Do You Shun Friends With Other Cellphone Carriers?
The Times brings us the sad story of Brandy McDowell and Kezia Chandler, two longtime friends whose relationship was shattered when they signed up with rival cellphone companies. The prospect of free mobile-to-mobile minutes has baited many friends groups to sign up or stick with the same carrier, ruining some friendships in the process. The Times article is rife with accounts of people who lost contact with friends banished to wilderness of nights and weekends. Are you loyal to your friends or your wallet? Tell us in our poll, after the jump.
What's Good for a Business Can Be Hard on Friends [NYT]
(Photo: sirmikester)
This is a test contextual ad for the SHOPPING category. It should appear on all SHOPPING entries, unless the subcategory has its own ad.
Post a comment
Comments:
It's funny though, my fiance knows what carrier all of her friends are on. She doesn't even have to keep track of minutes or keep them to a minimum, she, for some reason, must have talked to most of her friends at some point about what carrier they have. I don't get it, but I just let her go about her way :-p
Oh well, I live in China- (in USD)2cents/min for local calls and 10cents/min for calls to the States for me (prepaid, postpaid is too much hassle for me and quite a few people here). Who cares about what carrier there's on when there's no such things as free M2M here (we have discounted M2M at 0.7cent/min but that applies to all carriers except for the PHS carrier which is treated like a landline)?
Exactly. Nothing is more tedious and inane than listening to my mom and friends discuss which plan they have and what minutes give you this and that.
Who care - I make calls, I assume the recipient is capable of handling their own cell phone arrangements.
I have Cingular and Sprint, both provided by work. So I can make mobile to mobile calls to 90% of everyone that I need to speak to for personal phone calls. My friends on Verizon are in Cali, I'm in Chicago, So by the time they get off work, my 7PM nights are kicking in (6pm on Sprint) and I'm enjoying free calls!
@HeyHermano: Hey, it works out for people like me and my bf who are both the kind who, if work or other schedules don't intrude, sleep late and stay up late. Plus, we can use instant messaging unless we really want to do a voice call, which is free any time.
If you stop talking to someone over who they use for cell service, you're not much of a friend anyway.
@yg17:
Bwerk. Have fun with that slow T-Mobile. My AT&T gets UMTS or HSDPA almost everywhere I am in NYC. T-Mobile doesn't even know what 3G is yet....
We don't tend to yack on cell phones so much, so my friends never come into the equation. My friends & I call each other over VOIP or Skype and chat endlessly. The cell phone is for "Please pick up asparagus on the way home, honey", or "the realignment on the car will be X. Is that about right?"
My husband & I share a small plan, and never exceed our minutes between the phones. I came within one minute of the total the month we were married several years ago, talking to caterers, musicians, seamstresses, and soon-to-be-in-laws.
That was the closest we ever got to the limit.
When I'm out, I want to be with the person I'm with or alone with myself, not droning on the phone.
@maevro: Don't care about 3G. AT&T sucks down here in St. Louis, by far the worst carrier I have ever used. I don't give a shit about fast speeds, I care about being able to make and receive calls.
I'm surprised people even know the difference. I can't count how many times as a csr a customer would say "What do you mean mobile-mobile doesn't include all mobile phones?".
All kidding aside, companies are on to this anyway with altels circle, tmobiles myfaves(scam), etc. Get a plan like that and it won't matter. Also, most cell phone plans aren't exactly designed for hours of talk time daily. You wouldn't believe how many 1000's of minutes some people will go over on a 1000 min plan, and at $0.40/min where I worked, could cost over $1000, and some even gladly pay it.
I don't expect my friends to call me on their cells. They can IM, e-mail, drop-by, etc. I know how expensive it can be. Also, there's this great, much cheaper invention for local calls, its called a pay-phone.
@yg17: My AT&T Razr works fine here in STL. All networks have good spots and dead spots and some phones are in general better than others. Variation's normal.
My boyfriend and I both have Cingular. When we signed on, we were under the impression that we would have free member-to-member (M2M) minutes. However, we later found out that our specific plans don't include M2M, so we don't get to call each other for free.
Fortunately, we have enough minutes to where we don't have a problem going over. Still, I felt misled when I found out the truth.
First, it's not important exactly what carrier your friends are on; it's only important to know if they're on your carrier. Your itemized phone bill will tell you this, so it's not like a ridiculous conversation has to ensue to find out.
I would never damage a friendship over something trivial like this. Period. However, I will call people in a different order to put M2M calls first (ie before 6PM) and others later. No need to waste minutes unnecessarily, even though I have plenty.
First, I admit that I do know at least some of my friends companies, but it's not a huge issue. My phone plan has 5 lines and rollover minutes (yeah cingular, I mean AT&T...). We honestly rarely use all our minutes and every month we lose a handful of rollover ones (which doesn't matter, cause we just add more). According to my mother (the official name on the bill, I pay it straight to her) the last time we used all of our minutes was just over 2 years ago when I got married.
Now, text messages we've gone over more than I like to think about, but we usually find a plan that better works and change (example: for awhile, my husband would go over mostly because we were texting each other and both our accounts would get dinged for both messages. We then changed his account so that he had unlimited messaging to cingular customers and 1000 to everyone else, which is many of his friends).
I have never even thought about losing a friendship over something as dumb as cell phone carriers...
i shun all of you that have cell phones and it is not a necessity of you making a living. specifically you, the on the phone driver, who can't drive anyway, but for good measure is completely preoccupied chatting about your latest ring tone to your friend, whom you are currently on the road to see in five minutes.
Good lord. The only time I EVER cared was when it came up as a discussion for work and the coworker-friend was looking for a new carrier. They didn't like the one I had. I left the discussion.
Jeez. With text messaging, email, instant messaging, and social networking sites, how wouldn't you stay in contact with them?
First of all, I am one of them and we still contact. The article states, and I repeat, "they don't talk on the phone as much." We have to communicate by other means. It's not about being cheap. It's about being smart. You can always use your home phone, IM, or visit, etc. I shouldn't have to pay $250 a month b/c I don't want to communicate in other ways! So who will be the loser when you check your cell phone bill and it's more than your car payment? Thanks, I have my answer.





















Shunning them would mean I would have to ask what carrier they have and that in itself is too much work. I just try to keep my minutes down in general without paying attention to which carrier I'm calling.