Reader Pays Off $14,330 In 20 Months With Our Tips
Stuck in a $14,300 debt hole, reader Trixare4kids was able to dig herself out using tips she learned about on Consumerist.com. Let's learn how she attacked her personal finances and learned to live frugally, and did it all in 20 months.
She writes: "This morning I made my very last payment on $14,300 in credit card debt and a personal line of credit for a home improvement project that was completed a few years ago. I paid it off over the last 20 months thanks to applying some of the stuff I learned at consumerist.com. It was tough. It took discipline, but I did it!
Instead of making a bunch of changes at once, I did things a little over time. It looked something like this. It's maybe not in the order that makes the most sense to a financial planner or in the order that someone else would do things; I just know that it worked for me.
MONTH 1: NEGOTIATING BETTER CREDIT CARDS RATES:
I called every single credit card company and tried to negotiate for a lower rate. I was successful with a lot of them. In once case the rate went from 14% to 7.99%. If they would not lower the interest rate, I politely thanked them and then transferred those balances onto lower rate cards. I canceled each card as it was paid off.
RELATED CONSUMERIST POST: Sample Script To Get Your Credit Card Rate Lowered
MONTH 2: GO CASH-ONLY:
I cut up every single card except one for emergencies. I actually put my remaining credit card in a big plastic cup full of water and stuck it in the freezer. That way, I'd really have to work at it to get that card. Cash only was the rule. If I did not have the cash, I did not need it. It's still in the freezer 20 months later.
RELATED CONSUMERIST POST: Paying Cash-Only, Family Spends $1,800 Less
MONTH 3: START DEBT-SNOWBALL:
It really works. I first heard about this method on consumerist and set myself up to pay off the lowest balances first. I used an Excel spreadsheet I downloaded here. I liked this one because it was easy to add extra one-time payments. I know that it would probably save me more money to pay off the higher interest rates first, but it was very, very satisfying to get stuff paid and DONE with. I cannot even begin to explain how highly motivating it was to finally pay something off. It was worth whatever little amount extra it cost me extra to pay the smallest balances off first. It makes for that good "light at the end of the tunnel" feeling. I also set up automatic payments on payday through the online bill pay to make this a seamless process. For the first couple of months, I just started off with just $50 extra because that's all I could afford. Once I started living more frugally, I applied more to the snowball.
Make extra payments to the snowball. They really do help, no matter how small. Every single extra penny that came my way went toward paying down the debt. At the end of the month, if I had anything left over in any of the budget categories, I immediately applied that as an extra payment. The nice thing about online bill pay is that it's just so easy to make as many payments as you want. Sometimes it was $100, sometimes it was $10 or even $3 one month, but every little bit helps. I purchased a printer that was almost free after rebate and applied the rebate to the debt. I did a few side jobs helping a caterer do some prep work; I sold some books on half.com, cleaned out my garage and made $300 from a yard sale, grandma sent me money for my birthday and Christmas, you get the idea. The point is, every single extra penny went right to the debt.
RELATED CONSUMERIST POST: Use Snowball Method Spreadsheet To Pay Off Debts
MONTH 4: SET UP BUDGET:
I made a budget and figured out where exactly my money was going.
RELATED CONSUMERIST POST: On The Money's Budget Calculator Helps Guide Your Monthly Spending
MONTH 5: CUT BACK EXPENSES:
I figured out what I could cut back on or go without. Not only did I figure out what I was giving up would save me I also diligently applied that amount to the snowball. It also really helps to figure out what something is costing you per year. I had no idea I was spending $600 a year just on manicures!
Here's what I gave up:
Cable TV. Got a cheap netflix plan and a roku player instead. Savings: $17/month, $204 a year
Land line phone. Savings: $27/month, $324/year
Gardener. Savings: $40/month, $480/year
Got slower DSL. Savings: $10/month, $120/year
Manicures. Did my own. Savings: $50/month, $600/year
Public Radio Membership. Sorry KQED and KALW, but I have to come first right now. I'll continue to support you later. Savings: $11/month, $132/year
Gym Membership. Savings: $30/month, $360/year
Lunches at work. Savings: $120 month, $1440/year
Starbucks. Savings: $60/month, $720/year
Total extra towards snowball: $365/month, $4,380/year.
Just like that.
RELATED CONSUMERIST POST: 5 Expenses You Can't Afford If You Have Credit Card Debt
MONTH 6:
I worked on cutting my spending in other ways.
I am an avid reader and I realized one of my biggest expenditures was new books. I gave up my Amazon habit and switched to the library. My local library allows you to browse the catalog online and request books be sent to the branch of your choice. I work 2 blocks from a branch so I just picked up things there. I also used paperbackswap.com, bookmooch.com and swaptree.com to give books I no longer wanted and in return get books I wanted. It only cost me the price of shipping books to other users via media mail. I saved unknown hundreds and hundreds of dollars by making this simple switch.
For example, in September, I spent $36 on postage to send out used books, books that would otherwise just be sitting around and in return I received about $300 worth of books had I bought them new at retail price. For those who are into DVDs and CDs, swapadvd.com and swapacd.com are also awesome sites. (Other than being a member, I'm not affiliated with any of those sites)
I stopped buying anything new. If I really, really needed something, I would ask first on freecycle http://www.freecycle.org/ and search craigslist for used items for sale. For example, my hairdryer stopped working about 6 months ago. Instead of running out to buy a new one, I posted an "Item Wanted" listing on the yahoo group and had a new and FREE hair dryer within 24 hours.
Food Budget: I ate the kind of things I normally eat; I just made some simple substitutions. I ate at home instead of eating out. I brought my lunch to work instead of eating out, but I did let myself eat out on Payday Friday. I used coupons and only bought very small amounts of perishable items so there was no waste. I stocked up on items like toilet paper when there was a really good sale, but was careful not to buy too many perishables. Nothing went to waste. I gave up paper towels and used rags instead. I shopped at the grocery outlet instead of Whole Foods (aka Whole Paycheck)
Instead of buying new clothes (except for bras, panties and socks) I shopped for things at thrift and consignment stores.
I know it sounds like I gave a lot of stuff up, but I don't see it that way - I kept thinking about what I was GETTING instead, which is freedom from debt. I still gave myself a small budget for entertainment and frugal dining out once in awhile, and please, nothing could induce me to give up my hairdresser!
You'd be surprised how much you can actually do for FREE if you just look around.
Free Theatre: Lots of theatres need volunteer ushers. You work in the theatre for an hour or so before the show, maybe stuffing envelopes or something. You help seat people before the show and then you get to see the show for free. You often get good seats too. I saw 3 or 4 free show a month this way. You often have to wear black
slacks or skirt and a white shirt, but that's a small price to pay for free theatre.
Artist's receptions: You get to mingle and talk with people, see some (hopefully) lovely and interesting art, plus get fed wine and cheese.
I also used squidlist to find cheap and free things to do.
HOW IT FEELS
I was disciplined and determined and I did it! Thank you consumerist! As of today I am debt free (except for my thankfully low fixed-rate mortgage) and I feel like a huge weight has been lifted from my mind. My spirit feels lighter. I am FREE. I am doing a happy dance! My plan is to continue to live frugally and start building up a savings
now. I will never, ever be in that much debt again. I never want to feel the stress an anxiety of owing so much.
Oh yeah, all during this time, I also put just $40 per month away into a savings account (ING) which I set up as an automatic $20 deduction every payday. I now have $800 to spend guilt-free and after 20 months I'm ready for a vacation. So, as my prize for getting debt free, I just booked a $295 flight to Cancun a bit later in October. I really deserve this vacation for a job well done and best of all? It's NOT going on a credit card.
Thanks, consumerist!
-trixare4kids"
Excellent work! We're proud of you, trixare. You really buckled down and make the right decisions to aggressively attack your debt. For anyone who's in debt, even if you just adopt a few things, there's a lot in here to get you further down the path towards true financial freedom.
(Photo: lemonjenny)
Post a comment
Comments:
@TracyHamandEggs!: Yes, they do. Cut your cable completely. Cut phone. Get the lowest internet speed and use skype. Stop eating fast food, Sell the newish car, get a used car and the cheap insurance that goes with that. If you want out of debt, there's ALWAYS something you can cut out.
@TracyHamandEggs!:
While I agree to a point, when we got serious about debt, we found all sorts of things we were doing. We kept takingvacations that put us in debt, we would eat out a ton, etc. There is always somwhere that can be cut. I think scaling back our lives temporarily was good because we valued the things we spent money on all the more.
That's not the point. The point is to take an honest look at how you are living and see what you can temporarily give up to reach a goal. It's not like trix* can't ever have starbucks or a new book again. Those are just some of the sacrifices she made in order to make her goal a reality.
@TracyHamandEggs!: I'm guessing Trixare4kids didn't think she did either, which is why this takes work and finagling and note-taking and figuring. Not to mention that she didn't just-like-that cut $10K. She trimmed $365 a month out of her budget. Doable for everyone? No. Doable for many? I'm gonna bet yes.
Congrats on getting out of debt! Wow. I agonize over getting a mani/pedi every few MONTHS, let alone once a month. My usual person told me ideally, I should get a pedicure every four weeks. I did the quick math and began to look at her as if she were nuts. And she was.
I agree, not everyone has 10K to trim, but I personally can attest to having some things that I could trim. BUT, I'm also not at liberty to cancel my internet or my phone or reduce my plan in such a way. We considered getting rid of one TV service (and getting something else that was cheaper, not giving it up entirely) but the early termination fees were outrageous and I doubt we could've gotten out of those. Bottom line, some places require a contract, and finding one that doesn't is pretty difficult.
Please, everyone take her advice on free theatre. Volunteering is insanely easy if you do it for smaller or mid-sized theatre companies, and the show is absolutely free. A lot of smaller companies don't even make you do the white shirt/black slacks thing. We're just happy you're there; because if you weren't there, we'd have to do it while selling tickets at the same time, which is not fun - trust me.
With theatre tix costing anywhere from $10 to $50 a pop, how can you go wrong?
takes a lot of dedication to start using free hair dryers and shopping thrift stores, not sure I'd be able to handle that.
One thing though, I don't really get everyone's aversions to credit cards when they are in debt. You can use credit cards just the same way as you do cash if you only use it for what you need and pay it off at the end of the month, plus that way if you have a decently high interest savings account you can accumulate a little interest on that money before paying it at the end of the month. Credit cards, when used correctly, are IDENTICAL to using cash except you just pay in one big lump sum. The only reason not to use credit cards is psychological, and if that's the reason for it, cool, but if people are somehow imagining a difference I don't understand why...
@billbillbillbill: But when you already take vacations once every 4-6 years (if ever), don't eat out unless someone else is paying, don't own a car, haven't had a landline in 7 1/2 years...
There really is a floor beyond which you cannot reasonably go, in many cases, and it's frustrating to be at or near that floor and still have debt. I think that's the gist, there.
The snowball method does work, we compiled it and it stated that it would take 39 months to pay off $20k in debt. We set a goal for 2 years and amoritized all of our debt, and got it paid off in half the time of the snowball for a $14/month difference.
I should write a book and get on the radio. I could be a multi-millionaire like some other guy in my city.
www.daveramsey.com
You would be surprised.
People have monthly expenses that they pay unconconciously. 120 comcast bundle? That's $2400 a year. And some of it is rounding up. Someone might not get lunch out every day, but calculates it as if they do.
Really this is the full plan for putting the financial house back in order. If everybody did this, in a year or two, everybody that had a job would be debt-free and contributing to their savings. As an added plus Starbucks would be out of business.
I've ushered in theaters numerous times. As the article indicates, it's free and pretty easy (depending on the layout of the theater). I've seen big names like Rodney Dangerfield, David Copperfield, and Penn & Teller this way. I've also seen plenty of well known dramas & musicals like A Christmas Carol, Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf, etc.
Another way to save money, if you like live theater, is to go to amateur community theater productions instead of the big professional ones. True, some amateur productions can be pretty bad, but there are a lot of community theaters in the towns around where I live and work, and many of them have very good reputations. You can likely volunteer at them to see shows for free, or if you just want to see the show they're usually 2 to 3 times cheaper than a professional one. You can find some community theaters in your area using this search form: [aact.matchingneeds.com]
Now we know who's sending the economy down the crapper!!
I kid... this is inspiring. Well done Trix. We should all be so disciplined!!
@TracyHamandEggs!: Me included, I can cut out energy drinks, that's about it. I don't eat out much, don't have cable, don't have a landline, and don't go shopping. I suppose I could get slower broadband but I really don't want to.
I'm moving to an apartment in the ghetto to try to pay off my debt faster. *shakes fist at health insurance company
@EtoilePB:
Everyone figures out what works for them, and there are really very few people who absolutely cannot cut costs any more than they do and be in debt. Those people should be on some sort of government assistance.
@TracyHamandEggs!: Oh yes there is. I think the concept should be what you are wiling to "sacrifice" rather than "trim". You don't have to have cable or an iPhone or a 10mbps $50 internet connection.
@shorty63136: So have them pay for it? If they insist on the higher priced services, that's their cost.
@EtoilePB: If you're at that point and you still have a significant amount of debt, then it's time to consider bankruptcy.
Congrats -- I'm sure you're loving every minute of your success! I managed to get to zero a few years ago (before I bought my apartment), and it is amazing how much extra pocket money you have once everything is paid off.
One extra piece of advice. If you feel too guilty for cutting out non-profits, you can always volunteer for them -- many need helpers as much as cash. I spent a good part of two years volunteering for Habitat for Humanity.
I started using the public library recently too. The online catalogue and branch transfer is excellent! It's saved me so much money. I highly recommend this.
I wish I could cut my cable. I could live without it since I don't watch much TV, and I could Netflix any shows that I want to watch. Unfortunately it's rolled into my HOA dues so I don't have a choice.
Another way you can save on grocery bills is to buy your fruits and veggies at your local farmers market. You can save a LOT of money this way and the variety and quality is a lot better too (or at least it is where I live). I buy large quantities at a time, spend a weekend cooking, and then freeze it. I freeze enough for a month of lunches. It saves me time on cooking too. I eat fruit for dinner, which is a lot cheaper than cooking a full meal. This winter when the farmers market doesn't have a good variety I will buy fruits and veggies at Costco. I always buy my meat at Costco and freeze it.
We only eat out for dinner once a week. It's our last remaining splurge. I'd hate to have to give that up. It may come to that soon though.
I don't have much in the way of debt but I am trying to live more frugally in an attempt to increase my savings accounts incase I lose my job soon. I work for a landscape architecture firm, an industry hit hard by the downturn in the housing market.
@Necoras:
Not true at all.
I'm a college student, take the bus everywhere, don't have a land line, don't eat out, moved back home to live with my parents to CUT my expenses, buy all my clothes secondhand and still have about 9000 of debt over my head already, which I am attempting to even put a small amount of money towards but have no time to work as I'm carrying 18 credits and 6 extracurriculars to look good for grad school.. in 2 years.
It's not just about the person. It's about their surroundings and background as well. College is more expensive than ever and getting out of those loans is hellish.
@ilves: The difference is the discipline that credit cards require. You have to say NO to the temptation to overspend. If you stick to cash, you won't overspend (as much).
Also, you could end up shooting yourself in the foot...paying off the new balances first and not making a dent in the higher interest old balances, depending on how the CC company applies your payments.
I agree, if you have the discipline to handle credit, then by all means do so. You can save/earn a lot by using a credit card.
But for someone trying to get out of CC debt, freezing the card is a great way to go. Whatever works for you, do it.
@TracyHamandEggs!: Isn't that the truth! I'm impressed that she achieved what she did, but I'm also shocked that what she was spending in a month at Starbucks was almost as much as I spend on groceries.
Way to go Trix. We worked a similar plan in 2006 (Ramsey's Total Money Makeover) and paid off $55,500 in debt in 12 and half months.
I had a pedicure on Saturday and enjoyed every minute. Some how not having debt and paying cash (or debit) for all our purchases (except travel and large purchases that we want/need extra protection and for which we have saved up the cash in order to pay off the CC ASAP) makes those little treats that much sweeter.
There was an article on Yahoo.com (cause aren't they the epitome of quality personal finance advice?) that was about saving $1,000 for Christmas. When I first started reading it, I thought, "why do you need $1,000 for Christmas?" And I think that's one of the reasons why we're shooting ourselves in the foot with debt.
We have a culture that wants to condemn people for being in debt, but does not necessarily (as a whole) facilitate people avoiding debt. I don't think there's enough education about financial responsibility, but at the same time, there are articles like [finance.yahoo.com] that assume you should have $1,000 for Christmas. As if the holidays are just SO important that if all the adults don't get a gift, they'll all cry. Or if a child doesn't get a $10 toy he/she will play with and ignore within a month, he/she will end up in therapy later in life.
I love spending money, I do. But this Christmas, we're all on a budget. I hate that there are articles advising people to cut extras not to save money, but to pay for GIFTS.
Awesome, it gives me hope. I always pay about 2x as much as the minimum for each of my 2 credit cards, recently both cards lowered my interest rate to 10% (sweet), but somehow something comes up every month that requires me to use one of the cards: vet bill, car repair, etc. My new project is to learn how to sew...because as much as I like clothes, some things I just don't want to pay $40+ for.
Congratulations.
However, canceling cards as they are paid off is a fast way to destroy your credit score. Never cancel the cards. Just pay them off.
Your credit score is partially calculated using the amount of available credit you have vs. how much you use. When you close an account, you actually reduce your available credit line and can annihilate your good credit you earned by paying it down.
























KUDOS! :)