Legend Of Comcast Office-Smashing Grandma Spreads
The old lady who busted up a Comcast office with her hammer after getting sick of their delays, that we told you about two weeks ago, got her story written up in a new and even more exciting fashion by the Washington Post. The piece includes this photo of Mona Shaw posing with her trusty tool of consumer vengeance.
WP got more choice quotes from Mrs. Shaw:
"They cuffed me right then..."
Of Comcast: "What a bunch of sub-moronic imbeciles."
"I scared the tar out of some people, at least...It had never occurred to me to take a hammer to a phone company before, but I was just so upset. . . . After I hit the keyboard, I turned to this blonde who had been there the previous Friday, the one who told me to wait for the manager, and I said, ' Now do I have your attention?' "
"My blood pressure went up around my ears. I started hyperventilating. They had to call the rescue squad and put me on a litter."
A new American folk hero is born.
Taking a Whack Against Comcast [Washington Post] (Thanks to Tracey!)
This is a test using rich text formatting and html links. It's the generic "company" ad that should appear on all posts with the Company category if they don't have an ad attached to a specific company.
Post a comment
Comments:
Read the article, boys -- her oh-so-notorious rampage was on her second visit. Destroying things with a hammer appears to be what it takes to escalate things at that office of Comcast. She didn't make the rules, she just lives by 'em.
As for cost to the company, she paid restitution; as for "less likely to help people", as a general rule, a consequence of having to file charges against a little old lady means a united public front -- "oh, no, it's a *horrible* thing and we acted right in every way" -- and a private reaming of epic proportions. This is a humiliation up and down the line, there's no mistake.
The sentence was entirely appropriate -- and she finally got her phone service.
@jesdynf: Tell that to the employees at the scene. Oh! Wait, they are HUMANS too!
A e-mail carpet bomb, media, picket in front of the office. So many civilized solutions...
She's being made into a hero because the public has already decided whose side they're on...and it ain't Comcast's.
When my wife finishes law school and we get ready to (possibly) move to another area for her job, we will seriously consider avoiding locations that are served by Comcast.
Yes. They are that bad.
Nothing infuriates me more than people who steal TIME from me. And this woman is running short on time. I generally don't approve of this kind of behavior, but it's nice to see someone react in a way that reflects how they truly feel, as long as it doesn't physically harm someone. So some "innocent" employees were "scared?" I've met quite a few Comcast employees in my life, and ever last one of them was nasty at worst, quietly surly at best. Fuck 'em. I'm glad she *acted* - because they don't seem to respond to actual words.
@Jean Naimard: Yeah, cause I think that unprovoked violence is bad makes me a shill. Im just a deadspin refuge who finds this site interesting, but is often sickened by the "screw the big company" attitude I see so often. There is a reason customer service sucks, and part of it is bad customers. (and yes, Ive dealt with comcast for the better part of my life)
Dear comcast, why is it that EVERYONE immediately sides with this woman? It is because your company sucks THAT BAD!
Drop Beth Bacha (quoted in the article) a line, and let her know what you really think was "inappropriate" in this situation. Personally, I find making a 75 year-old woman wait for two hours OUTSIDE IN THE AUGUST heat "inappropriate."
@Jean Naimard: Every time someone thinks that breaking things is not the solution they're a "company shill" or "a private property hardass" in your book. I personally do not much care for Comcast, but that does not mean I think this woman's actions are something admirable. In fact, I suspect all this is going to lead to is more people doing more irresponsible things in the name of "making a statement".
reminds me of that cool Jack in the Box commercial they pulled where the old lady is asked whether or not they should get rid of the clown in the drive thru and she responds "waste him." They then blow up the clown. Would love to see that one posted here.
You people take life so serious with your inappropriate response, etc. No kidding it was. That does not mean we can't enjoy the moment and have a good laugh about it. Lighten up, please.
@mconfoy: You people take life so serious with your inappropriate response, etc. No kidding it was. That does not mean we can't enjoy the moment and have a good laugh about it. Lighten up, please.
That seems to be the point a lot of people are missing with the pleasure taken in this. No, this was not an appropriate response, and people shouldn't do this, because it's just not how you're supposed to act, *and* someone could get hurt. But, now that it's settled, and no one is hurt, and Comcast got restitution for their office damage - c'mon, what's done is done, and everyone who's had to deal with Comcast's bullshit has a right to a glimmer of vicarious revenge.
@Sherryness: My sentiments exactly.
As someone inside a similar corporate machine, it is somewhat unnerving to see people taking out their frustrations with pointless vigilantism, but I can't see how the insanity inside corporate culture hasn't bred this sort of response like rabbits - especially having had to deal with my own company as a customer.
The fact that pointless vigilantism doesn't run rampant either means that we as a people are endlessly compassionate, or so overwhelmingly downtrodden that we don't care anymore.
@jesdynf: Cool! So when they continue to screw up my biling - like Cingular did for six months, after several calls per month and two in-person visits - I can just shotgun up the offices?
I hate to sound shrill, but blunt force trauma isn't the answer to corporate moronism. This old lady is off her rocker.
@Paul D: She's being made into a hero because the public has already decided whose side they're on...and it ain't Comcast's.
Nice to see that the celbrity culture has made this lady's nutty actions into a literal cause celebre.
There's something wrong with our country, folks - and it has a lot to do with a media culture that hold people like this old nutter up as an example of "fighting back", when in fact she's only gaining shock value and sympathy for the corporation that made "a few mistakes among milions of customers".
Any of you ever see Faling Down? An example of an empowered working man, or an insane asshole? Careful how you answer.
@backspinner: actually, i think they jumped the shark back when they called a certain computer company "sad" for failing to do free repairs on someone's seven year old computer.
we're waaaaayyy beyond the shark now.
it's all open, empty waters. & apparently the Consumerist's version of maritime law involves mindlessly grunting: "corporation bad! SMASH good!!"
incidentally, i think this is the point where i pull the feed from my RSS reader.
I have been a Comcast customer for six years in two locations. If there was any reasonable competition, I would switch immediately. My last dealings with live people at Comcast happened when a lightning storm fried my modem. I had to make two trips down to a dangerous (drug dealing, prostitution, open display of weapons) part of town to finally get a working modem.
Verizon moved into my area, but their local door-to-door solicitors accosted my *in my garage* and refused to take me off their sales list without my phone number and information on my current service.
If I wasn't so addicted to the internet, I'd go without TV/broadband just to avoid dealing with Comcast. All that said, I can empathize with that woman. A well-placed call to the local TV station probably would have been a better way to get things resolved.
@shad0ws: I believe that the person in question there had a 3 year warranty, and then extended it when it ran out. But Dell would not honor the extended warranty.
@mavrc: "....or so overwhelmingly downtrodden that we don't care anymore."
I'd agree with that observation, especially as many corporate entities (and lack of true competition in some marketplaces) have allowed poor and shoddy customer service policies AND procedures to foster as such.
I support this woman. All corporations really care about is your money and getting even more of it from you. This doesn't really surprise me or any of us. However, when companies like this "rob" us of time and money with their Byzantine rules and regulations they should expect a reaction. So boo hoo for the poor scared employees. They are nothing more than accomplices to the criminal entity of the company. Maybe they should start looking for a better job, work at improving their company's image, or maybe start doing their jobs in some cases.
@sonichghog: ... um. huh??
all i was saying was that article i linked, from Consumerist about a month back, was one of the first points where i noticed this blog getting really... irksome... about its anti-corporate stance. "waaaah! the big bad corporation should never ever ever be right!"
& this is clearly another example of same. viz.: old lady does what would qualify *anywhere else* as "fucked up shit", and the Consumerist cheers it on. not cool. i mean, i'm all about consumers rights. but not the right of consumers to fix their issues with a hammer.
the first article made me think Consumerist was going in a direction i didn't really care for. this article confirms it.
(& btw---the "first article" in question was some whining about -Apple- failing to repair a computer after seven years. nothing to do with Dells or warranties. not sure where that came from...)
It's easy to say there were more civil solutions, but we're all humans here. If I go to the pound and start teasing and kicking the dogs, its a good bet that at least one of them is going to eventually snap and attack me.
I'm just surprised with the way companies treat their customers these days that this doesn't happen more often.
Totally agree with VEX. I have ALWAYS advocated that front line employees are just doing their jobs and most of the time it's not their fault that corporate policies force unsavory solutions. However, my stance is starting to change. If this is the only way that customer service can get better, then that's the way it has to be. It's unfortunate.
@ArtDonovansLoveChild.: If you read the article, the employees had EVERYTHING to do with her complaint.
@vex: "If I go to the pound and start teasing and kicking the dogs, its a good bet that at least one of them is going to eventually snap and attack me."
I like that analogy! Gold star of the day.
@Mike_: I got a customer satisfaction survey call the other day. I gave them 4/5 on cable quality and 2/5 on internet service quality. They offered to transfer me to tech service. I said don't bother. I'm switching to FIOS as soon as I can.
BTW, my digital cable and internet were out this morning and I couldn't even get into the complaint queue, so my answers today would have been lower.
@ArtDonovansLoveChild.: The employees had her cool her heels outside in the summer heat for several hours and then told her the manager left for the day without seeing her. A hammer is the simplest weapon deserving of that reaction.
Oh great, an article praising a crazy woman who terrified a bunch of staff. Now there are going to be countless people who'll feel that they have a right to get aggressive whenever they get feel they've got bad customer service.
I have no time for anyone who gets aggressive at customer service people and the fact she used a weapon makes her a common criminal in my mind. Who cares if she paid for the damage, she still threatened people with a weapon. A blow to the head with a hammer will probably crack the skull and possibly kill or result in major brain damage.
I don't care if Comcast have bad customer service, if Ghandi can topple a government without violence and MLK can revolutionise a country's policy on race then you can find a way to deal with bad customer service other than scaring the hell out of £5.50 an hour employees.
















Woman assualts office equipment, terrorizes employees who had NOTHING to do with her complaint and shes a fucking hero now? This deserves a bad consumer tag. You do realize that all she did was add cost to the company and make the employees LESS likely to help people in the future?