What's Your Perspective On HSBC Anal Rapage?
Apropos, we suppose, of HSBC's ineffectual customer service, and their recent, "What's your perspective?" campaign, here is some of that vaunted user-generated content.
The internet is magical. Bringing companies and consumers closer than ever before. — BEN POPKEN
HSBC [Maulleigh's Place]
Post a comment
Comments:
Umm...posts like this make me unable to recommend Consumerist to friends and family. Way too over the top.
Is this supposed to be the photo of "BBB bends over like a tranny pre-op saving up for surgery."--another way too over the top analogy by the esteemed editor. I'm thinking anal sex humor is a an area where excess is far too easy to do. Wonkette can pull it off, but I'm pretty sure this thread doesn't.
This is so incredibly far from being funny or relevant. I usually love Consumerist but the fact that you're making light of rape (or at least giving your real estate to somebody's idiotic joke) is mortifying.
Oh, wait. Is it okay because the woman in the photo looks like a porn star? If she looked like your next door neighbor would you still post this?
I appreciate Consumerist's edginess but I'm not sure who you're trying to reach with this garbage.
WMeredith took the words out of my mouth. This isn't Consumer Reports (thank God), and Ben isn't John Stossel. The Consumerist has certainly enjoyed a higher profile thanks to 20/20 and the like, but the newer readers and commenters here have no real appreciation of the ironic, snarky, dark humor that this site was built on.
You can be pro-consumer and still have a twisted laugh now and then. (Heck, you have to.)
FWIW, I thought the Gawkeresque Wal*Mart gallery was a brilliant piece, too.
What del_ruby said. That's just plain ugly, to say nothing of the way it plays into the patriarchy. By portraying violence against women this way, even if it's "just for laffs," you're perpetuating it and making it even more socially acceptable than it is. Doesn't matter that the tone is "everyone gets raped by banking here" - just look at that image.
I'm not easily offended and I have a pretty sick sense of humor but, ugh. This sucks.
I have never been a fan of using the word "rape" in a financial context. Interestingly enough, though, women and men can be anally raped. So I guess it's equal-opportunity violence. Still not terribly funny, though.
This isn't Consumer Reports (thank God), and Ben isn't John Stossel.
Thank God Ben isn't John Stossel, because John Stossel is damned annoying.
I love all of the "woo, look at us, we're so edgy" comments. It kind of reminds me of the "We're punk rock and you're Guy Lombardo" moment on firedoglake, which incidentally is the exact moment that I stopped reading firedoglake.
WRT the image itself: Not as bad as the ads that I've seen on some (non-sex-related) sites, and I suspect that most of us have started riding the scroll wheel when we surf at work, anyway. But I really have to speculate about the employment status of people who can't see what the fuss is all about.
newer readers and commenters here have no real appreciation of the ironic, snarky, dark humor that this site was built on.
Actually, I am a long time reader and commenter who finds this shit pretty offensive... the ongoing problem is that Ben (and some readers) don't know the difference between "dark humor" or "snark" and truly offensive comparisons.
It's a shame, because the Consumerist has such incredible potential to be a truly great site. And since my ongoing bitching in the comments doesn't work, I'm off to right a strongly worded letter to the Gawker overlords.
A facetious depiction of anal rape (any sort of rape, in fact), is funny? Really?
I found it tasteless and obnoxious, but I guess I'm just a humourless dinosaur who doesn't think that trivialising rape is worth my chuckle.
So what if this is the internet? This blog is usually an intelligent and sensitive defender of basic consumer rights with an irreverent edge, but juvenile jokes like this undermine the blog's authority and its reader's respect for it.
If Walmart sold a t-shirt trivialising rape this blog would be high-horsing like crazy. So for Mr Popken, Nazi t-shirts and homophobic landscapers are bad, but depictions of rape and homophobic jokes are not.
But hey, fuck it. Let's go to town on the "edgy" humour angle. Lets revise the easy-bake oven post with an edgy and irreverent child abuse joke. Let's go back to the child's porn-filled laptop and throw in an "ironic" paedophilia punchline or two? That would be a total laff-riot.
The only two issues I have is one, I usually read from work like many others.
The second issue I have is that I couldnt find any story here. I am interested in the story, if there is one, because I am currently attempting to open an account with HSBC and I would like to know why banking with HSBC is akin to getting analy raped.
I swear...some people have no sense of humor. This ain't your grandparents' site.
All the snarky content on this blog would make my mother blush. That's why I read it!
Actually, I read it because it is brilliantly informed and addictive and a must read for those who don't know how to handle greedy, blood sucking corporations.
Trust me. I lived in England for a long time and the companies there make the ones here look like freaking Mother Theresa's convent.
Don't get cheesed off because a headline or picture offends you. You are one. We are many. Get over it. Grow up.
This bloody puritanical, Bible lovin' country needs to know that not all things are within 'acceptable' boundaries. So what????
Get. Over. It.
mojohealy writes:
AcilletaM: good memory. This blog has indeed taken the high ground on rape analogies before.
Indeed. The post states:
Yesterday, Ben and I received an email from Bruce C. ...On the one hand, Bruce C. seemed to have a quasi-legitimate gripe, and we admired its clearness and tersity. On the other hand... holy crap! Did Bruce just play the rape card?
However, note that the anti-"rape card" post was not penned by Ben. Also note that all of the comments were 'yeah, right on for calling him on pulling the rape card.' not 'hey, lighten up.' the way many of the comments in this thread are leaning...
So, WTF is going on now???
It's all done in humour. I am Irish, and it doesn't bother me in the least when people make jokes about drunkin Irishmen. I often go around calling myself a balding fat Mick for Christ's sake. Damn. Like I said, as repeated from another equally intelligent blogger, thin skinned wussies.
The thread isn't advocating anal rape, it is just associating the adverse affects of Corporate America and what it metaphorically does to the consumer.
People just take too much stuff way too seriously. If you get that upset about a humerous webpage, then perhaps you should ask [Comcast] to disconnect you.
Ever see "All in the Family"? Was that offensive as well? That show was chock full of racial/homosexual stereotypes, yet funny as hell.
I don't get what is so difficult to understand about that and why people get so damn uppity.
The users here have been supportive of defending Consumerist of 'porn' charges. Why would you post material this tasteless and dumb? Some immature people find 'tubgirl' pictures funny, that doesn't mean that anyone wants to see them.
The most annoying thing about this post is the complete lack of ANY real content about the subject. What about HSBC? Is this The Consumerist or Hustler Humor?
How was this useful or necessary?



























dude, so not a work safe image.