That's actually a really good scam. Most of the time I say things like "who would fall for that?" But I can see this catching a lot of people.

Thanks so much for reporting it here.

Just one more reason to drive.

Strange story, good lesson to learn, man really got scammed, etc., etc., etc.

But the part of this story that really jumped out at me was ".... and handed him all the money I had ($15 tip + $3 fee)".

Do people really travel with NO cash? Are you kidding me?

I always weigh my bags first. I live 2 blocks from a ups store and know the owner and he lets me use the scale. I always try to make my bags 7lbs lighter than the limit to make up the difference if they have a shady scale at the airport.

I'm not usually a blame the victim guy, but you have to be a little more careful here. I know you may have been in a hurry and all, but you should have asked to see the actual weight of the bag.
Even if it HAD weighed over 50lbs, what assurances do you have that this checker would have actually gotten it onto the plane? You may well have ended up at your destination airport, explaining that "the guy told me he'd put it on for a big tip." And getting blank stares..
That being said, this checker was a total scumbag. Way to go reporting him/her!

I normally check my bags at the ticket counter as I heard horror stories like this of curbside check-in and not to mention those attendants aren't really employees of the airline or the airport; just people contracted for that.

@msbask: I literally cannot remember the last time I held paper currency. Do people really still use cash?

50 pounds is a LOT of stuff for traveling by plane. People are going to have to get used to making do with a small carry-on or sending their stuff by FedEx or paying $$$ for checking a bag.

I'm with carso, cash is soooo 2002.

It's not as bad as those VISA commercials, but at least with CC transactions I feel more comfortable re: fraud protection, plus the ability to analyze my spending habits is sweet.

Wait, so the problem is you got burned trying to cheat the system? Tough shit. Live and learn.

So even though this whole situation sucks, you kind of deserved it. I mean you pretty much did what amounts to BRIBERY to circumvent the system. Granted you should never have been forced to and the porter is a low-life scumbag. Lesson learned.

@carso: Cash works just fine when your credit card company arbitrarily decides that using your credit card 1500 miles from home is worthy of being considered fraud.

Check the luggage department at Target or Wal-Mart, they have recently had luggage scales for about $10. Then check sporting goods at Wal-Mart; I got a similar scale, with a built-in tape measure, for $5. These things are not trade quality, but they are small enough to fit IN your luggage.

@evslin: Cash also works well when you're mugged for the entire amount in your wallet and can't get it back, whereas with a credit card you can report it stolen and are only liable for $50. My dad learned this the hard way when his ginormous George Castanza wallet was stolen during a break-in, and he lost $600+. He now uses a bank card and doesn't carry that much cash.

Caveat Emptur

I hadn't meant to turn this into a paper vs. plastic discussion. Obviously each has its own pros and cons. Staying on topic, I do feel bad for the submitter, it was a hell of a scam. Makes you wonder how the guy that hatched the scheme ended up working luggage at JFK.

Not much sympathy here, any more than I'd have if you were overtipping the bartender to get him to only ring up every other drink, and then found out it was two-for-one night.

Stuff like this is why you should always try to get to the airport early and check-in anywhere but curbside. If you have... HAVE to check your bag at the curb, the standard tip is roughly $1 or $2 per bag. Be advised that this is ON TOP OF whatever the airline decides to charge you for it by way of "convenience fee", so you're potentially looking at $5 minimum per bag.

As someone said earlier, there's no guarantee your overweight bag won't be discovered somewhere before it makes it to the plane.

The OP Was clearly taken advantage of. Kudos for not "taking it" and reporting the guy.

OP got scammed trying to scam the airline. Very nice. Next time: go inside and have your bag weighed.

This isn't all that uncommon. I've certainly 'bribed' curbside attendants before when I knew my bag was overweight. However, this attendant's behavior was atrocious and I never would have dealt with someone that blatant.

And not to blame the OP, cause the attendant sounds like scum, but maybe the bag really did come in over 50 pounds at the airport. When a bag is ~45-50 pounds, you run into sort of a grey area. Not all scales are perfectly calibrated, and what is 48 pounds at home may be 51 at the airport, and by the time you get to the check-in counter, you're SOL if their scale comes up higher.

@MercuryPDX: And to qualify, YES he was trying to get around the system which is "wrong". The nature of the scam preys on the time-sensitivity of catching your flight and an exorbitant overweight baggage charge. The temptation is just too great for some.

@MercuryPDX:
"As someone said earlier, there's no guarantee your overweight bag won't be discovered somewhere before it makes it to the plane."

That's not really a concern in modern airports. Bags are only weighed at the point of entry, and no special mark is put on the bag to show that extra fare has been paid, though that certainly may change as airlines fight for every last bit of revenue.

@basket548: I've seen orange "Overweight Bag" stickers applied on the side of the luggage to give the handlers extra warning, but it may be for bags grossly over the 50 lb. limit.

Well in my opinion he got what he deserves for trying to go around the system (even though he may not have had an overweight bag since the scale could have been off)

It's like buying illegal drugs, then find out they are bad and then going to the cops to tell them that someone sold him bad drugs.......

Haha, that's funny. Sounds like you get what you deserve.

First of all, you know the rules so weigh your bag ahead. Then rearrange some of it into your carry-on if you can. And, whether or not it was overweight, you took his word and tried to cheat the system making you as dishonest as the handler, so suck it up.

@james: You know, if he started making outrageous claims that he wanted ALL the money back I'd be all for hammering on the OP a little harder. I think he not only learned his lesson but was nice enough to share that with the rest of us.

Let's not make it so that people DON'T want to submit experiences like this for the rest of us and cut some slack when it's due.

Anybody that has traveled through a less developed country has learned that scam artists learn their trade at the local international airport. Just goes to show we are not as advanced as we thought we were.

Thanks for sharing and please ignore all the 'im too smart for that scam' and 'you deserve it' arrogant jerks.

@msbask: If he was going home (which the story indicates), then yes... I can see how he would only have $18 on him.

Kind of reminds me of that episode of COPS where the crack addict calls the cops because a crack dealer took her money without giving her any crack.
Do you really want to report to a company that you thought you were ripping them off, only to find out that you didn't actually rip them off and got ripped off yourself?
It is a tempting scam to attempt though... $35 is a nice dinner.

@DeanOfAllTrades: Yeah, he BRIBED an airline official to allow his underweight baggage on. Based on information that the agent made up in order to make him think his bag was overweight.

@MercuryPDX: I've gotten that tag before, either when my bag is 51/52 pounds (they didn't charge me for it) or once when I was traveling with some weights (don't ask) and my very tiny bag weighed almost 40 pounds. I think it's more for the luggage handlers than it is to prove payment. But then again I don't really know.

If I thought my bag was overweight, I would probably pay the guy. Although, I would be worried about it being measured more than once.
If I found out it wasn't overweight, I might tell my friends that I was scammed, but don't think I would report it to anyone official.

Hey, don't ruin it for the rest of us!

I really did have an overweight bag and tipped the curb side guy (who did NOT suggest it) so I didn't have to pay the fee.

I suppose you just have to know when your bag is truly overweight..... :)

Just thinking... if your bag is marked as weighing one amount at one point at the airport, then weighing another amount at another point, without you having contact with it, could it be confiscated as suspicious for smuggling/terrorism?

@carso: Yes, it's usually green paper with pictures of dead presidents on it. Although more devalued every day, still easier to carry than bags of salt or animal hides for trade.

On the plus side, your luggage didn't end up on a different plane going to a different destination.

@evslin: Pick up the phone and spend a few minutes informing them you are heading 1500 miles from home if it's not your usual pattern. *Never* had a problem when I've travelled to odd places and countries because I do that.

I HAD A SIMILAR INCIDENT!

Sorry for the caps but all should read this post. I usually Fly Southwest when i can, yes i know its a cattle car but it gets me where i need to be with out the bs. I had to fly delta to visit my father in law. I weighed my bag at the electronic checkin. And lets be real here for a sec, i fly a high amount for work so I know exactly what i pack and i know its never over, usually around 40 lbs.

I weigh in and the obviously bothered by my presence woman looked at the weight on the scale and it read 52 lbs, 12 pounds more than normal. She said it was over weight and would have to change me, I of course took issue with this and insisted she weigh it on another scale, she gave me a lot of shit, and finally when i said I'm not moving and you're not charging me another dime, i want to see the manager now, she proceeded to weigh it on another scale, the next scale read 48lbs. I looked at her and said.. wow how odd, your other scale is off 4 lbs. She scoffed and took started printing my bag tag, at that moment i grabbed my bag and threw it on yet another scale, "41 lbs". "WOW, your first scale was off 11 lbs, and your other one was off 7 lbs. Nice scam you're running here". I turned around and spoke loudly, "if your bag is overweight, make sure you get it weighed on multiple scales, i just weighed my bag on 3 of them and each of them were off."

Moral of the story, weigh your bag before you leave home, if its overweight dont just take their word for it, they hope you pay for the overage with cash and they just pocket it.

smart consumers usually have more money in their pockets.

I would have definitely asked to see it if I was not shown how much the weight actually was. (of course I would have weighed it myself first too)

But I've seen people willingly pay off the curb-side check in people when they were even overwight and were told about it. Recent trip to Vegas - I saw a girl semi-turning on the charm gun to a curb side check-in guy and giving him $10 to sneak in her 60lb bag...

I love all the comments saying the guy was trying to get away with something, even though his bag wasn't overweight.

This is the typical argument that tricky cops use to turn their entrapment techniques into convictions. And they fail quite often.

The question is, did the OP go into the transaction thinking he had an overweight bag, or did the agent convince him in order to gain financial benefit? The OP says "When he returned he told me my bag was overweight and there is a $50 fee for any baggage over 50lbs."

So was the OP convinced he had an overweight bag, and started looking for a cheaper way? Not according to the OP...

"Before I could even respond with "are you kidding me?" he told me he could he get it through if I "gave him a big tip"."

So without the OP even speaking a word, the agent (1) lied to him about his baggage weight, and (2) set up the scam.

That's pretty clear entrapment. I don't see any intent to defraud on the part of the OP.

He got scammed twice - the overweight fee for JetBlue's domestic flights is $20 for 51 - 70 lbs., not $50. It'd have to weigh over 70 lbs. to be charged $50 - presumably he would know if it was THAT heavy. See: [www.seatguru.com]

Still, I agree with some of the folks here that he shouldn't have been trying to scam the airline, either.

Being a skycap was a big money maker at one time. A CBS or a Newsweek report back in the 90's once said that at a busy airport these guys could fist away $100,000.00 or more a year in tips. Once all of the security measures took affect I always wondered how they would try to recoup their losses when they couldn't check bags but could only haul them to the counter for you.

Hey, that's bribe money the airline could have used...

Going by car is looking better by the minute. Who needs all this b.s?

I personally can travel for a week with a bag weighing 30lbs or less...

I wonder what would have happened if the OP had called out the curbside checker on the bag's weight/attempt to bribe? Would the checker then have retaliated by putting his bag on the wrong plane? I'm always afraid to piss off or call someone out who is in charge of my luggage.

@avsfan123: I traveled to Hong Kong and Tokyo for 2.5 weeks with a carry on and a laptop bag once.

I hope they don't use check-in as the criteria for estimating and summarizing baggage weight on small commuter flights, especially if caps are slipping overweight bags through for an extra tip.