 13, were immediately attracted to the store. They succeeded in getting us in the door, but I quickly realized that they catered to a class I don't and probably never will belong to, one who thinks it's acceptable to spend hundreds of dollars on kids' birthday parties and other events.
At the party, girls arrive at the Club. They are all greeted by a fairy and make a wish on her fairy dust. Each girl then creates her own secret Club name. Then their Libby Dusâ„¢ comes true. After dressing up and playing games, they visit our Goodie Shop and make their own Goodie Bags. Singing and Dancing, all the girls celebrate the guest of honor.
I don't know that I could bring home a paycheck finding out what kind of marketin works on children. There seems to be a lot of lost dignity involved, on both ends.
@deadandy: I thought you were going to say, the class of people who think that whoring their children is an appropriate birthday party activity.
Not long ago a client and I were outside his office and this bright pink limo drives by with "Girl Party Limo" or something down the side. We thought, "Hey, that looks great! Let's find out what they charge." So we go inside and the secretary hears us talking about it and says it's for preteen girls. Not what we thought.
Not what we thought indeed. We were sorely disappointed.
@Canino:
You must live near the Woodlands.. I've seen that Limo before.. Anywho, My daughter wanted to work there when she turned 16. Allwell..
Disney World has 2 of them. One in Downtown Disney and one inside of the castle (inside the freaking castle!) at the Magic Kingdom. They are always full of girls and I feel sorry for them because they all come out looking the same and, in my opinion, they often tend to look a tad whorish.
I hope they close them but I have a feeling that at least these 2 locations will remain open.
This a cute store where you can do "girl" parties and play dress up and put on makeup to be like Miley or Hannah or Selena or whomever, just like you probably did as a child with your mom's makeup and high heels, only everything is kid-sized and kid-friendly. They even have a little stage area where the girls can lipsync and karaoke. Cute concept. My daughter attended a party there when she was 6 and had an OK time (she's sort of a tomboy) but it did take me an hour to get her hair unbraided and all of the glitter spray washed out.
With all of the Hannah, et al, garbage at the Walmart, it's no wonder parents would shun spending the big bucks at CLL when they can get it cheap and have the same type of party at home. Hate to see people lose their jobs, though.
@SpiderJerusalem: "disgusting?" Did you NEVER play dress up or pretend? Liberal has nothing to do with it. Imagination does.
@suzapalooza: Neither Hannah Montana nor Selena Gomez wear tube tops or shake their asses in concert, both of which are things promoted at CLL.
I am very surprised at the negative replies to this chain. I took my then 11 year-old cousin for a "mother/daughter" makeover (close enough) and it was just a fun, cute thing to do - they just do your hair and nails, put on a *tiny* amount of makeup, and make the little girl feel special. It was just a neat and extremely inexpensive (I think it was about $35 for the two of us) way to spend some time with my cousin and I don't see anything wrong with it. It sounds like the people with negative comments haven't actually gone through the process - it is not expensive, they are not trying to give the girls a real "makeover" (they use that word because it is in fashion magazines - in reality they aren't changing the girls, just playing dress up for an afternoon), there is nothing "Bratz" or "hoochie" or "Paris Hilton" about it. I am sorry to see this chain go as it was a unique experience that my cousin loved!
@suzapalooza: Playing dress-up in my house did not involve any makeup, wigs, glitter, or spending money, actually.
@suzapalooza: Of course I played dress-up. Not in slut clothes. Not trashy dress-up. I played with my parents' things. I played with dolls and stuffed animals. I didn't clamber for body glitter and trollop makeup.
@lolan64:
[www.washingtonpost.com]
I like how you're discounting other people's experiences because they have a different policy for mother/daughter than for parties.
@Canino: You see, i read that as if you and your clients were guys.
Made me spit up in my mouth a little.
@CyrusOpeth: I have a 12-year-old daughter, I've been into the Libby Lu in Downtown Disney in Anaheim, I've seen a party in progress as well as the aftermath, and it is exactly as described here (if not worse). Fortunately my daughter was only interested in the trinkets they had for sale.




















YAY! This should be on Jezebel as well. I don't like to see businesses fail, and I know employees are involved, but I praise the good taste of those who didn't bring their daughters to these places and have them remade as living Bratz dolls.