What Do You Do When Your Moving Company Destroys Everything You Own?
What should you do when you carefully pack all of your belongings into a truck for a cross country move and the driver promptly drives under a bridge that's a couple feet shorter than said truck? That's the question that one couple is asking after their move from Boston to Oakland, CA went horribly awry. They shared their story with a Boston alumni email list and one user posted it to LiveJournal. Their letter, plus a gallery of photos generously donated by eyewitness (and Flickr user) K a t m, inside.
Hello all,
This is my first time posting to this list and I'm hoping that someone will be able to help! My husband and I contracted with a moving company, Broadway Express, to drive our belongings from Boston to Oakland, CA. Yesterday, after the truck was packed by local professional movers, the Broadway Express driver drove down Mt. Vernon Street, turned onto Storrow Drive and promptly hit the Longfellow Bridge (11' clearance and a 13' 6" truck), shearing off the entire top and sides of the truck and distributing our belongings across the road. We have the standard moving insurance offered by this company, which is $0.60/lb. In retrospect, we should probably have tried to get better coverage, but who would have thought that the truck driver would try to scrape the top 2.5 feet off of his vehicle?
My question for the list is: does anyone have experience in dealing with a total moving disaster? How can we maximize our reimbursement? Most of the furniture was damaged and a good deal was totally destroyed. The moving company claims that we need to pay for the move in order to file a claim, so they have already charged my credit card. This was our first experience using professional movers and I can't say I enjoyed it.
Thank you in advance for any advice and let me know if you'd like to see pictures -- I have a ton.
Best,
Unfortunate People
Has anything like this ever happened to you? Any advice for these people?
Don't hire Broadway Express as your moving company [Universal Hub]
More info on the bridge crash [LiveJournal]
(Photos: K a t m )
GALLERY







END
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nam malesuada commodo erat et molestie. Duis pellentesque aliquam bibendum. Suspendisse venenatis lobortis eleifend. Mauris id est sed lectus convallis aliquam.
Post a comment
Comments:
Find a lawyer and take them to court for full re-reimbursement of your goods. Also, you should not have to pay for the move seeing as how the move didn't actually occurred. You may have to pay a small amount for the labor of the packing crew but that should be it.
That wreck was caused by total negligence on the drivers part. There is no way he should have attempted to cross under that bridge with that truck.
Good luck and let us know how it works out
I used to commute down Storrow Drive into Cambridge and a week wouldn't go by when some idiot decided to ignore the laws regarding height limits on their vehicles and destroyed their vehicle, damaged the roadway or ruined goods they were carrying. I've seen entire tops torn off box trucks on this road, making very large sardine cans. This is BY FAR the worst I've ever seen. Since your driver ignored local laws and NUMEROUS overheight signs posted, they are subject to fines from the government and you may have charges of gross negligence against them. Contact a LAWYER (God knows there are enough in Beacon Hill).
Chargeback + ask for reimbursement of goods (be ready to show proof of worth for each item damaged/destroyed)
Possibly get ready to sue
I think a moving company would be considered a common carrier... if that is the case the only times they are NOT liable are:
-An act of nature (self-explanatory... tornado for example)
-An act of the public enemies (terrorists blowing up your truck)
-Fault or fraud by the shipper (not packing your goods well enough)
-An inherent defect in the goods (shipping milk in a non reefer truck)
However... if they are a private carrier look over the contract.
@magic8ball: hold off on that. Depending on how their insurance works the payment might need to be processed for it to kick in (I know thats stupid, but it makes sense that they would need payment to activate the contract.)
@ffmariners: I just looked it up... Broadway Express provides moving services under their common carrier authority
I would think Home owners insurance would cover this, but that would depend on the policy.
I would consult an attorney as the drivers insurance should cover this as I'd imagine this business is insured and has driver insurance as well both should easily cover this however they don't see it this way see below.
I would believe that regardless of what you paid for insurance from this company should not matter, as this is a gross act of incompetence and if you took them to court you should win.
I'd sue for around 50k.
If you maintained your homeowner's insure, it may likely cover the damage.
It may also be worth paying for a consultation with a lawyer. The insurance you took out with the mover is generally understood to cover accidental damage that is routine in the course of a move. What happened here is gross negligence. Was the driver ticketed by police? Was a drug / alcohol test performed? Even if the police didn't do this, most companies who employ drivers require testing after an accident. Is this the company's policy and did they follow their own policy?
That makes me cringe. We had a cross-country move in 2004, from Columbus, Ohio to San Diego, California (yay, ocean again!).
What we thought was a moving company was actually an agent, and the deposit we paid was actually their fee for performing a service we could have performed ourselves. They said that everything would be shipped on the same truck all the way, and it wasn't, the shipment was a few weeks late, and we ended up having to pay a couple of thousand extra because the weight was underestimated, or so we were told.
Never again. Next time, we'll pack what we need in the cars and ship the rest using a freight company, which I've heard is a better option.
The first thing to do is get the trucking insurance and start from there. Usually all the insurance people will talk with each other and determine how much each of them are responsible and will come back with an offer. You are going to be dealing with at least three possible different carriers (voluntary moving insurance, trucking/auto policy, and the insurance the business has). As for paying before a claim...I would have laughed at them and went straight to their moving/trucking policy. Might want to get ready for a charge-back.
I would suggest NOT doing a chargeback. The charge is fraudulent, since they charged for a service (moving to Oakland) that was not delivered.
Once you intstitute a chargeback and it's sucessful, you now you have less to go after them for legally. (The credit card bill is no longer part of the damages, since you've remedied the problem before a lawsuit is filed).
@parliboy: Plus Storrow drive is clearly marked as "cars only." The driver is clearly, totally and completely at fault, and the moving company's insurance should cover everything.
Having worked at a moving company long ago (mid 90's), it will be a FIGHT for you to get more than the .60 cents per pound per article the insurance defaults to if you didn't buy more insurance. The moving companies hold this to be as self evident as the Constitution.
You MAY have better luck suing the driver for HIS personal negligence because the company guaranteed will say YOU signed off on the 60 cents.
You MIGHT be able to ge the company IF they provide the GPS for the truck if it's company owned.
I hope you do get your money back (obviously your stuff is ruined)
Everyone needs to remember they are a common carrier... which means they are automatically liable unless:
1) act of nature
2) act of enemy of the state
3) fault or fraud of shipper (the homeowners)
or
4) inherent nature of the goods
because of the gross negligence (unforeseeable) they should be able to sue for more than the 60 cents. It is foreseeable that a few things will get broken on the drive... just because of turns and bumps and yada yada and that is what the 60 cents coverage is for. But it is not foreseeable that the truck will break everything running into a bridge.... Let a judge decide!
> the trucker was in an accident, seems his insurance should cover it
This is NOT an accident, it is negligence. Truckers have access to maps indicating bridge heights, road weight limits, etc. so that they can plan their routes in advance. Nothing about hitting a bridge is ever accidental.
This person NEEDS a lawyer.
@SkokieGuy: Probably the best advice on here.
Do NOT file a chargeback. This is downright negligence and because of the very low insurance coverage, a lawsuit will probably be your course of action.
Some people have mentioned homeowner's insurance, which you should definitely look into because that will probably end up being a lot easier for you to get reimbursed.
@SOhp101: In a lot of cases they will pay you THEN go after the movers for the money, and believe me INSURANCE COMPANY X is a lot scarier to a company then you are.
Looks like a fairly new Peterbilt medium duty truck set up for local moving only though. It doesn't have a traditional sleeper but is a four door "crew" type cab unless they converted the rear cab as a sleeper. Kind of odd setup for across country moving unless they do hotshot commercial deliveries and are picking up extra work moving consumers...
Believe me that this driver not only is on the hook for their belongings but he just totalled ($20-50,000 worth)the van (enclosed box area) body if the truck frame is not bent also...
@MyPetFly: We had a good experience w/ our Pod/Relocube when we made our cross country move. Might save a bit if you only have a few rooms to move.
I would contact a lawyer, I would also research whether this moving company is actually allowed to truck interstate, because if they are not you have them by the balls to replace your stuff.
Where was your driver from? It's bizarre that a driver comes to pick-up in Boston, which you would assume he is familiar with, and proceed to drive on Storrow. Everyone knows you can't go on Storrow with a truck and if you don't know there are 500 signs, not to mention every car you pass will honk at you like crazy trying to get you to stop.
Here's the company's website:
It looks like they do quite a bit of commercial moving, all of it probably badly.



























The picture of the driver on his cell phone on the side of the road looks like a great Snickers commercial, "Not going anywhere for awhile?"