Best Buy Charges Wrong Price, Lies When Confronted
Chris writes: "I had been last minute Christmas shopping on Saturday morning with my younger brother and sister and we happened upon Best Buy where we were looking for a digital picture frame for my Dad as a Christmas present. We got to the section near the digital cameras and noticed a decent deal. "7" Digital Picture Frame Touch" 79.99 was the label. A whole slew of product (NuTouch 7" Touch button Frames) were neatly stocked on the shelf. Note: STOCKED not STACKED. I quickly picked one up and proceeded to the register. At the register- the product rung up for the incorrect price (179.99)- here in CT, when that happens, so long as the item is labeled as such in the store (mistake or not) the retailer is legally supposed to give you the product for free (if food items) or at the marked price if it is any other type of consumer product..."
I quickly informed the cashier of the price mishap and he said, "No this is the right price" (how would he know what the RIGHT price is?). I asked him to have it checked. He quickly walked away from his post to find someone to go check on it. At that moment I had my brother go over and snap a quick picture of the items stocked on the shelf with the incorrect tag. The cashier came back within about 2 minutes and said we would have to wait. I was ok with this. About 5 minutes later, a "Computer Specialist," as his nametag read, came over and asked if I needed some help. I explained the situation and he invited me to come over and check out the products on the shelf and re-verify the price. All of the digital picture frames had been restacked and reorganized with new tags on the shelves and whatnot (Mind you this was about 10 minutes overall). Since all I had was a picture (blurry at best from the iPhone) I couldn't really do much- he either invited me to take a 30$ discount off of the 179.99 price or to please vacate the store. I was infuriated.This happened once to me too when I was a teenager. I was buying kitty litter at Shop Rite and I noticed it rang up the wrong price. I told customer service and they sent someone to go check it out and he came back and said, "oh, nope, you're mistaken, the register was correct. So then I went back and grabbed the sticker off the shelf and came back and showed it to them and they had no choice but to give me the litter for free. It looks like retailers have become more sophisticated since then and have resorted to elaborate Potemkin shelf displays in order to dupe their customers.I will not be shopping at Best Buy ever again.
- Chris
In his original email, Chris asked for some Best Buy executive email addresses so he could send his complaint off to a senior somebody. We told him that the email address format for Best Buy is firstname.lastname@bestbuy.com and that he should combine that with a list of top company executives and go to town. CC the Connecticut Department of Weights and Measures as well.
Here is the full-size version of the picture:
This is a test using rich text formatting and html links. It's the generic "company" ad that should appear on all posts with the Company category if they don't have an ad attached to a specific company.
Post a comment
Comments:
I think he would've had a lot more luck if the photo had been clearer. Taking a quick photo doesn't mean take it while you're running away. It does look like Best Buy was in the middle of changing its price, or baiting people to buy something. If it was $85 instead of $80, I think most people would be ok with it and pay the extra few dollars. But from $80 to $180 is ridiculous.
@CumaeanSibyl:
Probably not. The guy likely saw it, knew it was probably wrong, and thought he'd take advantage of it. I doubt he did anything to make sure the price on the shelf matched up to item above it.
I would like to know if the sku on the box matched the sku on the 79.99 label. Unfortunately the pic is terrible and doesn't do anything to prove or disprove the op.
This appears to be another "gotcha" posting about box store mislabeling and a consumer expecting a tremendous discount.
Or it could be a more nefarious, switch the labels around and demand the lower price scam, but I'll give the benefit of the doubt to the poster and say that its just labeling incompetence (not a shock, I don't trust any labels I read at best buy or other similar stores)
1. If labeled, make sure the skus are matched, a lot of stuff gets shuffled around this time of year, both by workers (many of whom are merely seasonal know nothings) and even consumers
2. Price tags at bestbuy probably have the date its good for, so make sure it still applies.
3. if price seems off, say by the 100$ it is in this post, have a guy in blue ring it up. Much better than finding out after standing in line that there is a labeling problem.
@infinitemojo: I use to work in a BBY as a third party vendor... Their store is so incredibly mislabeled. I would believe any store like this.
@AlisonAshleigh: the only kind I don't like are "Slow news day Consumerist?".
As if this is the only site on the internet for anything.
I like a little snarky/funny, but nothing that's downright rude.
I'm not sure about the laws in Connecticut, but here in Georgia the sku on the tag and the sku on the product have to match. As mightypen wrote above there are customers out there who will place a more expensive product in the spot of a cheaper product and demand the lower price. There are also customers who pick up an item and then place it back on the shelf in the wrong spot. The only protection the store has is to have the skus match. On the other hand, I too have ran into mislabeled items in pretty much every retailer I've ever visited. It just a fact of life, it happens.
@mercurypdx: When people are like "THIS DOESN'T BELONG ON A CONSUMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMERSIT WEBSITE" I want to throttle them a little.
Its obvious that they re shuffled the stock when you pointed it out to them, that picture is good enough, you can read the price tag. I would write to best buy corporate, go to planetfeedback.com and write a nice public letter to them.
Wow, thats just slimy.... What a scam, not like i was surprised to see best buys name associated with this story.
@AlisonAshleigh: When people are like "This doesn't belong in a discussion thread!!!" I want to throttle them a little. ;-) jk, I do know what you mean. But it's a hard thing to stop - I find myself getting snarkier as time goes on...
Thing is, they had others sitting in a basket behind the register, obvious that others had seen the mislabeled price and tried to purchase it as well. It's just downright wrong to call me a liar to my face and ask me to leave the store due to their mislabeling practices.
Where the sku should have been read something to the tune of "7INTOUCH" not a model # or anything to identify the tag to a particular item. Convenient.
@AlteredBeast: haha!
@pylon83: When I worked in a grocery store, this was very common. People would grab an item, assume that the first price tag that entered their field of vision matched the product they wanted to buy, and then complain about how cans of tuna weren't individually stamped with prices anymore, like in the olden days when their product rang up at a different price.
Kohl's has twice charged me more than the price listed on the shelf for items. Both times, the clerk just shrugged when I told her what the shelf tag said and changed the price manually--no questions. I was surprised, but given that most Kohl's I've been to look like giant rummage sales, maybe the clerks are used to that sort of thing.
According to the picture, it looks like a Digital Spectrum 7" Elite Frame priced at $179.99 on Best Buy's website. It could have been on sale for $79.99 as a Christmas special, but Best Buy's ads run Sunday to Saturday. I'm suspecting it was on sale, the new prices were already in the computer and because of that, threw up the new tag to make a quick $100 on the item.
I honestly wouldn't be surprised with Best Buy the way they've acted recently and with CompUSA's crumble that they've notified cashiers how to proceed when price changes go into affect and how to reset the display before the customer sees.
Anybody have a Best Buy ad laying around for the week of December 16th-22nd? I'm really curious to see if this frame is in there. In that case, Best Buy would really be screwed.
Also, the customer should have tried to grab an ad for that week on his way out of the store just in case it was in there.
well best buy had done that to me before and luckily, i had the presence of mind to secure a legible photo with my cellphone of the mismarked tag that showed the UPC. with that info..you're outta luck.
in an unrelated note...i'm miffed that a best buy salesperson talked my wife out of letting buy the dslr camera that i have been wanting for over a year. he told her that we could go home and come back tomorrow (Sunday) and the same financing and pricing would be in effect. I asked him, "are you sure? tomorrow's sunday."
he said yes it wouldn't be a problem...sure enough...on sunday the 18 month financing option was gone and i'm back to not being able to afford my camera.
thanks a lot jerk.
@AlisonAshleigh: i don't like the blame the victim people, but i have read some articles on here and been thinking? this is news?! perfect example: "judge judy not a real judge".......uh hello? did i miss something here?
but i have noticed an extremely large volume of haters (victim blamers) and a lot of people on here seem to be big on defending large corporations.
@Infoclast: And you know they are scamming because why? Sure I have questions about stories where I only hear one side of the story, but I don't automatically jump to the conclusion that because the story is not air tight the person must be a scammer. In this case the price tag clearly shows $79, it looks like from the blurry picture that the product is neatly behind the price tag (if the product where all of the place, that would clue you in that you needed to find what product went to what tag). And he if was was just scamming and got caught, why would he put himself out there in this story? I would think most scammers would not complain to the Consumerist.
@Ben:"It looks like retailers ...have resorted to elaborate Potemkin shelf displays in order to dupe their customers."
Way to HighBrow this place up.
I side with the consumer in this case. The part that tips me over is the deliberate deception on the part of the manager to change the prices after the fact.
I'd be more inclined to give the corporation some leeway on screwing up the prices, if they hadn't tried to LIE and change the pricing after the fact.
He changed it because he knew he'd get dinged for the mistake.
-
I'd bring as many small item merchandise up front from the computer sectino of the store in a shopping cart (just toss it in by the fistful... then at the counter, I'd tell them I changed my mind and decided not to buy it. Abandon the cart and go. Bastards.
I'd definitely raise a stink to corporate about it.
So because you couldn't get the price that some store clerk getting paid $6.50/Hr places on the picture frame you will no longer shop at Best Buy? I could understand if Best Buy, overcharged you on the correct price and then refused to give you back the difference, but in this case you are mad because some 18 year old messed up on the sign and to avoid getting into trouble switched the sign to the correct one. Plus with the heavy use of photoshop I find it impossible to trust your blurry photo.
I guess you can always shop at circuit city and CompUSA while they are still in business.
@snoop-blog: It kinda bugs me when people don't get obvious sarcasm. Like the "Judge Judy is not a real judge" post.
@unclescrooge: "on sunday the 18 month financing option was gone and i'm back to not being able to afford my camera. thanks a lot jerk."
If you couldn't afford it on Sunday, you couldn't afford it Saturday.
Why is there all this open hostility against the consumer on this site?
The law is that you pay what an item is marked. If this item was marked for $79 and it rang up at $179, the marked price should control. I do not care what the clerk makes or who gets into trouble. The law is the law. The company faces the possibility of a class action lawsuit, which will cost them far more than $100 if they were to continue such "mistakes".
I am not saying the story is true, but the picture looks clear enough to me to see that it is a $79 picture frame.
WTF is with all the SKU questions? If the name of the product is on the shelf-sticker tag along with the price, then why should the sku matter?
Looks to me the customer got hosed by incompetant/prickish employees.... which for best buy... its no suprise.
I am with the customer on this one. If a store mis-prices an item, or has a sale & doesnt register the sale price in computer & then charges me the full price(happened to me MANY times).... then the customer needs to be comphensated for the false advertising..... intentional or not! I dont care if its a $500 fridge advertised/labeled for $50.
















Seems like a lot of trouble just to overcharge him. I think he caught them in the middle of a price change, and got screwed over by the poor timing. Also, hold the iPhone with two hands when taking a picture, please.