Radio Shack Won't Accept Cash Without Your Home Address
Reader Tim went to Radio Shack to buy something or other and the manager refused to process his cash transaction without first learning his home address. Tim left the store and dashed off a quick email to us. He let us know he was going to contact Radio Shack about the incident, but felt certain that he'd be ignored.
He wasn't. Within about an hour Tim was writing us to say he had $20 in gift certificates from Radio Shack.
Here's Tim's first letter:
Just left Radio Shack store in Jackson Mississippi located on Hwy 18.Sales Associate took my name and telephone number prior to ringing up about sixty dollars worth of small parts. Refused to finalize cash transaction without my home address! I left the store as he was returning the stock to the shelves.
I have attempted to make Radio Shack aware of this incident as well as my contacting your site. Perhaps their sales are so good in these trying times that they are not interested in doing business with folks who aren't
interested in giving them such information?Seems highly unlikely, but the whole incident was witnessed by a fellow I assume to be the manager, but I've no way to confirm that. In any event, I will report to you any communications I receive from Radio Shack in regards to this incident. At this time I am limited to going through a form on their website. Why do I feel that will be ignored?
Thanks,
Tim
Wow. I emailed Radio Shack (thru an online form) and then I called their 800 number to report the treatment I had been given earlier in the day. I got thru directly to the Area Coordinator and he apologized profusely and offered me $20 in Radio Shack gift certificates. Turned out their local corporate office is right down the street from my house, so I went right over and picked up the gift certificates. That's a pretty fast response to a complaint wouldn't you say?Turns out the guy who was abusing me is the freaking store manager! I don't think he's in for a pleasant evening.
Thanks,
Tim
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nam malesuada commodo erat et molestie. Duis pellentesque aliquam bibendum. Suspendisse venenatis lobortis eleifend. Mauris id est sed lectus convallis aliquam.
Post a comment
Comments:
I suppose giving fake info is the most expedient way to get out of there, but why not address it head-on and say you're not going to give them your info? If more people refused to, these policies would become unworkable for the stores and they'd be dropped. I've noticed that I get asked for my phone number more and more during transactions, I say no, and the transaction goes on. I also refuse to give my zip code when they ask -- that's not so much a privacy thing as it is about me resenting that the store is going to inconvenience me by making my transaction take longer just so they can get marketing info.
Wow. They still do that at RS? That's actually a throwback to the good old days - the 70s at least. You know, when they had needles for every obsolete record player ever made, free batteries, and enough loose electronic parts to build your own nuclear weapon - or a killer robot. Those were the days. I don't think I've been to Radio Shack in years.
@valarmorghulis: (asking for clerk's address)
I'll sometimes say something like "my, aren't you forward -- we've just met and you haven't even bought me dinner yet!" Do it while smiling and it doesn't come over as rude.
Doesn't work so well on the older clerks of either gender. In that case, where it's clear they're too low-level and are just following policy, I'll smile and say, "No thank you."
On a return, a lot of places now ask for ID because of return fraud. There's zero reason to ask for it on a sale.
Since the cashier isn't the one setting store policy, I just give fake info. My daughter worked for 2 hellish weeks at Work 'N Gear, where the cashiers were given quotas for telephone numbers of store patrons. In those short weeks she saw how the staff were hectored and lectured about getting the numbers and how their very jobs depended upon it.
Naturally, she was quickly indoctrinated by the general staff on the art of supplying her own fake numbers to fulfill the quotas. Two short weeks were enough nonsense for her.
I make it obvious to the cashier that I'm "making it all up on the spot" and leave it at that. Too lazy to contact corporate!
IIRC, asking for personal information has not been their policy for a while. I worked there seasonally in college, at that time we had to ask. When a customer asked why, I said "so we can send you junk mail"
RS is indeed obsolete, but when you need an 8-terminal distribution block or a specialty audio cable, where else are you going to go? Can't find any of that locally.
@Antediluvian: Dear god, with a name like your's, who do you consider to be 'older'?
Yeah, I've tried to make it come across as humorous a couple of times, but like you said, that'll usually only work if they're in a good mood already.
The odd thing is, they got his phone number. Businesses use the phone number to obtain the address to send mailings and other crap. So it's strange that they would ask for both when they can easily find one with the other. Perhaps they worry that they are being given cell phones more frequently. Still, asking for an address is just wrong. It would be ironic if, to use the store credit, he had to give them his address.
@MissPeacock: I had a cash return to make in Belk once and they would not complete the return until I'd given them my name, phone number, address, and DRIVER'S LICENSE NUMBER. I make it a point never to return to any place that requires this kind of info from me for a cash transaction.
The reason for this is to help combat fraud. Rightly or not, many stores now require positive ID on returns (especially cash returns), and often only allow a certain number of returns by a single customer in a given amount of time. This is to keep shoplifters from lifting an item from the shelf and "returning" it with a receipt found in the parking lot, or purchasing an item to replace an old, broken one, then repackaging the old one to return, etc.
After a certain number of returns, many store policies will allow you no more. They ask for your DL to track this.
They can't figure out what they want to do with this policy... Back when I used to work there (I know... *sigh*), they first said yes you must get at LEAST name/phone, and address was better (still needed it for things like checks, certain service products, and whatnot).
Then they got rid of the whole policy altogether, only collecting info for warranties, phones, etc... Then they brought it back, and i dunno wtf they're at now, but some of the old-school managers are just real pricks about their metrics and numbers. Severely so.
So just remember this: You don't HAVE to give your name, number, and address for a cash sale (I had lots of people say their name was "Cash, Johnny Cash" as mentioned above). The employees are not supposed to refuse sale due to not providing this information... however, most of them will get away with doing whatever they want, it's pretty sad.
Next time, just tell them that the missed sale will affect their numbers more than their Names/Address percentage, and if they refuse to make the transaction for you, you will indeed give your name and address--as you RETURN ANYTHING you buy at ANY OTHER Radioshack at HIS location, and never give that store a positive transaction again.
Trust me, it'll work. Managers HATE returns.
You can use Schenectady, NY 12345, just to mess with them. It is a legitimate zipcode, and matches the city and state, but sounds illegitimate. When they call you on your bullshit, be very insistent about it.
Don't try this if you live in or near Schenectady, though. Most everyone around here knows that 12345 belongs to the GE campus. (Yes, I live in Schenectady though, obviously, in a different ZIP code). Also, be sure to pronounce it right: ska-NEK-ta-dee.
Also kind of fun is to use 22 Twain. Pronounce it two-two, not twenty-two. Try saying it out loud if you don't get it.
Incredible, I got the same treatment about ten miles away in Pearl, MS on Highway 80. I bought around $80~ worth of parts (I usually go to Hoopers Electronics, but I was in a rush). When I tried paying with a $100, the sales clerk asked for my name and address - I refused. He then gave me the option of paying with a credit or debit card or leaving the store. So I left the store. I ended up going to Hooper.
Long story short, I have not been to a Radio Shack in over a decade and thanks to my incident, and Tim's as well, I won't be going back for another decade more :)
I'm glad that Tim got a gift certificate out of the deal, but I would have sooner burned the thing than accepted it.
This process of being asked to provide any information other than "How would you like to pay for this" is absurd. I walked into a Pizza Hut a few months ago to order a pizza. I told the clerk,who had an Asst Manager name tag the type of pizza I wanted and he entered it into the computer terminal and then asked for my telephone number. I said "why do you need my phone number, I'm standing right here giving you the order?" he insisted that the computer could not process the order without my phone number. So I gave him 555-1212(information) and then walked out. I went to my local pizza shop and they only asked what type of toppings I wanted.























Jim Fakerson at 123 Fake St. in whatever zip code you want will work fine. Telling a fib is not perjury at Radio Shack!