Europe vs USA: Who's Handling The Crisis Better?
The debate on the BBC news right now is who is cooler, America or Europe. Europe is getting props for acting speedily and decisively in contrast to Paulson's pace, which is getting characterized as dawdling and indecisive. Some of the very policies Treasury derided, they're now considering since Europe enacted them. The ex-Reagan economic adviser talking head says it's nationalizing risk, a backdoor way of calling them socialists. However, it wasn't until Europe's "socialistic" actions did the markets rebound. Who is right? Only time will tell; we'll see if the rally sustains or is just another fitful shiver in this economic fever dream. The key here is confidence, and it seems to be the most precious and rare commodity on the face of the earth right now.
Post a comment
Comments:
@anonymousryan: Here is Paul Krugman's analysis... [www.nytimes.com]
Bottom line: The Brits moved faster and had a deeper bench of intellectually capable people to deal with the mess. Whereas, the White House (and its Treasury) failed on speed and skills.
@AlexPDL: Ah, Krugman is always appreciated. I think he nails it on the head, the idea of taking partial public ownership of a private firm simply sends the neo-conservative into a red panic.
for the record
government sponsored corporations and subsidization of industry is characteristically fascist more so than it is socialist. socialist is more about excess in public goods; fascism is private industry flush with government capital to encourage national economic expansion and independence.
@panzerschreck1:
Do you have an example from a fascist regime (Spain, Argentina etc?) besides the national socialists?
@no.no.notorious: my point is that not all of europe is a happy place where they hand out free medication and the public transit is flawless.
i know russia isn't socialist, incase that's lost in translation
@Josh:
Once the mortgages have diminished as a threat to the banks, or once the chaos spreads to become larger than it should be if the only problem were mortgages, yes, it is a matter of confidence.
@no.no.notorious:
I shouldn't think so. Russia isn't really Europe, they're kind of their own thing.
The US has two parties under orders from lobbyists. The Europeans have a shitload of countries with at least three parties in each, and a union government to deal with as well.
When governments are in disagreement and have to work together, lobbyists for businesses are useless. The US economy is going to implode, while the Europeans will clean up their mess and get back to business as usual - unfortunately.
What in the world is it going to take for Milton-Friedmanesque laissez-faire economics to be discredited as the misguidedly blind orthodoxy it is? At this point in civilization's history -- that is, after so many failed attempts at each -- it's pretty clear that neither pure capitalism nor pure socialism works. Each has its merits, and there's nothing wrong with cherry-picking these and coming up with some kind of hybrid, as most non-American democracies have done, mostly with considerable benefit to their societies.
Yes, people need the freedom to forge their own destinies. But regulation and social programs are also necessary in order to check both corporate corruption and the beating-down of citizens who are poor or weak through no fault of their own.
In other words, I hope it's soon beyond the realm of argument that the European/Canadian economic model is both more humane and generally works better than the American system of the past decade -- the one that's led the world economy to its current crisis.
Captain America dies and comes back all the time just like every other comic character. Right now Bucky (NooOooOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOO!!!!!!!) is Cap. Previously, there was another Cap when Steve died a different time who has now come back for another round; I suppose as an evil Cap (I haven't really been keeping up).
@no.no.notorious: Different name tag, same situation AS NOW IN USA!
Corruption killed URSS. Now it's USA's turn.
(By the way, Russia is verrry capitalist now. More than USA. The strong survives and weak get swept under the carpet.)
@ARP:
I excluded Germany because they a socialist regime (and I was trying to leave nazis out of it). I will have to go back the books on fascist Italy to check their relationship with the industrialists and socialism.
















Cavuto says America. QED.