American Eagle Kicks Autistic Child And His Mother Off Plane
On Monday, an American Eagle flight which was in the process of taxiing at the Raleigh-Durham Airport in North Carolina turned around to kick 2-and-a-half-year-old Jarett Farell (pictured left) and his mother Janice off of the plane. According to WTVD, the unhappy toddler was crying loudly and after a few warnings, the decision to turn the plane around was made. Janice Farell contends that the crew was very short-tempered and unsympathetic toward her and her son and that everything would have been ok if it weren't for the flight attendant who kept upsetting Jarett. American Airlines claims they did nothing wrong. Details, inside...
The article says,
As the American Eagle flight headed down the taxiway, two-and-a-half-year-old Jarett Farrell wasn't a happy traveler.
His mother says she was doing all she could to calm the autistic boy, but got no sympathy from the flight crew.
"If they just would have been a little more understanding I think that none of this would have been a problem," Mother, Janice Farrell said.
But it became a big problem for everyone on the plane. Farrell says that's because the flight attendant was indignant.
"She kept coming over and tugging his seatbelt to make it tighter, 'This has to stay tight'. And then he was wiggling around and trying to get out of his seatbelt. And she kept coming over and reprimanding him and yelling at him," Farrell said.
One of the pilots came back to the cabin with a stern warning and Farrell says the frustration level escalated.
She says Jarrett picked up on that and things only got worse.
"He just melted down. He saw me getting upset. He was upset. He was on the floor rolling around," she said.
The pilot returned to the cockpit, turned the plane around and headed back to the terminal.
"The pilot made an announcement that there was a woman and her child on the plane and the child is uncontrollable. And at that point I just broke down," Farrell said.
Farrell says when she got back to her home in Cary she called her husband and they decided that she should call American Airlines corporate. She says a company representative apologized and said the incident should never have happened.
But that's not what American Airlines told Eyewitness News.
A spokesman in Dallas says Jarret was pitching a "raging fit".
And that Janice, who was in a front-row seat, refused to allow her bag to be placed in an overhead compartment, even though there was no under seat stowage.
He says that with a "passenger not complying with FAA regulations, this was the right decision."
Farrell says even though her travel bag had things to calm Jarrett, she did indeed give it to the flight attendant.
"She took my bag and put it up top," Farrell said.
Farrell is taking the train to see family in New Jersey and she and her husband say they will never fly American again.
Without having been on the flight, it's difficult to say who, if anyone, was at fault. If a child is literally out of control, we can understand why this would necessitate the child's removal from the flight, especially since it was still on the ground. If indeed it was necessary, we just wish it could have happened in a way that didn't leave Jarett and his mother so upset.
Autistic toddler kicked off airplane [WTVD] (Thanks to everyone who sent this in!)
This is a test using rich text formatting and html links. It's the generic "company" ad that should appear on all posts with the Company category if they don't have an ad attached to a specific company.
Post a comment
Comments:
This sucks, but what was American Airlines supposed to do?
You kids settle down or I'm turning this airplane around! I mean it! You think I don't mean it? Here. We're going back home. Happy now?
I have an autistic child, and so I'm sure I'm automatically biased. It is hard to say what happened without having been there. She says the flight attendant kept coming over and tightening his seat belt. That right there would be enough to send an autistic child into a rage. And I really don't see how that was necessary. I think she could have asked the parent to do that instead. That makes me wonder if the flight attendant was indeed being unreasonable. Whether the airline was in the right or not, I feel for the parent.
I feel for the mom, and the kid, but you know what? There are few experiences more aggravating than being stuck on a plane with an implacably screaming child.
If the flight attendant really was hounding the child about the seatbelt, that's messed up, but I can't imagine that happening. I flew constantly as a kid and often my seatbelt was quite loose, and no attendant ever paid any mind.
Umm morons, poking a an autistic kid is just asking for a melt down. They should have left it up to the parent to calm her down, and let her have what she needed. FU American Airlines.
I just hope that the attendant gave the mother sufficiant time (without comming and hastling them) to get child under control. Autistic children are a handful and my sympathies are with the mother.
Sounds like they violated his civil liberties. Lawsuit in 3...2...
@vgerik1234: "whining little brat"? "poopdoll"? Dude, I don't even _LIKE_ kids and I know better than to say shit like that about someone's child. A child who is AUTISTIC. Look it up. Seriously, it's not at all cool to be a mean person for absolutely no reason. I hate it when a kid is crying near me in restaurants and public transit, too. But this kid isn't a brat and isn't doing it for spite. Just a touch of respect, dude. Try it sometime.
Autistic child = whining little brat? vgerik1234 I'd rather sit next to a toddler all the way to SE Asia than next to you for 10 minutes. Eventually the child will stop crying but you'll always be a...
we just wish it could have happened in a way that didn't leave Jarett and his mother so upset.
I don't see that there would be a way. The airline employees could have been nicer about it, but I'd be willing to bet that they would have been upset no matter how the employees came across.
"I'm really sorry, but your son is just too disruptive. I know he has a medical condition, but he has to be able to follow our directions, regardless of his condition. We have to take you back to the gate. The gate agent can help you with rebooking your flight."
"But.. but.. my snowflake! My flight! I paid good money for these tickets!"
You get the idea. Parents (to say nothing of people in general) have big enough entitlement complexes as it is, and parents with 'special needs' children are the worst of the bunch. (Present company excepted, of course.)
I smell ADA lawsuit if the FA did harass the child. We should know by now that we let the parent deal with an autistic child, and if he/she can't calm the child down, then there is a reason to turn the plane around.
Brother is autistic. Unless they HAVE to go by plane, it just messes the young Autistic Children up terribly. THEY CAN"T COPE! The air-popping in the ears even freaks me out.
I think the blame is spread around. The mother for not being able to realize that her son just cannot cope. Parents (and siblings) that have autisic kids essentially have to lead a sedentary life style until the child can at least semi-function in the world. No easy task.
Fortunately, my brother can control himself, and is 'lightly' autistic almost at the level of asbergers (hard to tell...) But other kids have no point of reference, autistic kids, that is.
The Air line is at fault for not understanding his problem. They should not have made him upset, or his mother upset. Seriously, it was really badly handled.
raleigh-durham to nj is hardly a four-hour flight. and most people know better than to reprimand an autistic child, let alone physically aggravate them as this attendant did. i'd reserve judgment until some eyewitnesses come forward, as one persons "hysterical fit" is another's "crying".
Failure to provide accommodation under the Americans with disabilities act, anyone?
And if American Eagle has a flight lasting (or at least scheduled to last) more than 90 minutes anywhere in its route system, I'll be surprised. They're the commuter airline that feeds into AA hubs like Raleigh.
I'm sorry but any parent traveling with a toddler should just pop em some Dramamine, extra-drowsy. Not that I'm for drugging the buggers, but it'll help matters.
2 and a half year old diagnosed with autism? The research says that before the age of 3, autism screening is only 35% reliable.
The mother says in as many words, "He was on the floor rolling around." I can't imagine any commercial airplane in the U.S. being willing to take off in that situation.
@bwcbwc:
Um....it's not "failure to provide accommodation," it's "must provide reasonable accommodation."
There are no winners in this one. Sorry to hear it.
sorry, amateur lawyers. The ADA does not apply to airlines.
Whether the child was autistic or not, the parent had probably 30 minutes already onboard, to try to make him ready for the flight. And the kid was still not staying seated, which is a safety issue. Exactly how much longer were they supposed to give her to try? And what if it hadn't worked?
The only responsible thing, on behalf of the other passengers and crew who needed to get their scheduled flight in the air, was to offload them. (given the information that we've been provided.)
Hmm,... I don't know who the jerk is in this story but being on that plane was a lose / lose. Either you're on with the kid or your flight is late to drop him off. Given the choice, I'd be glad he was gone. Sorry, but torture is torture even if they made it worse.
This sort of reminds me of that Catholic church in Minnesota that banned an autistic kid-I think about 12 or 13-from services, even served the mom with a restraining order and arrested her, because he was apparently touching people inappropriately and grabbing them and peeing in church. The mom lost me, though, when she said she didn't think God would want her son to view the service from the church basement TV, and that God said you had to be in church every Sunday or it was a sin. And also, she didn't want to put him on meds.
But this is way way different. I feel for the mom more than the airline at this point, although I'd also feel for passengers who would have had to ride with a screaming kid. Tough call all around. Maybe the FA was used to people heeding her every instruction because otherwise they'd be put on the terror watch list? And she didn't get that the kid was autistic or what the hell that meant.
As autism is a disability defined under the ADA (as it is mental condition), they have violated federal laws by denying services based on disability of a person -- age does not matter to the ADA. They may play they "FAA regulations" card by saying the mother didn't put the bag away and then it is a she said they said and then the witnesses side of it.
To take this to a different example, lets say a blind person has a guide dog and a airline attendant keeps bothering the dog and the dog keeps moving around. (note most guide dogs that are trained wont care) That attendant would likely say that the dog is uncontrollable and they would be thrown off the plane. Guess what, if the person can prove that that isn't the case and the attendant kept bothering the dog, then the blind person would have a ADA suit on their hands and previous suits have proven to be winners.
If you are a business and you refuse to provide your business to a person under the ADA protection because of that disability, you are open to a suit.
So, if the mother doesn't get an apology from them, I would recommend she seek out a ADA lawyer and force it.
(Note to flamers: the ADA is to protect those in business that "think" people with disabilities are second, or even third class citizens and don't require the same level of respect)
Was he merely crying or screaming? Or was he out of his seat? The former is a mere nuisance. The latter is grounds for ejection.
Tough call indeed but if there was no way to guarantee he'd at least stay in his seat during take-off / landing then, well, he had to go.
I witnessed a flight-attendant (back when they were still called 'stews') who lost his balancing trying to close a storage door during takeoff. Fell, cut his head mightily, blood oh mother blood.
Of course, they could have EXPLAINED that to the mother instead of just pissing her off and kicking them out.
If you can't control your kids, DON'T FLY! It doesn't matter WHY they are disruptive. Autistic kids, having difficulties with communication in general have enough problems with strange people. Putting them into a situation where they are trapped with a bunch of other strangers with no place to escape is a formula for disaster.
As a person who flies for a living, I must be as biased as the people who have autistic kids. I personally hate to fly, so I drive whenever I can (5 hours to Virginia is almost as fast as getting to the airport on time and flying). NC to NJ is an 8 hour drive. Let the parent suffer the child and not the rest of the world.
I feel for the mother and child as well, but I'd like to hear what some of the witnesses/other passengers have to say in the matter.
Autistic or not, I wouldn't want to be on a flight with a child screaming the entire flight. I've been on flights with crying babies before and its maddening. Its not like you can get off the plane if you don't like it.
I don't like American Airlines, but if I were a passenger I would probably have applauded their removing them from the flight.
I agree with the airline. If you bring very young child on board who cannot stay quite then you deserve to get kicked off the plane.
What were they thinking???
They say they have an autistic kid and imply he is hard to control, but everyone on that plane was just supposed to sympathize and deal with it for several hours?
That kids parents should be ashamed of themselves.
I applaud the airline for turning around. This is the most "customer satisfaction" I bet American Airlines has done in years. Inconvenience two people or everyone else.
If an airline wants to increase revenues, they should schedule child free flights and charge a premium for them. It would be a boon to their bottom line. Just like Metroliner for Amtrak, and the Bridge for movie theatres; people are more than happy to pay for ways away from people's children.
A screaming child on a plane can make an already miserable flight even MORE hellish. Make it an autistic kid & I'd want to open the emergency door mid-flight & jump out!
Sorry, to seem heartless, but come on!
I await the flames from people who have never had any experiences with autistic children.
I think it was handled poorly, theres a difference between a child crying and a child unbuckling the seat belt, and running down the aisle or kicking someones seat.
I would get annoyed by a child crying, but i would get pissed if the child was being a true ass. I feel bad for the parent and the kid, being slowly developed in the head is never fun.
On the plus side amtrak has a train that goes to new york that stops in cary that is cheap as shit. Amtrak rocks, just keep the kid busy with a lot of colouring books!
Absolute support for the airline here.
Also the summary "the unhappy toddler was crying loudly and after a few warnings the decision to turn the plane around was made" does not equal what actually happened. Refusing to stow baggage, a screaming child who refuses to be in a seat, parents who expect special treatment... no. Get off the plane, rent a car, and grow up.
/works in public school with autistic children. Some parents actually accept the challenge, others thing that everyone ELSE must accept the challenge. Guess which kids actually adapt and improve?
Finally, some good news about the airlines! I don't care what the kids condition is, no one person has the right to make 200 other people miserable for 4 hours.
If I was on that flight I would have been aplauding the flight crew.
Dear Struggling Airlines: I will pay $25.00 to $50.00 extra to be on an "18 and over" flight
@r081984: There are either far fewer people like you in RL, or people like you seem to have the good sense to keep views like that to yourself in RL. So, parents like me seem not to know our place in society, so we unfortunately inflict ourselves on you. Oh well, I say. Earplugs are cheap, and they fit in your pocket.
this is why all children under 11 should be checked as luggage and not allowed on the plane
Stop it right now or I'll turn this plane around, I swear!
@cmcd14:
Not that I'm for drugging the buggers, but it'll help matters.
Yes you are. Don't you recall writing this?...
I'm sorry but any parent traveling with a toddler should just pop em some Dramamine, extra-drowsy.
First: then he was wiggling around and trying to get out of his seatbelt. And she kept coming over and reprimanding him and yelling at him,"
and then, after the pilot came and talked to the mother: "He just melted down. He saw me getting upset. He was upset. He was on the floor rolling around," she said
A child who isn't in their seat after they are told to be, isn't in control, and is screaming shouldn't be on an airplane.
It is not the job of the pilot, the flight attendants, or the passengers to put up with a screaming child or one who delays the entire flight because he isn't in control or can't be buckled properly into his seat.
@The_IT_Crone: In what capacity do you work with those children? I find it interesting that you jumped to conclusions and automatically sided with the airlines. Even I didn't do that. I conceded that we can't know what happened. You sound rather judgmental about the parents of the kids you work with.
If the parent can't hold it together and starts crying perhaps she should have had another adult with her to help her.
Not that I don't feel sympathy for a stressed parent, and I do have to note that autism spectrum disorders signs can be noted by 18 months
It seems to note a lack of preparation for this trip. An uneventful trip with an autistic child on an airline is possible, but in this case the preparations were not adequate to insure that the child would remain in his seat for the time needed to taxi and take off.
The parents should discuss the trip with their pediatrician or neurologist and discuss the possibility of the use of a sedating pre-flight oral medication if indicated.
"He was on the floor rolling around"= out of seat, can't be controlled. All passengers must be buckled in and have their seats in the upright position. "And at that point I just broke down"... did she start to cry or start to yell?
Anyways, autistic or not, the child was violating safety rules. After taxiing on the tarmac (which takes FOREVER) I think the staff gave her a reasonable amount of time to try and calm him down. I wouldn't want to be on a flight with a screaming child, anyway.
In fact, I was on Amtrak and this family brought their 3 y.o. and a baby. It cried from 11p until 12a when I finally shouted SHHHHH!!!! from my seat. I was listening to music on over-the-ear headphones and I could still hear the baby crying. Shortly thereafter, the attendant came and asked them to move to the lounge car. Yay!
Perhaps the child's car booster seat should have been brought along. Many models are airline approved. The harness system, rather than a lap belt, would have helped him remain in place. And perhaps the familiar car seat, with his toys attached, would have helped him feel more secure than a strange airplane seat.
The mother might also discuss her future travel arrangements with her special needs pediatrician or the psychiatrists and therapists treating her son. Perhaps they could prescribe a mild sedative to be used only before a flight?
It would seem that any risks of a carefully prescribed sedative might be outweighed by the benefits of the child not flying out of his plane seat and whacking his head on the ceiling during turbulence.
Or next time buy Grandma a ticket to come visit them, instead of flying with the child.
I do feel for the mother, since the kid is 2.5 yrs old, he was probably recently diagnosed with Autism, we have a 6 year old and it was only last year we got an official diagnosis, though we knew all along. If he was recently diagnosed the mother might not have developed techniques for prepping the kid for this type of travel. In our autistic son, we spend about 5 times a much time in prepping for things like this than the duration of the event.
i dont really mind crying/whiny kids as long as the parents are trying to calm them down. if the parents just expect everyone to just deal with it and not do anything, i find that rather frustrating. i think a parent with an autistic/special needs child deserves more latitude in these kinds of situations.
I recently bit my tongue when some snarky anti-child comments were made in another thread about airlines. My son is 5, he's a fantastic traveler, and people don't realize there are quiet kids on the plane because, well, they're quiet.
Charge more for childless flights? It might work. Personally, I'd pay good money to avoid the chatty old ladies, the blowhard businessmen, and the drinkers. The most obnoxious person on a flight is rarely the screaming child.
But I think the pilot was right to turn the plane around. The kid was having a fit, and was so disruptive that the crew couldn't ensure he and his mother were ready for takeoff.
It doesn't matter whether the child is autistic. It's not a condition that is readily apparent, nor something flight crews are trained to handle. If a flight crew is expected to bend the rules because a mother claims her child is autistic, that's not a judgment call they should make minutes prior to takeoff.
I know it's hard raising an autistic child. It's also hard raising a child who is in a wheelchair, or requires oxygen, or has some variety of immune deficiency. My son is allergic to peanuts. If his allergy worsens, and he has life threatening anaphylaxis from touching or breathing peanut dust, he won't be able to fly on airlines that serve peanuts. What a nightmare! But having a child means working through those limitations.
@shor0814: I am sorry but the ADA isn't going to overrule FAA regulations. If this kid does not have the capacity to stay calm on the plane, the kid can't fly. The ADA cannot undermine the safety of other passengers. Imagine if that kid takes his belt off during turbulence and a bump sends him flying down the isle and he crashes into someone else? And him being autistic all but guarantees that the mother will not be able to control the child. Then add to that the huge annoyance of a screaming child for a few hour flight that no one else can escape from. These parents have some nerve trying to pawn the responsibility of looking after their child onto everyone else. I also find it very telling that she admits because her child is autistic she feels like she gets to break the rules and not securely stow her bags. This lady really doesn't care at all about the safety or rights of the other passengers. I just wish the overhead bins were full by the time the attendant told her to stow her bag so they would have made her check it. Imagine that wonderful scene of entitlement vs the FAA.
@mdoneil:
We have taken our 6 year old on a few air travel trips (also have 4 year old twins, they have flown as well), you are right, preparation is the key. We build a social story, pictures of what will be expected on the trip as well as expected by our son. I would have definitely found a picture of the kid in an airplane seat, seat belted in, and printed it out and spent about 2 weeks prior to the trip discussing it with him.
Autism is on a continuum. Some kids are fine, they just tune out the world. Others, well...we have policies for them. Rubber room. Constant observation. Low stimulus.
Sounds like moms is Entitled. We had a woman walk her child around a store for over an hour and then told the customers and staff that they should "just adjust". If the store manager had been there he would have thrown her out. One non-paying mooch vs. $1500 possible dollars.
Who is in control here? One assumes that moms was the adult and doing the appropriate actions. Sounds like they smelled settlement money.
I have to agree with the airline. They will have a crapton of complaints about the whining little brat. If you have ever flown, a crying kid makes a 4 hours flight, FOREVER... The poopdoll never shuts up..