Rite Aid Selling Smoke Machine Fuel Containing Antifreeze
Rite Aid is selling antifreeze-laced fog juice, the substance that is atomized and turned into a gas by smoke machines, isn't terribly concerned, reports reader Jennifer.
Instructions available on making your own smoke machine fuel specifically forbid using ethylene glycol, as it is a deadly poison. You remember your mother teaching you how it's bad to turn a poisonous liquid into a gas, right?
The distributor, Harry at First Imperial Trading Company, told Jennifer that ethylene glycol was a "harmless food additive." (He somehow must have it confused with propylene glycol...)
When Jennifer contacted the CPSC, they referred it to Rite Aid, who referred it back to the manufacturer. The local Rite Aid, however, did agree to take the bottles off the shelves, but what of the 5,000 other Rite Aids?
Post a comment
Comments:
@alice_bunnie: Yeah, but you don't atomize and inhale cleaners or automotive fluids. If I were to buy fog juice, I'd like to buy the sort that I don't need to hold my breath around. Call me crazy.
Fog machines creep me out anyway, but I think this needs a little more research. Yes it's poisonous, but the sources talk about ingesting it. Now I'm not saying breathing it is a good thing, but its concentration might not be that bad. Kinda like standing in a bus terminal huffing diesel fumes: you know it can't be good, but you're not in it all day.
But you gotta love this from wikipedia:
If one has ingested ethylene glycol, give the person an alcoholic beverage while the paramedics arrive.
That's my kinda poison!
All the movie fog machines run on juice containing this chemical. We do breath it all day at times and the result is many-fold. 1. Black snot- I always have black residue, almost like soot, in my nostrils and coating my buggers, which are also more plentiful. 2. My throat hurts, like I'm coming down with a cold. 3. My eyes burn. 4. I get a headache.
We are supposed to be able to go outside and get fresh air intermittently, and although nobody would ever say you couldn't if you just got up a left, it is often very difficult to do so because we'd never finish the day. I've been in small spaces with this stuff for 12 hrs and I'm sure it is very bad for your health.
@e10: AH! I have always wondered what was in that stuff. I used to work in nightclubs and they pump the fake smoke like there is no tomorrow. I used to have the exact same symptoms plus a giant headache the next day after spending 10 hours in a club so smokey you couldn't see 20 feet away.
I was pretty sure the fake smoke was the reason I always felt so horrible after work but now I am sure that was the culprit.
This is off of the MSDS ([www.jtbaker.com]):
Inhalation:
Vapor inhalation is generally not a problem unless heated or misted. Exposure to vapors over an extended time period has caused throat irritation and headache. May cause nausea, vomiting, dizziness and drowsiness. Pulmonary edema and central nervous system depression may also develop. When heated or misted, has produced rapid, involuntary eye movement and coma.
Hmm, coma doesn't sound good. How did this stuff get to market? It sounds like short term exposure is Ok, but longer term isn't great.
@alice_bunnie: You're not supposed to breathe it, either. Tell me- would you leave a bottle with no safety cap labeled "halloween juice" where children could reach it? It only takes a few swigs to kill a child.
E10, unless you are working on a non union set, you should report that stuff to IATSE. Chemical fog in a closed environment has been against union regulations for a couple of decades. That stuff can KILL you. That doesn't stop lots of folks from using it in haunted houses, etc., but on a closed set, you should be protected.
As for the consumer, tell her to find a local dry ice perveyor. It's not too expensive and WAY cooler.
The entertainment industry is finally starting to move away from this nasty fog stuff. On my last show, we stopped using the disgusting DF-50, which uses some oily stuff that makes people ill and makes a mess everywhere, to the Look Solutions hazers/foggers, which use a "water-based solution", which I'm understanding is better. If I weren't on dialup, I'd go lookup the MSDS's for the two and compare.
BY TEREKKINCAID AT 09/05/07 11:14 PM
This is off of the MSDS ([www.jtbaker.com]):
Inhalation:
Vapor inhalation is generally not a problem unless heated or misted.
...that's pretty funny because that is exactly what foggers do! They heat up the fog juice to create an atomized mist. You aren't inhaling the "vapor" --the gaseous form of ethylene glycol--it's the liquid in a fine mist you are breathing in!
@ KMCCOY AT 12:53 AM
The propylene glycol foggers are, for some reason, sometimes referred to as "water based" foggers--as opposed to mineral oil based ones. Both kinds of foggers work the same way, they just use different fog juice.
Hopefully, the water based hazers your productions will use in the future are the fairly rare "real fog" water based fog generators.
Probably the best government response I've ever heard of, and testament to the dangers of diethlyene glycol:
@Alvis: That story is about another ingredient in this Fog Juice, diethylene glycol - not ethylene glycol. Looking at the ingredients, it also includes triethylene glycol.
Diethlyene glycol doesn't seem as dangerous per the MSDS [www.jtbaker.com]
and Triethylene glycol doesn't appear to pose any significant risk in vapor form.
[www.jtbaker.com]
@jblake1: The MSDS for ethylene glycol states that "Vapor inhalation is generally not a problem unless heated or misted." [emphasis mine] Blanket statements like "most things are dangerous at high doses" are meaningless, that's why we have MSDS.
Here's the ingredient list off the Le Matire fog juice bottle I have sitting at home:
Dipropylene glycol
Water
I don't have any haze fluid left, but I know for a fact that Le Maitre's haze fluids are just glycerol & water. Reel Efx's is 100% mineral oil (nasty stuff!). I do like the look of the Reel Efx haze, but not willing to put up with that much oily residue over everything.
@Henrythoreau: Hell, I've got a tiny fog machine hidden in a fake air vent in my living room. If the alarm system goes off, it fogs the place, preventing people from stealing my nice audio & video equipment. No burglar's going to hang around when they see this whiteish/yellowish cloud of gas and loud hissing sound coming from an air vent straight at them. You also can't steal what you can't see. It also makes a nice party trick as well. I also have one of these on my back patio to deter burglars from even thinking about breaking a window.
[www.smokecloak.com] Very cool stuff.
@King of the Wild Frontier: Additionally the MSDS goes on to say "When heated or misted, has produced rapid, involuntary eye movement and coma."
I always use Froggy's Fog Swamp Juice (www.froggysfog.com) out of Cookeville, TN for my Halloween fog. I have been using them for about 6 years now with great results in my Haunted House I run here in IL. I have a copy of their MSDS which they have always been willing to send anytime I asked for one. I am very leary of FITCO and some of the other Indonesian and Chinease made stuff. When I read Froggy's MSDS I noticed that they used only Pharmaceutical or Kosher Grade (no machine grade stuff) chemicals and DI Water. They even include cas numbers in their MSDS. I actually met one of their owners at Hauntcon Convention in Detriot this year. He is an mild asthmatic who couldn't work for extended periods in store bought fog fluid (I think his family owns Laser tags and roller rinks or something like that). Anyway his dads degree was in bio-chemisty and they worked out a way to make fog that didn't make him sick. For what it is worth, my actors in my Haunt have noticed that their throat doesn't feel as dried out as it used to and I can definently say it doesn't stink with a foul oder like that other stuff we used to buy from Walmart. Check them out, they seem to be very nice, honest folks. I am happy!
Kristoff
Just this last Sunday I attended a double surprise birthday party in a small low-ceilinged room with a really foul-smelling fog machine and DJ. The 15 or so people I knew there have come down with intense headaches, sore throats, etc. One guy who was in the smoke and next to the machine for about 5 hours has been home sick since Monday and is coughing up blood. I'm not sure about the other 25 or so people...I was also effected, but not with the same intensity because I was outside as much as possible. Fog machines should have been taken off shelves for the smell alone years ago! The fog machine seemed like the most likely culprit for this outbreak and I just wish that I had come across this consumer alert earlier...















Well, you're not supposed to drink it. And, I'm sure two aisles over there's the same ingredient in the automotive aisle. I think someone doesn't understand that there are some things you don't drink. Hey, don't let her over to the cleaning aisle, she'll really freak out.