If you’ve seen the “Bodies” exhibit at the South Street Seaport in New York City, you’re entitled to a refund (click here for info) according to a new agreement between New York’s Attorney General’s office and Premier Exhibitions, Inc. When “Bodies” first opened here over two years ago, some opponents questioned whether the Chinese cadavers were legally obtained—or whether they were Chinese political prisoners who hadn’t consented to being plastinated, flayed, and displayed by a private for-profit company. At the time, Premier Exhibitions’ president said all the bodies were documented: “Although he said he was not allowed to keep copies of documents, officials at Dalian University in northern China showed him papers attesting to the origin of the remains,” wrote the New York Times in 2005. Then ABC’s news show “20/20″ aired an investigative report this past February that showed otherwise.
From ABC News:
Premier Exhibitions says that the “unclaimed” bodies on display were legally obtained from Dalian Medical University.
ABC News’ “20/20″ reported earlier this year that the bodies did not come from the university but instead from a private, for-profit lab about 30 miles away. “20/20″ interviewed someone who said he was a former participant in the black market, in which, he said, bodies were sold to that lab for $200 to $300 each. Dalian Medical University told ABC News that it severed its ties to the plastination lab several years ago.
Premier’s former CEO Arnie Geller, who is still on the company’s Board of Directors disputed the allegations on “20/20.” He said that his suppliers assured him that “these are all legitimate, unclaimed bodies that have gone through Dalian Medical University.”
“20/20″ also reported that the inventor of plastination, Dr. Gunther von Hagens (who has touring body shows that are not related to Premier Exhibitions or their exhibits), claimed he stopped using Chinese-sourced bodies entirely because of his suspicions that they were unethically obtained:
Von Hagens says he had to cremate several bodies he received in China after detecting injuries that led him to suspect they had been executed prisoners. He says those bodies were given to him by a medical school in China to plastinate for teaching models. He said he only used Chinese bodies, all of which he received from the Chinese university, for teaching models, but has never put Chinese bodies on public display.
“There is now no way for me any more to work with specimens in China,” said von Hagens, who says his company in China now only deals with animal specimens.
Oddly, there are no customs restrictions in the U.S. with plastinated corpses at the present, writes ABC News:
U.S. Customs has said that since the plastination process changes the nature of the human remains, plastinated body parts can be imported as plastic objects, not as human bodies.
This is why 21 members of Congress have sponsored a bill that would prohibit the importation of plastinated cadavers entirely.
WNYC reports that as part of the agreement, Premier Exhibitions will have to post a warning now that some of the bodies may be those of executed Chinese prisoners, which we imagine would put a damper on any future visits.
We can’t find any details yet on how to request the refund, so if someone finds out, please send us a tip. Thanks to Brian and Melt for the refund contact info!
“‘Bodies’ exhibit avoids a stiff penalty” [Daily News] (Thanks to Alex!)
RELATED
“Cadaver Exhibition Raises Questions Beyond Taste” [New York Times]
“Exclusive: Secret Trade in Chinese Bodies” [ABC News]
“Lawmakers Call for Crackdown on Bodies Exhibits” [ABC News]
H.R. 5677 [GovTrack.us]
“State Reaches Settlement with Bodies Exhibit” [WNYC.org]
(Photo: jemsweb)
More From Consumerist
-
The Body Shop Ships Glass Candle Holder Loose In Box, Makes Up For It With Fabulous Customer Service
-
This Year’s Consumer Electronics Show Might Be A Yawn Because We’re Content With What We Have
-
IRS: H&R Block Causing Refund Delays After Bungling 600,000 Tax Returns
-
U.S. Postal Service Promises Express Mail Money-Back Guarantee, Won’t Give It To Me
-
EECB Saves Nexus 10 Owner From Restocking Fee
Somehow if I were to donate my body to science…being strung up in an art gallery as a grotesque display isn’t what I had in mind. Still debating on the old organ donation thing on my driver’s license at this point…now that we have NYC creating organ harvesting vans. I tell ya, once you are worth more dead than alive, it isn’t a good thing.
I went a couple years ago. There were signs at the entrance and exit saying that the bodies were treated with “respect.” The exhibit has bodies staged to look like they are playing tennis and basketball. There was a comment book and I wanted to write “Saying you treated the bodies with respect doesn’t make it so,” but every pen was out of ink. Every one.
@DrCrippen: There’s at least two bodies that were on display in one of the traveling European exhibits (I can’t recall which one) that had what appeared to be obvious bullet wounds. Body Worlds has publicly stated that “donated” bodies received from China had gunshot wounds to the skull.
Furthermore, there’s been more than a few reports that the traveling shows that followed the original “Body Worlds” exhibit have featured corpses that were evidently preserved too quickly and were oozing unidentified liquids.
I saw this exhibit. Fascinating. I knew about the controversy over the bodies and went anyway. Guess I can’t file for a refund. It was way overpriced, though — can I file for a refund for that reason???
Body Worlds > Bodies the Exhibition
This is just another example.
@ sharkd
If that’s the case, disregard my last statement.
The Gunther guy seemed legit…. the guy from Premier exhibitions, who looked like Lewis Black..definitely a slimeball! All he kept doing was repeating the phrase “Dalian medical university…”. Turns out the place the bodies are from is a crock shop that conveniently named itself “Dalian medical university institute of plastination” Also, I read on the ABC site that the investigation started shen some random house in Grand Rapids got a crate of the bodies…. How messed up with that be? You open up the box expecting the new widget you ordered from Amazon.com…..and look what you got instead?
@humphrmi:
No kidding! The catch is that you have to pay to ship your own body to them…but still..
@luz:
And you can be sure no more kids in the area will steal gum ever again…
@RvLeshrac:
While I somewhat agree with you…the problem here is that there’s a chance that the demand is actually causing more people to be shot than would be otherwise..
@IrisMR:
I take it you also believe that a kid who knows how to build Legos can built the same quality of house as a contractor with a ton of hands-on experience?
@Saboth:
You’re the reason I propose an “Organ Donor A-List” program: If you’re willing to donate your organs and actively donate blood, or unable due to MEDICAL reasons (i.e. AIDS, etc… not religious reasons), you get first dibs on transplants should you ever require one. The selfish people out there can go to hell.
Best quote from the ABC Video:
“Calling is a plastic model? That means I can take Grandma Betty…put a lampshade on her, and put her in my living room!”
I suppose you could put the lightbulb above her head, so it looks like she just had a good idea?
Also, I can’t believe how many of the Premier exhibitions ones look Chinese compared to the Body Worlds ones…
@LUV2CattleCall:
That’s actually why I stated “the ends do not justify the means here.” There’s nothing wrong with using the corpses of the executed, since a corpse is just a corpse – but since money is involved, everything goes immediately to hell.
@DoktorGoku: That’s not the same
Professional interest is one thing, Outright morbid curiosity is another.