This "Labor Day" Car Ad Was Very Well Thought Out Indeed
Reader David asks:
What is with the pregnant woman drinking champagne in the ad on this page!?!
Oh, c'mon, David. She's just having one for the road! Don't be such a square.
Happy Labor Day everyone!
This is a test using rich text formatting and html links. It's the generic "company" ad that should appear on all posts with the Company category if they don't have an ad attached to a specific company.
Post a comment
Comments:
@Git Em SteveDave displays attention-grabbing vanity: I'm sure one crack rock won't kill the child either. Everything is okay in moderation...
@Git Em SteveDave displays attention-grabbing vanity: The Europeans don't think song. Especially once you're past 8 months and all the important parts are done being made.
It's still a pretty big fail as far as ads go.
1. You don't know she's pregnant. And my rule of thumb as has always been, if you don't actually see a baby coming out of the birth canal, don't assume a woman is pregnant.
2. You don't know she's drinking champagne. Could be sparkling cider or apple juice or what-the-hell-ever.
3. Even if she's drinking champagne and she's pregnant, so what. Nobody ever got fetal alcohol syndrome because they're mom had one or two sips of champagne.
We've turned into a nation of worry-worts.
@Git Em SteveDave displays attention-grabbing vanity: One drink is how the pregnancy got started in the first place, so I don't see the harm :)
@Git Em SteveDave displays attention-grabbing vanity: I'm no doctor either, but my ex's aunt told us that she could have one glass of wine a day as per HER doctor.
She still drank like 4, but still. One drink does not a 4-legged baby make.
Multiple fail...
She's drinking something out of a champagne glass (so regardless of what it is, you see it, you think champagne).
Apparently while pregnant
AND
In relation to buying a new car.
Knock that ONE drink back and go for a test drive, weee DUI. She looks fairly petite, baby notwithstanding, one drink consumed right before driving could possibly put her at the .08 BAC and/or it might affect her enough to be dangerous.
Not the best thought out ad.
@dragonvpm: I do agree with the multiple fail. However to correct you on one thing, 1 drink would not put her at the .08 level. If she were 100 lbs, it would put her at max .029. Now, being pregnant, she's probably closer to about 120 lbs (just guessing), where 1 drink would put her at a max .021. That's assuming 1 glass of 4-5 oz. of wine. Drunk? No. Impaired? Probably not. But still really in bad taste!
(Note: Looking at the various BAC charts on the web, it appears there is not a consensus BAC level by sex, weight and # of drinks. Guess we should probably pull out a breathalyzer!)
@Cupajo: I believe she has to be pregnant to make the Labor Day joke that's the point of the ad.
However, I agree with you and most of the posters here that there's not exactly a medical consensus that one drink of champagne is damaging. That's more of an American frenzy than a medically tested idea.
@nicemarmot617: "Now drinking and driving is another story! "
Umm...she's not driving. It's tricky to tell, but one clue might be that she's not inside the car.
@floraposte: "I believe she has to be pregnant to make the Labor Day joke that's the point of the ad."
Fair enough, but I would hasten to point out that "We're having a labor day sale" is not really a joke. Especially when it's a sale that ends on September 2nd. Hell, maybe she's just fat.
My wife's OB said that the main reason they say NO alcohol is because people have no self control or self awareness. If you tell everyone it's OK to have an occasional drink while pregnant then a fair chunk of women will be knocking back a six pack every Friday and Saturday night, which would be excessive. A glass of wine with dinner now and then was OK with him, but you have to assume that the general public are idiots.
My girlfriend is an obgyn, and i've read the text books.
Look up Fetal Alcohol Syndrome - [www.cdc.gov] It's not pretty.
This is hilarious. People take themselves way too seriously. There's a fine line between an occasional drink and turning your baby into a poster child for fetal alcohol syndrome. Maybe we could call the OP's pic "fetal champagne-alcoholic syndrome."
Also, this reminds me of a hilarious Jane magazine prank a few years ago where women wore fake pregnancy bellies and went to bars and got drunk and bummed cigarettes off people.
@digitalhen: READ the textbooks, or LOOKED at the pictures?
As far as the drinky...she's not drinking it, she's serving it to her man like any good woman should.
@Cupajo: I don't think the sale itself is meant to be a joke, just that her pregnancy is meant to be a visual gag on the term. But I agree it's not the most obvious thing in the world--then again, it doesn't look like the most high budget of ads.
@digitalhen: People aren't suggesting there's no such thing as FAS or that it's a picnic. People are pointing out that there's no evidence that a glass of champagne causes it, and that plenty of doctors are aware of that too.
@Git Em SteveDave displays attention-grabbing vanity: A recent study showed that women who drank one glass of wine a day in the last trimester of their pregnancies had children who were generally above-average in cognitive development, as compared to women who did not drink during pregnancy, whose children tended more towards average developmental stages. One theory is that the children of the women who drank underwent less stress in the uterus.*
Doctors may also recommend a little wine in the beginning of pregnancy to prevent miscarriage, or a little at the end to prevent early delivery - alcohol stops uteran contractions.
However, I'm not sure if the woman in that picture is supposed to be pregnant, or supposed to have her thumb hitched in her pocket, or supposed to have a weird hip growth - the perspective on that photo is very odd.
[*I can't find the damned cite. There are plenty of studies that say the exact opposite, of course. I think one problem with these studies may be false reporting - a woman may say she has 4 glasses of wine a week or less, but if it's self-reporting, it's more difficult to determine how large those glasses are, whether it was more like six...]
@Git Em SteveDave displays attention-grabbing vanity: One drink is fine. A very small amount of alcohol after the 1st trimester is fine.
My sister in law works for one of these agencies that put together newspaper advertisements. They send the job offshore, where many times the worker simply grabs some clipart and adds it to the advertisement. In this case, it sounds like the offshore worker didn't understand what the American version of Labor Day really meant and it must have passed the stateside audit before being approved.
@All the it's milk/non-alcoholic comments:
If this were a photo or video of a real customer in a car dealership I'd be with you. However, this is an ad and in an ad if someone is holding a champagne glass it's a pretty safe bet that we're supposed to think that it has champagne or wine in it. They had to know that's what most people would assume when looking at the ad.
I'm with dragonvpm. A car ad is not high art or a complex novel. It's pretty much WYSIWYG and what you see is a pregnant woman drinking out of a champagne glass standing next to the car they want us to buy. In real life you don't know if she's pregnant or if that's alcoholic but for an ad this is very, very bad.
@Mr_Mantastic: 0.0% is better than 0% when 0% is actually 0.4%.
@floraposte: I'm pretty sure drinking during pregnancy is something that must be studied, not tested.
I remember my mother telling me that back when she was pregnant with me the doctor told her to have a glass of wine to calm her before bed. Also he told her that coffee in the morning helped with morning sickness. And there was nothing said about the bad effects of cigarettes. I was remarkably small at birth and I have sort of misshapen hands and feet now but this was in Poland in the '70s so I don't know what that says.
@Git Em SteveDave displays attention-grabbing vanity:
You know I just had this conversation with a few of my wifes' (very pregnant) friends.
Apparently alcohol is a no-no during early pregnancy, but in small amounts later during the pregnancy (third trimester) aren't harmful. It seems its really only harmful before the baby is fully developed, before the 3rd trimester.
My wife wouldn't take a drink regardless, but it was odd to hear the reality of it all.
On the other hand, is it something you really want to advertise with a national ad? I don't think so....maybe in France, but not here :)
























hahahahahahaha.
If I were a woman, I'd love to go in to labor no where else than in a 2008 Toyota Sienna.